Influence of Reaction Conditions on Catalyst Behavior during the
Early Stages of Gas Phase Ethylene Homo- and Copolymerization
Estevan Tioni,
†,‡
Jean Pierre Broyer,
†
Vincent Monteil,*
,†
and Timothy McKenna*
,†
†
Universite ́ de Lyon, Univ. Lyon 1, CPE Lyon, CNRS, UMR 5265 Laboratoire de Chimie Catalyse Polyme ̀ res et Proce ́ de ́ s (C2P2),
LCPP team, Bat 308F, 43 Bd du 11 novembre 1918, F-69616 Villeurbanne, France
‡
Dutch Polymer Institute DPI, P.O. Box 902, 5600 AX Eindhoven, The Netherlands
ABSTRACT: A packed bed stopped flow minireactor (3 mL) suitable for performing gas phase polymerizations of olefins has
been used to study the initial phases of ethylene homo- and copolymerization with two supported metallocene catalysts. The
reactor can be used to perform gas phase polymerizations at times as short as 100 ms under industrially relevant conditions. It has
been used to follow the evolution of the rate of polymerization, the gas phase temperature (and indirectly the particle
temperature), and the polymer properties (molecular weight distribution, melting temperature, and crystallinity) for the two
catalysts. It is shown that polymerization activity during the first 2-5 s of reaction can be up to 20 times higher than what is
measured at longer polymerization times. The main consequence is the release of a significant amount of heat due to the rapid
reaction that has to be efficiently evacuated in order to avoid particle overheating and melting. It has been seen that insufficient
heat removal can strongly influence the behavior of the active sites, eventually leading to uncontrolled transfer reactions and
polymers with unusually broad molecular weight distributions (MWD). It is also observed that the kinetic behavior of the two
types of catalyst is similar at short times. Finally, some influence of particle size on reaction rate and molecular weight is observed
between the largest and smallest catalyst particle cuts.
1. INTRODUCTION
The annual production of polyethylene (PE) and polypropy-
lene (PP) in processes using supported catalysts is likely to be
close to 90 million at the current time.
1
This process, which has
been used commercially since the 1950s is clearly commercially
significant and has been the object of many industrial and
academic studies far too numerous to cite here. However,
despite the intense research efforts that have been made in the
past 5 decades, there remains much to understand about these
processes. In particular, the events surrounding the trans-
formation of the catalyst particle into a growing polymer
particle still need to be better understood.
2
The most common types of catalyst supports used in olefin
polymerization are magnesium dichloride for Ziegler-Natta
(ZN) catalysts, and silica which is used to support chromium
oxide and metallocene active sites (although hybrid supports of
MgCl
2
on silica are used for certain types of ZN catalysts). Both
types of support have a high surface area and porosity that
allow for the deposition of a large number of active sites
throughout the structure, and both types of support undergo
physical transformations as soon as they are injected into the
reactor. It can be said that the nature of the steps by which the
particles of supported catalyst are transformed into growing
polymer particles is certainly understood from a qualitative
point of view: once the virgin catalyst particles are injected into
the reactor, monomer diffuses from the bulk phase and begins
to react at the active sites on the surface of the catalyst support.
Polymer then quickly accumulates, generating pressure
throughout the particle and provoking a local fragmentation
of the support. Once the fragmentation step is complete, the
resulting particle (now referred to as a polymer particle) will
continue to grow as long as monomer arrives at the active sites.
For a more in-depth discussion of the process of catalyst
fragmentation and growth, the reader is referred to earlier
reviews from our group, as well as the references therein.
2,3
The fragmentation step is quite short with respect to the
average residence time of the reactor; fractions of a second up
to several tens of seconds, depending on the type of support
and reaction conditions, versus 1-3 h, respectively. Despite the
almost negligible amount of time the fragmentation and initial
growth phases take with respect to the length of an industrial
reaction, it is at this point that the most extreme changes in
particle morphology occur, that the production of fines due to
an abrupt particle fragmentation is likely, and when severe
overheating of the particles can be a significant problem. Given
that the rates of mass transfer into the particles and heat
transfer out of the particles are strongly dependent on the
morphology (pore network, pore size, pore volume, and
especially particle size), this can be also the time range in which
the temperature and concentration values inside the catalyst
particle can vary most abruptly. For instance, strong
concentration gradients can lead to different parts of the
particle core expanding more rapidly than others, with
consequences as extreme as the production of hollow
particles.
4,5
Excessive temperature gradients in the boundary
layer (temperature profile inside the particle is known to be less
important
6,7
) can lead to polymer melting and reaction
extinction.
Received: June 25, 2012
Revised: October 14, 2012
Accepted: October 18, 2012
Published: October 18, 2012
Article
pubs.acs.org/IECR
© 2012 American Chemical Society 14673 dx.doi.org/10.1021/ie301682u | Ind. Eng. Chem. Res. 2012, 51, 14673-14684