1
Early Literacy of Kindergartners With
Hearing Impairment
The Role of Mother-Child Collaborative Writing
Dorit Aram
Tova Most
Adi Ben Simon
Tel Aviv University
The study assessed the value of maternal writing mediation in predicting children’s early literacy. Thirty kindergartners with hearing
impairment (HI) and their mothers participated. Mothers were videotaped at home while helping their children write words, and the
children’s early literacy was assessed in the kindergarten. Maternal writing mediation was analyzed in terms of its cognitive and emo-
tional aspects. Results show that beyond the child’s age and his or her degree of hearing loss, the cognitive aspects of maternal writ-
ing mediation predicted word writing (11%), word recognition (34%), and letter knowledge (35%). Beyond the background measures,
the emotional aspects of the mediation predicted word recognition (12%), letter knowledge (14%), and general knowledge (9%).
Discussion focuses on writing interactions as a context of early literacy development among kindergartners with HI.
Keywords: joint writing; kindergartners; deaf/hearing impaired; parent-child interaction; early literacy; phonology
T
he study examined the context of early literacy
development among kindergartners with hearing
impairment (HI), focusing on the role of mother-child
collaborative writing. Success in acquiring literacy skills
offers one of the central keys to scholastic achievement. Yet
for many children with HI, reading and writing pose great
difficulty (e.g., Howell & Luckner, 2003; Musselman,
2000), and progress in the literacy domain is extremely
slow (Harris & Beech, 1998; Kyle & Harris, 2005;
Marschark & Harris, 1996).
Studies of reading acquisition in children with HI have
reported that their language skills, phonological awareness,
and language comprehension in kindergarten predicted
reading progress in first grade (Colin, Magnan, Ecalle, &
Leybaert, 2004; Harris & Beech, 1998). The evidence
regarding continuity in literacy achievements invites
research to tease apart possible sources of these differences
in early literacy among young children with HI.
Reading tasks require the same acquisition of skills
whether a child is hearing or deaf (Luetke-Stahlman &
Nielsen, 2003). Research on hearing children that has
examined the issue of continuity in the transition from
kindergarten to school has emphasized the role of alpha-
betic skills and phonological awareness in kindergarten
as chief predictors of decoding accuracy, reading flu-
ency, and reading comprehension at the beginning of
school (e.g., Badian, 2001; Ehri, Nunes, Willows,
Yaghoub-Zadeh, & Shanahan, 2001; Stern & Goswami,
2000). Compared with the wide volume of studies on
hearing children’s early literacy development, only a few
investigators have described the development of early lit-
eracy in young children with HI (Williams, 2004).
Nevertheless, some data have indicated that beyond the
language delay, which is a hallmark of hearing loss
(Musselman, 2000), kindergartners with HI lag behind in
alphabetic skills, such as letter naming, word identifica-
tion, and word writing (e.g., Mayer, 2007; Most, Aram,
& Andorn, 2006), as well as in phonological awareness
(e.g., Allman, 2002, Colin et al., 2004) relative to their
hearing peers.
Williams (2004) reviewed the literature on early liter-
acy in children with HI and concluded that their literacy
development comprises a naturally emerging process
that can parallel that of hearing children, given support-
ive literacy environments. However, researchers have
asserted that children with HI experience less exposure
than hearing children to such adult-child literacy-related
interactions prior to entering school (Luetke-Stahlman,
1999; Marschark, 1993; Williams, 1994).
Observations in homes of young hearing children
revealed that children are engaged in writing interactions
with their parents. They pretend to write in their parents’
Topics in Early Childhood
Special Education
Volume XX Number X
Month XXXX xx-xx
© 2008 Hammill Institute on
Disabilities
10.1177/0271121408314627
http://tecse.sagepub.com
hosted at http://online.sagepub.com