Psychodynamic Therapy from the Perspective of
Self-organization. A Concept of Change and a
Methodological Approach for Empirical Examination
Antje Gumz,
1
*
Michael Geyer
2
and Elmar Brähler
3
1
Department of Psychosomatic Medicine and Psychotherapy, University Medical Center Hamburg-Eppendorf,
Hamburg, Germany
2
Academy for Psychotherapy Erfurt, Erfurt, Germany
3
Department of Medical Psychology and Medical Sociology, University of Leipzig, Leipzig, Germany
Observations from therapeutic practice and a series of empirical findings, for example, those on discontinuous
change in psychotherapeutic processes, suggest modelling the therapeutic process as a self-organizing system
with stable and critical instable phases and abrupt transitions. Here, a concept of psychotherapeutic change is
presented that applies self-organization theory to psychodynamic principles. The authors explain the observa-
tions and considerations that form the basis of the concept and present some connections with existing find-
ings and concepts. On the basis of this model, they generated two hypotheses regarding the co-occurrence of
instability and discontinuous change and the degree of synchrony between the therapist and patient. A study
design to test these hypotheses was developed and applied to a single case (psychodynamic therapy). After each
session, patient and therapist rated their interaction. A measure of instability was calculated across the resulting
time series. Sequences of destabilization were observed. On the basis of points of extreme instability, the pro-
cess was divided into phases. Local instability maxima were accompanied by significant discontinuous change.
Destabilization was highly synchronous in therapist and patient ratings. The authors discussed the concept and
the methodological procedure. The approach enables the operationalization of crises and to empirically assess
the significance of critical phases and developments within the therapeutic relationship. Copyright © 2013 John
Wiley & Sons, Ltd.
Key Practitioner Message:
• We present a concept of change that applies self-organization theory to psychodynamic therapy.
• We empirically tested the hypotheses formulated in the concept based on an extract of 125 long-term
psychodynamic therapy sessions. We continuously monitored the therapeutic interaction and calculated
a measure of the instability of the assessments.
• We identified several sequences of stable and unstable episodes. Episodes of high instability were
accompanied by discontinuous change. On the basis of these episodes of high instability, we divided
the process into four phases. Mean values of variables differed across these phases.
• Destabilization proved to be highly synchronous in therapist and patient ratings.
• The approach allows to empirically assess critical phases and developments within the therapeutic relationship.
Keywords: Psychotherapeutic Process, Psychodynamic Therapy, Discontinuous Change, Instability, Synchrony
THEORETICAL BACKGROUND
Observations from Therapeutic Practice—How Does
Change Occur?
From a clinical perspective, psychodynamic therapy pro-
cesses are complex acts that are not easily decomposed into
individual components. At the onset of therapy, prognoses
regarding course and outcome can only be made to a
very limited extent. While certain conjectures follow-
ing performance of a biographical anamnesis may be
likely to show a high degree of accuracy, the way in
which the specific pattern of the therapeutic relationship
develops and changes ultimately depends on a variety of
different influences and interactions. If we assume that there
are only direct causal associations between therapeutic
interventions and improvements in patients’ mental or phys-
ical symptoms, then we fail to appreciate the complexity of
the therapeutic process. In therapeutic practice, a good inter-
vention does not necessarily lead to positive change in a
*Correspondence to: Antje Gumz, Department of Psychosomatic
Medicine and Psychotherapy, University Medical Center Hamburg-
Eppendorf, Hamburg, Germany.
E-mail: Antje.Gumz@web.de
Clinical Psychology and Psychotherapy
Clin. Psychol. Psychother. (2013)
Published online in Wiley Online Library (wileyonlinelibrary.com). DOI: 10.1002/cpp.1840
Copyright © 2013 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.