Energy Conversion Options for Advanced Radioisotope
Power Systems
Mohamed S. El-Genk
Institute for Space and Nuclear Power Studies and Chemical and Nuclear Engineering Department
The University of New Mexico, Albuquerque, NM, 8713
(505) 277 - 5442, mgenk@unm.edu
Abstract. Static and dynamic energy conversion technologies for Advanced Radioisotope Power Systems (ARPSs) are
reviewed and their impact on the system's total mass and specific electrical power and the amount of
238
PuO
2
fuel
needed for the heat source are assessed and compared. Conversion technologies considered are Segmented and
cascaded Thermoelectric, Alkali-Metal Thermal-to-Electric Conversion, and Free Piston Stirling Engines (FPSEs) and,
for comparison, SiGe thermoelectric. Estimates for a 100 We ARPS indicate that when using SiGe thermoelectric,
operating between 1273 K and 573 K, 8 General Purpose Heat Source (GPHS) modules would be required and the
system's specific power is ~ 4.6 We/kg. Using STE converters, operating between 973 K and 373 K, 5 GPHS modules
are required and the ARPS's specific power is ~ 7.28 We/kg. The next generation STE converters that could operate
between 1273 K and 573 K, for a projected system efficiency of 13.8%, decrease the number of GPHS modules needed
to 4 and increase the system's specific power to ~ 9.9 We/kg. With cascaded SiGe-STE converters, operating between
1273 K and 373 K, the system's efficiency could be as much as 16%, requiring only 3 GPHS modules, for an estimated
specific power of 10.7 We/kg. This specific power is more than twice that for SOA RTG. With the current version 1.0
of FPSEs, the 100 We ARPS needs only two GPHS modules, but its specific power (4.1 we/kg) is slightly lower than
that of SOA RTG (4.6 We/kg). Future introduction of versions 1.1 and 2.0 engines, with slightly higher conversion
efficiency and significantly lower mass, could increase the system's specific power to ~ 7.5 We/kg, using the same
number of GPHS modules as version 1.0 engines. With Na-AMTEC and K-AMTEC, the 100 We ARPS needs 3 and 4
GPHS modules, respectively, for an estimated specific power of 5.3 and 5.8 We/kg, respectively.
INTRODUCTION
The recent NASA Nuclear Space Initiative (NSI) aims at advancing the conversion technologies for future
Advanced Radioisotope Power Systems (ARPSs) in the 100 - 200 We power levels. These ARPSs are enabling for
deep space missions and long-duration surface and subsurface exploration of Mars and other planets in the solar
system. Going beyond Mars, solar illumination is nil, making the mass and size of a solar power system
prohibitively large to be practical. For some surface and subsurface missions, ARPSs could also offer the option of
full retention of the helium gas generated by radioactive decay of the
238
Pu isotope fuel (El-Genk and Tournier, 2002
and 2003). The current State-Of-The-Art (SOA) Radioisotope Thermoelectric Generators (RTGs) with SiGe
thermoelectric converters have served the U.S. space exploration program very well during more than three decades
(Carpenter, 1970; Schock, 1980; and Bennet, Lombardo, and Rick, 1987). However, in order to reduce the cost of
future deep space missions and the amount of
238
PuO2 fuel needed, ARPSs need to be lighter and more efficient than
SOA RTGs. In order to realize the objectives of the NASA NSI, successful conversion technologies for future
ARPSs are those able to demonstrate the system's efficiencies > 10%, and at the same time result in the system's
specific powers > 8 We/kg.
During the next 5 years, NASA's NSI will provide for the advanced development of promising conversion
technologies capable of: (a) increasing the specific powers of ARPRs to twice that of SOA RTGs (~4.5 We/kg, Fig
1.); and (b) demonstrating system's conversion efficiencies that are 2 to 4 that of SOA RTG (~5.7%). Energy
conversion technologies currently being considered include Segmented Thermoelectric (STE) (Caillat et al., 1999
and 2000; El-Genk and Saber, 2002; and El-Genk, Saber, and Caillat, 2002) (Figs. 2 and 3), Alkali Metal Thermal-
To-Electric Conversion (AMTEC) (Cole, 1983; El-Genk and Tournier, 1998, 2002; Tournier and El-Genk, 1999;
Hendricks, Huang, and Huang, 1999; and El-Genk and King, 2001), and Free Piston Stirling Engines (FPSEs)
(Dochat, 1992; Wong et al., 1992; Schreiber, 2001; and Thieme, Schreiber, and Mason, 2002). These energy
CP654, Space Technology and Applications International Forum-STAIF 2003, edited by M.S. El-Genk
© 2003 American Institute of Physics 0-7354-0114-4/03/$20.00
368