PII S0360-3016(99)00525-8
CLINICAL INVESTIGATION Prostate
TEMPORAL RESOLUTION OF URINARY MORBIDITY FOLLOWING
PROSTATE BRACHYTHERAPY
GREGORY S. MERRICK, M.D.,*
²
WAYNE M. BUTLER,PH.D.,* JONATHAN H. LIEF,PH.D.,*
‡
AND
ANTHONY T. DORSEY, M.S.*
*Schiffler Oncology Center, Wheeling Hospital, Wheeling, WV;
²
Division of Radiation Oncology & Biophysics, George Washington
University Medical Center, Washington, DC;
‡
Wheeling Jesuit University, Wheeling, WV
Purpose: To report the short-term urinary morbidity for prostate brachytherapy patients without a preimplant
history of a transurethral resection of the prostate gland and who received prophylactic and prolonged
-blockers. -blockers may decrease radiation-induced urethritis and increase urinary flow. Multiple clinical
and treatment parameters were evaluated to identify factors associated with increased acute urinary morbidity.
Materials and Methods: One hundred seventy consecutive patients without a prior history of a transurethral
resection of the prostate gland underwent transperineal ultrasound guided prostate brachytherapy for clinical
T1c-T3a carcinoma of the prostate gland. For all patients, an -blocker was initiated prior to implantation and
continued at least until the international prostate symptom score (IPSS) returned to baseline levels. Clinical
parameters evaluated for short-term urinary morbidity included patient age, clinical T stage, preimplant IPSS
(obtained within 3 weeks of implantation), and prostate ultrasound volume. Treatment parameters included the
utilization of neoadjuvant hormonal manipulation, the utilization of moderate dose external beam radiation
therapy before implantation, the choice of isotope, the urethral dose, the total implant activity in millicuries, and
a variety of dosimetric quality indicators (D
90
and V
100
/V
150
/V
200
). Catheter dependency and the duration of
-blocker dependency was also evaluated. On average, 11.2 IPSS surveys were obtained for each patient.
Results: One hundred fifty of the 170 patients (88.2%) had the urinary catheter permanently removed on day 0.
Only one patient required an urinary catheter for > 5 days. Two patients (1.2%) required a subsequent
transurethral resection of the prostate gland because of prolonged obstructive/irritative symptoms. To date, no
patient has developed an urinary stricture or urinary incontinence. The IPS score on average peaked at 2 weeks
following implantation. This score returned to within 1 point of the antecedent value at a median of 6 weeks and
a mean of 13.3 weeks. At 26 and 50 weeks, 85% and 56% of the patients, respectively, continued with -blockers.
Of the clinical and treatment parameters evaluated for short-term urinary morbidity, only variants of the IPSS
such as the maximum, maximum increase, and preimplant IPSS values correlated with time to return to the
referent zone with p < 0.05.
Conclusion: The return of the IPS score to baseline occurred more rapidly in our series than what has previously
been reported. The 1.2% incidence of transurethral resections also compares favorably with the published
literature. We believe these results may be due to maintaining the average urethral dose to approximately 115%
of the prescribed dose and the prophylactic and long-term use of -blockers. © 2000 Elsevier Science Inc.
Prostate brachytherapy, Urinary morbidity,
125
Iodine,
103
Palladium, -Blockers.
INTRODUCTION
Over the past decade, transperineal ultrasound guided pros-
tate brachytherapy has been increasingly utilized as defini-
tive management for early stage carcinoma of the prostate
gland. The results of prostate brachytherapy have been
reported to be as favorable as the most positive radical
prostatectomy series with a decreased incidence of urinary
incontinence and sexual dysfunction (1–5). In addition,
significant rectal injury is rare (6). A paucity of data, how-
ever, has been published regarding the short-term urinary
morbidity following prostate brachytherapy. Almost all pa-
tients experience some degree of urinary irritative/obstruc-
tive symptomatology including urinary frequency, dysuria,
urgency, interruption of the stream, incomplete voiding,
straining, and nocturia; 3%–22% of patients develop acute
urinary retention following prostate brachytherapy (4,
7–11). Terk et al. (7) were able to correlate the risk of
urinary retention with the preimplant international prostate
symptom score (IPSS). A recent controlled study concluded
that peri-operative dexamethasone does not significantly
alter short-term urinary morbidity (12).
The IPSS was developed by the American Urological
Association (AUA) in 1992 as a measure of symptomatic
relief following prostatectomy for benign prostatic hyper-
trophy. The generated score resulted in excellent test-retest
Reprint requests to: Gregory S. Merrick, M.D., Schiffler Oncol-
ogy Center, Wheeling Hospital, 1 Medical Park, Wheeling, WV
26003-6300; E-Mail: oncology@hgo.net
Accepted for publication 23 November 1999.
Int. J. Radiation Oncology Biol. Phys., Vol. 47, No. 1, pp. 121–128, 2000
Copyright © 2000 Elsevier Science Inc.
Printed in the USA. All rights reserved
0360-3016/00/$–see front matter
121