Roscoe Conkling's Wartime Cotton Speculation
Jeffrey D. Broxmeyer, University of Toledo
American Civil War catapulted a new generation of political lead-
ers into positions of influence. In New York, Roscoe Conkling was
chief among this crop of ambitious politicians and he remained a dominant
figure well into the 1880s. In the war's aftermath, and the eclipse of slav-
ery as a central issue, Conkling institutionalized the Republican Party in
the state by establishing a political machine through control over federal
patronage. Despite mastery of the spoils system, and quite unlike many of
his own political lieutenants, Conkling did not conspicuously leverage his
position to build personal wealth while holding public office.1 Yet, it would
be a mischaracterization to claim that Conkling did not profit from poli-
tics. During the war years, he used party and government connections to
discreetly make a small fortune by speculating in cotton. Previous scholars
have failed to scrutinize Conkling's participation in this quasi-legal ven-
ture. New evidence, including Federal Income Tax records, suggests that
long-hidden wartime cotton profits first established the future U.S. Senator
as a property owner. This pivota! episode deserves attention because it
sheds light on the role of private wealth accumulation in political factional-
ism, and the way that savvy Republican officeholders benefited from the
cotton policies established during President Abraham Lincoln's first term.
For Roscoe Conkling, an alliance that initially formed with partners over
wartime commerce persisted in political and business relationships well
into the Gilded Age.
l. After resignation from the U.S. Senate in 1881, however, Conkling became wealthy for the first
time in his life. He spun political influence into a successful career as a corporate lawyer and lobbyist for
railroads and other business interests. By contrast, top Conkling loyalists such as Alonzo Cornell, Chester
Arthur, and George Bliss built personal fortunes during their tenure in office. Jeffrey D. Broxmeyer,
"Politics as a Sphere of Wealth Accumulation: Cases of Gilded Age New York, 1855-1888 (PhD Diss.,
City University of New York-Graduate Center, 2014), chapter 4.
New York History Spring 2015
© 2015 by The New York State Historical Association