Methodology for Estimation of Time-Dependent Surface Heat Flux
due to Cryogen Spray Cooling
JAMES W. TUNNELL,JORGE H. T ORRES, and BAHMAN ANVARI
Department of Bioengineering, Rice University, Houston, TX
(Received 13 March 2001; accepted 1 November 2001)
Abstract—Cryogen spray cooling CSC is an effective tech-
nique to protect the epidermis during cutaneous laser therapies.
Spraying a cryogen onto the skin surface creates a time-varying
heat flux, effectively cooling the skin during and following the
cryogen spurt. In previous studies mathematical models were
developed to predict the human skin temperature profiles dur-
ing the cryogen spraying time. However, no studies have ac-
counted for the additional cooling due to residual cryogen left
on the skin surface following the spurt termination. We formu-
late and solve an inverse heat conduction IHC problem to
predict the time-varying surface heat flux both during and fol-
lowing a cryogen spurt. The IHC formulation uses measured
temperature profiles from within a medium to estimate the
surface heat flux. We implement a one-dimensional sequential
function specification method SFSM to estimate the surface
heat flux from internal temperatures measured within an in
vitro model in response to a cryogen spurt. Solution accuracy
and experimental errors are examined using simulated tempera-
ture data. Heat flux following spurt termination appears sub-
stantial; however, it is less than that during the spraying time.
The estimated time-varying heat flux can subsequently be used
in forward heat conduction models to estimate temperature
profiles in skin during and following a cryogen spurt and pre-
dict appropriate timing for onset of the laser pulse. © 2002
Biomedical Engineering Society. DOI: 10.1114/1.1432691
Keywords—Inverse heat conduction problem, Sequential func-
tion specification, Skin, Selective cooling, Epidermal protec-
tion, Heat transfer coefficient.
INTRODUCTION
Cutaneous laser therapy is based on the principle of
selective photothermolysis.
2
Light is preferentially ab-
sorbed by subsurface chromophores causing irreversible
thermal damage. Applications include port wine stain
therapy and removal of tattoos, unwanted hair, and facial
rythides. Theoretically, by choosing appropriately short
pulse durations and proper wavelength, thermal energy
remains confined to the targeted structures.
2,9,12
However,
melanin within the overlying epidermis absorbs light
over a broad spectrum.
30
This absorption of light by
melanin causes nonspecific thermal damage to the epi-
dermis and underlying dermis, clinically resulting in blis-
tering, dyspigmentation, and, rarely, hypertrophic
scarring.
1,8,11,13,15,22,23,32
Cryogen spray cooling CSC has recently been de-
veloped to selectively cool the epidermis during cutane-
ous laser therapies.
3–6,17,18
The principle of this method
is to spray the skin surface with an appropriately short
cryogen spurt on the order of tens of milliseconds im-
mediately prior to laser exposure so that only the super-
ficial skin layers are cooled while the temperature of the
deeper targeted chromophores remain unchanged. Thus,
in response to the subsequent laser pulse, the temperature
within the superficial layer remains below the threshold
for thermal damage while the targeted chromophores are
thermally destroyed.
Spraying a cryogen onto the skin surface creates a
time-varying heat flux, effectively cooling the skin dur-
ing and following the cryogen spurt. In previous studies,
mathematical models were developed to predict the hu-
man skin temperature profiles during the cryogen spurt
application time.
6,19,25,31,33
However, recent studies have
shown that the presence of the residual cryogen remain-
ing on the skin surface may result in substantial cooling
following spurt termination.
25,26,28
To properly character-
ize skin thermal response to the interactions between
CSC and laser irradiation during treatment of various
dermatologic disorders, an appropriate thermal boundary
condition needs to be used at the skin surface following
spurt application time.
Inasmuch as thermal boundary conditions such as a
time-varying heat flux are difficult to measure directly,
indirect techniques using internal temperature measure-
ments are often used.
24
With these techniques, an inverse
heat conduction problem IHCP is solved to estimate the
boundary condition from internal temperature measure-
ments.
We use the sequential function specification SFS
method
7
to solve the IHCP and estimate the surface heat
flux due to CSC. In doing so, we first analyze the accu-
racy and sensitivity of this method to measurement
Address correspondence to Bahman Anvari, Department of
Bioengineering, Rice University, P.O. Box 1892, Houston, TX 77251.
Electronic mail: anvari@rice.edu
Annals of Biomedical Engineering, Vol. 30, pp. 19–33, 2002 0090-6964/2002/301/19/15/$15.00
Printed in the USA. All rights reserved. Copyright © 2002 Biomedical Engineering Society
19