Applied Vegetation Science 15 (2012) 290–298
SPECIAL FEATURE: VEGETATION RESTORATION
Enhancing plant biodiversity in species-poor grassland
through plant material transfer – the impact of sward
disturbance
Ralf Schmiede, Annette Otte & Tobias W. Donath
Keywords
Alluvial meadows; Floodplain; Grass sward;
Grassland restoration; Hay transfer;
River Rhine
Nomenclature
Wisskirchen & Haeupler (1998)
Received 21 February 2011
Accepted 6 October 2011
Co-ordinating Editor: Thierry Dutoit
Schmiede, R. (corresponding author,
Ralf.Schmiede@umwelt.uni-giessen.de),
Otte, A. (Annette.Otte@umwelt.uni-giessen.
de) & Donath, T.W. (Tobias.W.
Donath@umwelt.uni-giessen.de): Department
of Landscape Ecology and Resource
Management, Interdisciplinary Research
Centre, Justus-Liebig-University Gießen,
Heinrich-Buff-Ring 26-32, DE-35392, Gießen,
Germany
Abstract
Questions: Is the transfer of plant material a feasible measure for the enrich-
ment of species-poor alluvial grassland? Which is the proper degree of grass
sward disturbance to enhance germination and establishment of plant material
species? Does the establishment success depend on soil nutrient status of the
restoration sites?
Location: Northern Upper Rhine valley, southwest Germany.
Methods: Seed-containing plant material was transferred to species-poor mead-
ows. We tested two methods of sward disturbance: rotovation or ploughing
before the transfer of plant material vs. a control, i.e. no disturbance but transfer
of plant material. We studied vegetation development on nine sites for 3 yr.
Results: Three years after the transfer of plant material, 101 species were suc-
cessfully re-established on the restoration sites, including 28 Red List species. In
contrast to our expectations, establishment was similar on rotovated and
ploughed plots, both harbouring higher numbers and abundances of plant mate-
rial species than the control plots. In contrast, the cover of resident grassland
species differed significantly between ploughed plots (lowest cover), rotovated
plots (intermediate cover) and control plots (highest cover) in the last 2 yr of
vegetation recording. While elevated phosphorus was in line with reduced
establishment of plant material species, potassium and total nitrogen had no
negative effect.
Conclusions: The transfer of plant material is an appropriate method to
enhance plant biodiversity in species-poor grasslands. We show that a sward dis-
turbance by rotovation or ploughing is crucial for species to re-establish. Our
results suggest that ploughing is the more promising disturbance measure
because it more persistently suppresses grassland vegetation.
Introduction
In most parts of Central Europe a serious decline in
species-rich grasslands, caused either by intensification
of land use or abandonment, has placed them as a
focus for conservation and restoration activities (Joyce
& Wade 1998). As a consequence, species-rich flood-
plain meadows are protected by the Fauna Flora Habi-
tat Directive of the European Union (Council of the
European Union 1992).
In our study area at the northern upper Rhine, Ger-
many, remnant stands of species-rich alluvial grasslands
are mostly small and fragmented (Bo ¨ger 1991). After sev-
eral major floods in the early 1980s, large areas of arable
fields in the study area were converted into grassland via
spontaneous succession and subsequent non-intensive
management for hay production (Bissels et al. 2004).
Although site conditions were favourable for the establish-
ment of species-rich plant communities, i.e. bare soil sur-
faces and a near-natural flooding regime, typical species
and plant communities of alluvial meadows did not re-
occur (Donath et al. 2003; Bissels et al. 2004). Similar to
other studies on grassland restoration (Bakker et al. 1996),
target species have not re-established due to seed and
Applied Vegetation Science
290 Doi: 10.1111/j.1654-109X.2011.01168.x © 2011 International Association for Vegetation Science