Single Embryo-Coupled Gate Field Effect Transistor for Elective
Single Embryo Transfer
Toshiya Sakata,*
,†
Akiko Saito,
†
Jinji Mizuno,
‡
Haruyo Sugimoto,
†
Kaori Noguchi,
§
Eiko Kikuchi,
§
and Hiroaki Inui
§
†
Department of Materials Engineering, School of Engineering, The University of Tokyo, 7-3-1 Hongo, Bunkyo-ku, Tokyo 113-8656,
Japan
‡
Kato Ladies Clinic, 7-20-3 Nishi-Shinzyuku, Shinzyuk-ku, Tokyo 160-0023, Japan
§
Inui Maternity Clinic, 3-5-18 Namiki, Koriyama, Fukushima 963-8026, Japan
ABSTRACT: In this study, we have proposed and demonstrated
experimentally a novel monitoring device of single mouse embryo activity
after in vitro fertilization (IVF) using a semiconductor-based field effect
transistor (FET). The FET biosensor realized to detect it noninvasively,
quantitatively, and continuously by change of hydrogen ions with positive
charges, which were induced by dissolved carbon dioxide due to cellular
respiration activity during cleavage. The electrical signal of FET biosensor
should become an effective indication to evaluate objectively single embryo
activity as its morphology is observed subjectively after IVF. The platform
based on the FET biosensor will contribute to promote elective single embryo
transfer (eSET) in human assisted reproductive technology (ART).
R
ecently, assisted reproductive technology (ART) has been
expected to be one of therapeutic methods of sterility.
Engineers other than obstetricians have been required for
assured success of ART programs. For in vitro fertilization
(IVF) of one of ART programs, how to evaluate embryo quality
and select an embryo in good condition are significant.
Morphological evaluation has been widely used to rank embryo
quality because microscopic analysis is noninvasive and useful
in predicting pregnancy rates.
1,2
However, the standard of
classification for embryo quality seems to be ambiguous among
operators because it is a subjective method. Moreover, elective
single embryo transfer (eSET) will be recommended in the
future in order to prevent a multiple pregnancy.
3
Therefore, a
novel principle to evaluate the quality of a single embryo
quantitatively and noninvasively in a real-time manner is
required for practical use in ART.
In our previous work, the respiration activity of a fertilized
ova of a sea urchin was monitored noninvasively, quantitatively,
and continuously as the change of pH by the use of the
principle of a semiconductor-based ion sensitive field effect
transistor (IS-FET).
4
The detection principle of IS-FET is
based on the potentiometric detection of charge density
changes at the gate insulator
5
and is applied for various
biosensing.
6-9
Since the gate insulator usually consists of Si
3
N
4
or Ta
2
O
5
with hydroxyl group at the surface in solutions,
furthermore, the IS-FET is sensitive to the concentration of
hydrogen ion with positive charge and should be utilized as the
pH sensor. Therefore, pH variation based on respiration
activity of the embryo will be monitored quantitatively and
noninvasively in a real-time manner using a single embryo-
coupled gate FET for eSET (eSET-FET), because pH at the
interface between the embryo and gate membrane of FET will
change sensitively according to dissolution of carbon dioxide
into medium generated by metabolism and respiration activity
in an embryo. Thus, the platform based on the eSET-FET
sensor will be valuable for the development of an evaluation
system to select a single embryo with good quality for eSET in
the future.
On the other hand, oxygen consumption has been
considered to be the parameter that provides the best
indication of overall metabolic activity of a single embryo,
10-14
although embryo metabolism has previously been assessed by
measurement of nutrient consumption, such as glucose,
pyruvate, and amino acids.
15-18
As one of the detection
methods for the evaluation of embryo quality, the electro-
chemical system is being developed. Shiku et al. reported
previously the detection concept of oxygen consumption based
on the respiration activity of an embryo.
19
In this method, the
oxygen reduction current was detected near the surface of a
single embryo using the cyclic voltammetry technique.
However, this method is unsuitable for real-time measurement
for a long-term such as cleavage of mammalian embryo.
In this paper, we propose a semiconductor-based embryo
sensing device for eSET (eSET-FET) to monitor single mouse
embryo activity based on cellular respiration in a real-time,
Received: January 11, 2013
Accepted: June 19, 2013
Published: June 19, 2013
Article
pubs.acs.org/ac
© 2013 American Chemical Society 6633 dx.doi.org/10.1021/ac4001018 | Anal. Chem. 2013, 85, 6633-6638