Virtual Repulsive Force Field Guided Coordination for
Multi-telerobot Collaboration
Nak Young Chong, Tetsuo Kotoku, Kohtaro Ohba, and Kazuo Tanie
Intelligent Systems Laboratory
National Institute of Advanced Industrial Science and Technology
1-2 Namiki, Tsukuba, Japan 305-8564
Email: nychong@ieee.org
Abstract
The Intelligent Systems Laboratory (ISL) has been
developing coordinated control technologies for multi-
telerobot collaboration in a common environment re-
motely controlled from multiple operators physically
at a distance from each other. We have built a test
bed and conducted a series of experiments, where we
learned more about how the transmission delay over
the network deteriorates the performance of telerobots.
Previously, to overcome the problems arising from the
throughput of the network such as the operator’s de-
layed visual perception, we have suggested several co-
ordination approaches in the local operator site. Like-
wise, this paper discusses the use of virtual repulsive
force field in the on-line predictive simulator to as-
sist the operator to cope with the collision between
telerobots in remote environments. In the test bed,
the operators control their master robot to get remote
telerobots to work cooperatively with the other teler-
obots in a task. Specifically, the operator detects a
priori the possibility of collision in the predictive sim-
ulator that runs in near real-time and the use of vir-
tual force field prevents the telerobots from coming into
collision. We have demonstrated various tasks by two
telerobots and two operators via an Ethernet Local
Area Network (LAN) subject to simulated communi-
cation delays and evaluated the validity of the virtual
force field guided approach in Multi-Operator-Multi-
Robot (MOMR) tele-collaboration.
1 Introduction
The current on-site work and maintenance that
usually require a lot of travel is to be substituted
for remote teleoperation over the network in a cost-
effective way. Thus, we expect that the collaborative
multi-telerobotsystemwouldbeanalternativetosup-
port the coming society in which the working popu-
lation decreases. In teleoperation with time delay, re-
motetelerobotmotionscontrolledfromlocaloperators
would be visualized with round-trip time delays, thus
the video camera image is often overlaid with graph-
ics model predicted from local master control instruc-
tions. However, in the MOMR tele-collaboration as
showninFig. 1,thetelerobotunderthecontrolofthe
counterpart operator would not be straightforwardly
predictable and accordingly the telerobots are most
probably exposed to the possibilities of collision in re-
mote environments. This seriously affects operators’
decision-making and accordingly the performance of
telerobots. Thus, to cope with the operator’s delayed
visual perception arising from the throughput of the
network,weneedtofeedanothersupplementaryinfor-
mation locally to the operator to safely steer remote
telerobots through time delay [5].
Todate,manyworkshavebeenreportedinthecon-
troloftelerobotoverthenetworkandSheridanexten-
sively reviewed them in [13]. In addition, Goldberg et
al. [7][8]builtsystemsthatallowarobottobeteleop-
eratedviatheWWW.Brady et al. [1]proposedanew
method for controlling telerobots over vast distances,
where communication propagation delays exist. But
most of the past works were applied only to a single
telerobot controlled by a single operator. Recently,
some efforts have been devoted to the teleoperation of
multiple telerobots [9], [14]. But, they did not con-
sider communication delays between local operators
with large physical separation over the network.
In this work, we have built an experimental test
bed to research the remote tele-collaboration through
timedelaybetweentwodistantoperators. Specifically,
toassisttheoperatorsufferingfromthedelayedvisual
Proceedings of the 2000 IEEE
International Conference on Robotics & Automation
Seoul, Korea • May 21-26, 2001
0-7803-6475-9/01/$10.00© 2001 IEEE