December 2014 221
OBJECTIVES: To examine Achilles and patellar tendon mor-
phology in dancers with and without tendon pain. METHODS:
Fifty-three dancers with and without Achilles and/or patellar
tendon pain participated. Eleven age-matched non-dancers
served as controls. Longitudinal ultrasound images of the
middle and distal Achilles and proximal and distal patellar
tendons were acquired. To assess macromorphology, the
thickness of the middle and distal Achilles and proximal and
distal patellar tendons were measured. Micromorphology was
analyzed by selecting 2 × 2-mm
2
regions of interest in the ten-
dons; spectral analysis using the fast Fourier transform was
run for several kernels (2 × 2-mm
2
subimages) within each
image, and the peak spatial frequency (PSF) was extracted. A
one-way ANOVA compared asymptomatic, symptomatic,
and control tendon thickness and PSF. RESULTS: Macromor-
phology: There was no significant difference between asympto-
matic and symptomatic dancers in middle or distal Achilles
tendon thickness and distal patellar tendon thickness. Proxi-
mal patellar tendons in control subjects were thinner than
those in asymptomatic (p=0.036) and symptomatic (p=0.003)
dancers. Micromorphology: There was no significant difference
in PSF between asymptomatic and symptomatic dancers and
controls in the Achilles or patellar tendon. CONCLUSION:
Increased proximal patellar tendon thickness without
changes in tendon micromorphology suggests that tendon
adaptations are more likely activity-related and less likely
influenced by degeneration. Med Probl Perform Art 2014;
29(4):221–228.
A
thletes who participate in sports involving running,
sprinting, and frequent jumping incur repetitive,
high rates of loading to tendons of the lower extremity. It
is thought that those high loading rates, when combined
with suboptimal technique, may produce aberrant strain
to lower extremity tendons, contributing to microtrauma
that may trigger tendinopathies. The prevalence of
Achilles and patellar tendinopathies in dancers is reported
at 9% and 8%, respectively.
15,28
Tendinopathies can be cat-
egorized as a “tendinitis,” if signs of inflammation are pres-
ent, or as a “tendinosis,” a degenerative condition lacking
clinical or histological signs of inflammation.
21
Another
category of painful tendons may include those which do
not exhibit inflammation or degeneration, but which may
be accompanied by chemical substances associated with
pain and increased tendon loading, such as the neuropep-
tide substance P.
3
It is important to distinguish tendinoses from other
pathologies of tendons and surrounding tissues. By doing
this, health practitioners can provide a specific and there-
fore more effective plan of care for each athlete’s condi-
tion. Observation of histopathologic features such as col-
lagen fiber structure and organization, collagen strain
intensity, tendon cell shape, quantity and distribution, and
the presence of macrophages and intracellular fatty
deposits in a tendon sample is one reliable method for
identifying tendinoses.
2
However, from a nonsurgical
standpoint, it is not feasible to take tissue biopsies to deter-
mine the nature of the dancer’s tendinopathy. Hence, the
clinical presentation, such as swelling, warmth, respon-
siveness to anti-inflammatory medication and recurrence
of symptoms, collectively provides for a provisional diag-
nosis as an -itis or an -osis. Alternatively, release of sub-
stance P may also accompany pain without the overt hall-
marks of inflammation or degeneration, making further
diagnosis reliant on the patient’s response to intervention.
To supplement athletes’ reports of symptoms, results of
clinical ultrasound imaging can be included in the diagnos-
tic process. The benefits of using ultrasound are that it is
noninvasive, as reliable as magnetic resonance imaging
(MRI) in diagnostic capacity
1,24
but more cost effective,
and it lends itself to the quantitative analysis of tendon
morphology. Tendon thickness, a macromorphologic
characteristic of the tendon, can be measured on ultra-
sound images and may be reflective of adaptations or mal-
adaptations. Considering the tendon’s micromorphology,
spatial frequency parameters can be mathematically
extracted to quantify the regularity of striation patterns
made by collagen bundles comprising tendons. Decreased
regularity of collagen bundle fibers has been shown to cor-
relate positively with decreased collagen organization, as
well as with athletes’ reports of recurrent episodes of pain
in the Achilles tendon.
4
Hypoechocity, defined as regional
Dr. Kulig is Professor, University of Southern California, Division of
Biokinesiology and Physical Therapy, Los Angeles, CA; Dr. Oki is
Physical Therapist, Rehabilitation Hospital of the Pacific, Honolulu,
HI; Mr. Chang is PhD Candidate, Jacquelin Perry Musculoskeletal
Biomechanics Research Laboratory, Division of Biokinesiology and
Physical Therapy, University of Southern California, Los Angeles, CA;
and Dr. Bashford is Biomedical Engineer and Associate Professor,
Department of Biological Systems Engineering, University of Nebraska-
Lincoln, Lincoln, NE.
Address correspondence to: Dr. Kornelia Kulig, Musculoskeletal Biome-
chanics Research Laboratory, Division of Biokinesiology and Physical
Therapy, University of Southern California, 1540 East Alcazar Street,
CHP-155, Los Angeles, CA 90089, USA. Tel 323-442-2911, fax 323-
442-1515. kulig@usc.edu.
© 2014 Science & Medicine. www.sciandmed.com/mppa.
Achilles and Patellar Tendon Morphology in Dancers
with and without Tendon Pain
Kornelia Kulig, PT, PhD, Kari C. Oki, PT, DPT, Yu-Jen Chang, PT, MS,
and Gregory R. Bashford, PhD, PE