ORIGINAL ARTICLE
Analysis of the factors creating consumer attributes of
roasted beef steaks
Dominika GUZEK,
1
Dominika GLA ˛BSKA,
2
Krystyna GUTKOWSKA,
3
Jerzy WIERZBICKI,
3,4
Alicja WOZ
´
NIAK
1,4
and
Agnieszka WIERZBICKA
1
1
Division of Engineering in Nutrition, Departments of
2
Dietetics and
3
Organization and Consumption Economics,
Faculty of Human Nutrition and Consumer Sciences, Warsaw University of Life Sciences (SGGW-WULS), and
4
Polish Beef Association, Warsaw, Poland
ABSTRACT
The aim of the study was to analyze the factors creating consumer attributes of roasted beef steaks of various animals.
Eight cuts from 30 carcasses (characterized by various types of animal, conformation and fat class, rib fat thickness,
ossification score) were selected. Samples were prepared using the roasting method and consumers rated the tenderness,
juiciness, flavor, overall acceptability (rated in a 100-point scale), and satisfaction (rated from 2 to 5) for analyzed samples.
No influence of type of animal, fat class, conformation class or ossification score on the results of consumer analysis was
observed. For all analyzed factors, the influence of cut on consumer analysis was observed (the highest values of all
consumer attributes were observed for tenderloin - for juiciness significantly higher than for other cuts, for tenderness,
flavor and MQ4 comparable only with rump (RMP231), while for overall acceptability and satisfaction – with both rump
cuts). For rib fat thickness consumer attributes of roasted beef meat were not linear, but the influence was observed – the
highest values of consumer attributes were observed for 13 mm rib fat thickness.
Key words: beef, consumer analysis, cut, quality score, roast.
INTRODUCTION
In Poland, similar to the Western Europe, a decrease in
beef meat consumption has been observed (Van
Wezemael et al. 2010). This decline in consumption
reflects consumer concerns about beef meat safety
(resulting from bovine spongiform encephalopathy –
BSE incidents), as well as about animal welfare and
environmental protection (Daniel et al. 2011).
The lifestyle changes associated with increased
concern about diet improvement to prevent diet-
related diseases, has also impacted on changes in beef
consumption (Resurreccion 2003). At the same time,
households are nowadays having less time to spend
preparing meals, so they choose easy methods of
thermal treatment, as well as they often eat out or
purchase foods already prepared (Bastian 1996).
All these changes may lead to potential changes in
consumer beef preferences. Much research states that
perception of food quality, including meat, changes
over the years (Mannion et al. 2000; Grunert & Valli
2001), so there is constant need to examine consum-
ers’ preferences (Behrends et al. 2005). Therefore, the
meat market must all the time develop new beef prod-
ucts, as well as new beef production and marketing
strategies, for example trying to implement new
cutting methods to obtain new cuts from beef meat,
characterized by features accepted by consumers.
Proper applying of the methods of thermal treat-
ment also plays an important role in creating the desir-
ability of various cuts to achieve consumer satisfaction
(Behrends et al. 2005). However, as Lorenzen et al.
(2003) reported, there are difficulties in predicting
preparation techniques and the preferences of con-
sumers from laboratory procedures (using trained
sensory panels or instrumental methods), so in order
to achieve better understanding of consumers’ prepa-
ration of beef meat cuts and their preferences, con-
sumer tests are needed.
Correspondence: Dominika Guzek, Faculty of Human Nutri-
tion and Consumer Sciences, Warsaw University of Life Sci-
ences, 02-787 Warsaw, Poland. (Email: dominika_guzek@
sggw.pl)
Received 19 November 2013; accepted for publication 11
June 2014.
Animal Science Journal (2014) ••, ••–•• doi: 10.1111/asj.12278
© 2014 Japanese Society of Animal Science