IEEE TRANSACTIONS ON POWER SYSTEMS, VOL. 28, NO. 4, NOVEMBER 2013 4209
Probabilistic Assessment of the Impact of Wind
Energy Integration Into Distribution Networks
Pierluigi Siano, Member, IEEE, and Geev Mokryani, Member, IEEE
Abstract—Combined Monte Carlo simulation (MCS) and
market-based optimal power flow (OPF) considering different
combinations of wind generation and load demand over a year are
used to evaluate wind turbines (WTs) integration into distribution
systems. MCS is used to model the uncertainties related to the
stochastic variations of wind power generation and load demand
while the social welfare is maximized by means of market-based
OPF with inter-temporal constraints. The proposed probabilistic
methodology allows evaluating the amount of wind power that
can be injected into the grid as well as the impact of wind power
penetration on the social welfare and on distribution-locational
marginal prices. Market-based OPF is solved by using step-con-
trolled primal dual interior point method considering network
constraints. The effectiveness of the proposed probabilistic method
in assessing the impact of wind generation penetration in terms
of both technical and economic effects is demonstrated with an
84-bus 11.4-kV radial distribution system.
Index Terms—Distribution-locational marginal prices, Monte
Carlo simulation, optimal power flow, social welfare maximiza-
tion, wind turbines.
I. INTRODUCTION
A. Motivation and Approach
R
ECENT researches have indicated the potential of
distributed generation (DG) in offering an alternative ap-
proach to utilities to satisfy demand locally and incrementally.
Indeed, DG may determine various benefits, such as a positive
capacity margin, and, if properly allocated, may allow losses
reduction, energy savings, flattening of the peak, voltage con-
trol, ancillary services, transmission and distribution capacity
deferral, higher power quality and lowering the loss of load
probability [1]–[4]. On the other end, the international concern
over climate change is driving many governments to reduce
carbon-dioxide emissions and to increase the percentage share
of the total electrical supply energy from renewable energy
source (RES). Among other RES, wind energy represents the
lowest risk and most established technology, also thanks to re-
cent technical developments, financing options and incentives.
The connection of large amounts of wind turbines (WTs) to
distribution systems presents, however, a number of technical
challenges to distribution network operators (DNOs). The
impacts on the networks depend on several parameters, such as:
Manuscript received November 10, 2012; revised February 26, 2013 and May
14, 2013; accepted June 14, 2013. Date of publication July 09, 2013; date of
current version October 17, 2013. Paper no. TPWRS-01179-2012.
The authors are with the Department of Industrial Engineering, Uni-
versity of Salerno, 84084 Fisciano (SA), Italy (e-mail: psiano@unisa.it;
gmokryani@gmail.com)
Digital Object Identifier 10.1109/TPWRS.2013.2270378
size, type and location of the new connections; the density of
installations and proximity to the load; the pattern and timing
of output; the state of the network and the overall amount
of capacity, etc. [4]. The intermittent nature of wind power
generation also introduces additional technical and economic
challenges that must be addressed by DNOs [1], [4]. DNOs
have, therefore, to carry out a rational operating strategy that
takes into account dispatching DG, interrupting loads while
keeping system security.
In the approach presented here, the DNO is defined as the
market operator of the DNO acquisition market, which deter-
mines the price estimation and the optimization process for
the hourly acquisition of active power [3]. Assuming that the
purpose of DNOs is to maximize their benefits, two different
regulatory cases can be, indeed, considered: 1) DG-owning
DNO—permitted to possess DG and can exploit the financial
benefits brought by considering new generation as an option
for distribution system investments, 2) Unbundled DNO—pro-
hibited from DG ownership but can maximize benefits based
on a set of incentives [4], [5]. European Directive 2003/54/EC
describes the technical and legal existing limitations among
different market actors of European electricity markets. Par-
ticularly, it establishes the unbundling regulations that DNOs
have to be unbundled from generation interests, hence, pro-
hibiting DNOs from DG ownership. It separates the electricity
distribution from retail supply where distribution utilities are
not responsible to sell power to customers. The US approach
for the ownership of DG is driven, instead, by the traditional
structure of distribution networks in which they are respon-
sible for supplying consumers throughout purchasing power
from various sources in addition to owning and operating
the wires. The financial profits of DG allocation to the utility
from deferred generation and distribution investments are well
recognized and utilities are permitted to site DG at strategic
places on the grid to defer network upgrade costs and reduce
peak-hour supply costs [4]–[9].
This paper provides a probabilistic methodology for evalu-
ating the amount of wind power that can be injected into the
grid as well as the impact of wind power penetration on the so-
cial welfare (SW) and on distribution-locational marginal prices
(D-LMPs) within a DNO acquisition market environment con-
sidering uncertainties related to both load demand and wind
speed. In the proposed approach it has been assumed that WTs
and dispatchable loads (DLs) are owned or managed by the
DG-owning DNO that is also the market operator of its acquisi-
tion market. Market-based optimal power flow (OPF), consid-
ering inter-temporal constraints, is used to maximize the SW
and to calculate the D-LMPs. The uncertainties related to the
0885-8950 © 2013 IEEE