Nature © Macmillan Publishers Ltd 1997
Survival of FimH-expressing
enterobacteria in
macrophages relies on
glycolipid traffic
David M. Baorto*, Zhimin Gao*, Ravi Malaviya*,
Michael L. Dustin*, Anton van der Merwe†,
Douglas M. Lublin* & Soman N. Abraham*‡§
Departments of * Pathology and ‡ Molecular Microbiology,
Washington University School of Medicine, St Louis, Missouri 63110, USA
† MRC Cellular Immunology Unit, Sir William Dunn School of Pathology,
University of Oxford, Oxford OX1 3RE, UK
.........................................................................................................................
Strains of Escherichia coli persist within the human gut as normal
commensals, but are frequent pathogens and can cause recurrent
infection
1–3
. Here we show that, in contrast to E. coli subjected to
opsonic interactions stimulated by the host’s immune response,
E. coli that bind to the macrophage surface exclusively through
the bacterial lectin FimH can survive inside the cell following
phagocytosis. This viability is largely due to the attenuation of
intracellular free-radical release and of phagosome acidification
during FimH-mediated internalization, both of which are trig-
gered by antibody-mediated internalization. This different pro-
cessing of non-opsonized bacteria is supported by morphological
evidence of tight-fitting phagosomes compared with looser, anti-
body-mediated phagosomes. We propose that non-opsonized
FimH-expressing E. coli co-opt internalization of lipid-rich
microdomains following binding to the FimH receptor, the
glycosylphosphatidylinositol-linked protein CD48, because (1)
the sterol-binding agents filipin, nystatin and methyl -cyclodex-
trin specifically block FimH-mediated internalization; (2) CD48
and the protein caveolin both accumulate on macrophage mem-
branes surrounding bacteria; and (3) antibodies against CD48
inhibit FimH-mediated internalization. Our findings bring the
traditionally extracellular E. coli into the realm of opportunistic
intracellular parasitism and suggest how opportunistic infections
with FimH-expressing enterobacteria could occur in a setting
deprived of opsonizing antibodies.
Escherichia coli are normal residents of the alimentary canal but
they have also been implicated in opportunistic and often recurrent
infections in man and animals
1–3
. E. coli, as well as many other
enteric bacteria, express on their surface type-1 fimbriae, 1–2-m-
long filaments composed of several subunits including FimH, a
mannose-binding lectin that is responsible for promoting bacterial
adherence and colonization of mucosal surfaces
4,5
. Paradoxically,
however, FimH also promotes adhesion to phagocytic cells, an event
that should presumably result in early bacterial clearance. With two
exceptions
6,7
, most in vitro studies have reported that type-1
fimbrial-mediated association with phagocytic cells results in bac-
terial killing
8–10
. As the effect of opsonic serum components or the
contribution of other bacterial surface antigens that promote
phagocytosis was not excluded, these findings may not be definite.
Nevertheless, expression of FimH is viewed by some as being
detrimental to bacterial virulence in vivo
10,11
, an assumption that
could not account for the invariable expression of type 1 fimbriae by
E. coli isolated from clinical specimens
12,13
.
To determine whether FimH-mediated binding to phagocytic
cells is a fatal error for the bacterium, we developed a system directly
to compare the fate of intracellular E. coli in mouse bone-marrow-
derived macrophages following internalization by a FimH-
mediated, non-opsonic mechanism, to the fate of the same organ-
ism internalized by an antibody-mediated opsonic mechanism.
After phagocytosis, extracellular bacteria were pulsed with enough
gentamicin to eradicate them, allowing exclusive observation of
intracellular E. coli. In contrast to antibody-internalized E. coli,
which are effectively killed in the first hour, E. coli internalized by a
FimH-mediated mechanism showed almost no sign of killing after
letters to nature
636 NATURE | VOL 389 | 9 OCTOBER 1997
Figure 1 Intracellular survival of FimH-internalized E. coli in macrophages
compared to opsonized E. coli. Intracellular E. coli can survive in cultured
macrophages when they are internalized via FimH, in contrast to opsonized E. coli
internalized via antibody, which are effectively killed (a, model strain; b,
uropathogenic-clinical isolate). Bacterial viability stains also demonstrate
increased intracellular survival of the FimH-internalized bacteria at 1 hour (c,
antibody-internalized; d, FimH-internalized). Viable bacteria stain green and dead
bacteria stain red.
§ Present address: Department of Pathology, Box 3712, Duke University Medical Center, Durham, North
Carolina 27710, USA.