Comparing Prevalence of Condom Use Among 15,379 Female
Sex Workers Injecting or Not Injecting Drugs in China
JOSEPH T. F. LAU, MD,* JIANXIN ZHANG, MD, MSC,† LINGLIN ZHANG, MD, MSC,‡ NING WANG, PHD,§
FENG CHENG, PHD, YUN ZHANG, MBA,¶ JING GU, MSC,* HI-YI TSUI, MPHIL,* AND YAJIA LAN, PHD†
Objectives: To compare the prevalence of condom use with clients
and regular sex partners between female sex workers (FSWs) who
were or were not injecting drug users (IDUs).
Methods: Behavioral surveillance data (2002–2004) conducted in
Sichuan, China were analyzed. Mapping exercises were done. About
250 to 400 FSWs were anonymously interviewed from selected estab-
lishments in 19 surveillance sites.
Results: Of all 15,379 FSWs studied, 3.2% were IDUs. This group,
when compared with the non-IDU group, was less likely to have used
condoms with clients (last episode: 71.1% vs. 81.2%, OR 0.6, P <
0.01; consistent use in the last month: 26.7% vs. 40.4%, OR 0.5, P <
0.01) or to possess a condom (68.7% vs. 77.8%, OR 0.6, P < 0.01).
The between-group difference in last month’s consistent condom use
with clients remained significant in the multivariate analyses, after
adjusting for other significant factors [age, education level, age at first
sex, having a regular sex partner, HIV-related knowledge and percep-
tions, HIV antibody testing (OR 1.1–2.9, P < 0.05); STD symptoms,
type of sex workers, longer duration of sex work, larger number of
clients per week, and not having received HIV-related information
(OR 0.4 – 0.9)]. Comparable results were obtained for condom use
with the last client. Such between-group differences were, however, not
observed for condom use with regular sex partners (P > 0.05). Expo-
sure to HIV-related services was associated with condom use with
clients (OR 1.3–2.8, P < 0.05).
Conclusions: Higher sexual risk behaviors were found among
FSWs who were also IDUs, when compared with those who were
non-IUDs. A double-risk bridging population for HIV transmission
thereby exists.
AS OF THE END of 2005, 44.3% of all estimated HIV cases in
China could be attributed to injecting drug users (IDUs).
1
HIV
transmission among IDUs is the driving force of the HIV epidemic
in China.
2
The efficiency of the spread of HIV from the IDU
population to other populations [e.g., female sex workers (FSW)
population] is a determining factor for future HIV prevalence in
China.
3–5
A number of studies investigating female IDUs in China and
other countries reported that about 21% to 60% of them were also
engaged in sex work
4,6–8
and that FSWs who were also IDUs
(FSWIs) often engaged in behaviors involving risk of sexual
transmission of HIV.
9,10
In contrast, other studies surveying FSWs
found only a few percent of them were FSWIs.
11–13
The apparent
inconsistency may be explained by the fact that surveys targeting
IDUs were often institution-based or community-based,
4,14,15
whereas surveys targeting FSWs were often venue-based (e.g.,
night clubs, saunas).
16 –18
Moreover, FSWs with IDU behaviors
would find it difficult to work in some types of venues (e.g.,
karaoke clubs or saunas). Many of these reports, however, in-
volved a relatively small number of FSWIs. With financial pres-
sure resulting from their drug dependency, FSWIs may be less able
to insist on consistent condom use with their commercial sex
partners.
3
Because there may be around 6 to 8 million FSWs in
China,
19
the size of the FSWI population is noteworthy.
This study compared data on the FSWIs and FSWs who were
not IDUs (FSWNI) obtained from the Behavioral Surveillance
Surveys (BSS) of the China-UK HIV/AIDS Prevention and Care
Project
20
conducted for FSWs in Sichuan in 2002, 2003, and 2004.
The Project also implemented various prevention and care pro-
grams for HIV-vulnerable populations in Sichuan and Yunnan,
China and was managed by its National and Provincial Manage-
ment Offices.
20
Both funding (about 20 million pounds) and tech-
nical support have been provided by United Kingdom Department
for International Development and Family Health International
(FHI).
Sichuan has a total population size of about 87 million
21
and
was ranked sixth among all China provinces for the number of
HIV cases reported.
22
The HIV prevalence among IDUs in Si-
chuan was quite high.
15
This study tested the hypotheses that FSWIs and FSWNIs had
different background characteristics, HIV-related perceptions, and
prevalence of condom use with both sex work clients and regular
The authors thank all staff of the China-UK HIV/AIDS Prevention and
Care Project and CDC of Sichuan. Thanks are extended to Dr. Jean H. Kim
for her help in early drafts of the manuscript.
The study was Supported by United Kingdom Department for Interna-
tional Development, Family Health International, and the China-UK HIV/
AIDS Prevention and Care Project.
Correspondence: Joseph T. F. Lau, Centre for Epidemiology and Bio-
statistics, School of Public Health, Faculty of Medicine, The Chinese
University of Hong Kong, 5/F., School of Public Health, Prince of Wales
Hospital, Shatin, NT, Hong Kong. E-mail: jlau@cuhk.edu.hk.
Received for publication January 19, 2007, and accepted March 26,
2007.
From the *Centre for Epidemiology and Biostatistics, School of
Public Health, Faculty of Medicine, The Chinese University of
Hong Kong, Shatin, NT, Hong Kong; †West China School
of Public Health, Sichuan University, Chengdu, China; ‡Sichuan
Provincial Center for Disease Control and Prevention, Chengdu,
China; §National Center for AIDS/STDs Control and Prevention,
Chinese Center for Disease Control and Prevention, Beijing,
China; China Country Office of Family Health International,
Beijing, China; and ¶Management Office of China-UK HIV/AIDS
Prevention and Care Project, Beijing, China
Sexually Transmitted Diseases, November 2007, Vol. 34, No. 11, p.908 –916
DOI: 10.1097/OLQ.0b013e3180e904b4
Copyright © 2007, American Sexually Transmitted Diseases Association
All rights reserved.
908