X-ray Absorption Spectroscopy of Liquid Methanol Microjets: Bulk Electronic Structure
and Hydrogen Bonding Network
Kevin R. Wilson,
²,‡
Matteo Cavalleri,
§
Bruce S. Rude,
|
R. D. Schaller,
‡
T. Catalano,
|
A. Nilsson,
§,⊥
R. J. Saykally,*
,‡
and L. G. M. Pettersson*
,§
Department of Chemistry, UniVersity of California, Berkeley, California 94720, FYSIKUM,
Stockholm UniVersity, AlbaNoVa UniVersity Center, S-10691 Stockholm, Sweden, AdVanced Light Source,
Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory, Berkeley, California 94720, and Stanford Synchrotron Radiation
Laboratory, Menlo Park, California 94025
ReceiVed: February 17, 2004; In Final Form: September 22, 2004
We have measured the X-ray absorption (XA) spectrum of liquid (298 K) methanol at the oxygen and carbon
K edges. The 4a
1
orbital at the O K edge exhibits a pronounced sensitivity to the formation of intermolecular
hydrogen bonds, with significant differences observed between the vapor and bulk spectra, whereas the C K
edge reveals only subtle corresponding spectral changes. Comparison with DFT computed spectra of model
methanol clusters indicates that the bulk liquid comprises long chains (n > 6) and rings of hydrogen-bonded
monomers.
I. Introduction
Our knowledge of the electronic and geometrical structure
of liquids has advanced dramatically over the past decade due
to rapid progress in both theory and experiment. However, the
microscopic structure of hydrogen-bonded liquids remains a
vigorously debated subject. Classical molecular dynamics
simulations have offered some new microscopic insights, but
developing realistic force fields that properly account for many-
body effects in the bulk liquid continues to be a challenge.
1
Ab
initio molecular dynamics simulations eliminate the need for
predetermined force-fields and the method has become well-
established as a simulation tool. Wilson et al., have recently
reported a new X-ray spectroscopy technique for the study of
bulk liquids and liquid-vapor interfaces.
2-4
In the initial
applications, we described the first measurement of intermo-
lecular surface relaxation in liquids (water and methanol),
4
as
well as the presence of a previously unrecognized type of
“acceptor only” species at the liquid water surface.
3
Recently,
these experimental findings have been corroborated by new ab
initio molecular dynamics (CPMD) simulations reported by Kuo
and Mundy,
5
who find that 19% of surface molecules of 298 K
water are “acceptor only”. Here we study the bulk properties
of liquid methanol by X-ray absorption spectroscopy, using
liquid microjets to introduce the volatile samples into the high
vacuum environment of a synchrotron endstation and as an
effective means of avoiding sample photodamage.
Soft X-ray absorption spectroscopy (XAS) is a powerful
structural tool commonly used to study the bonding of adsor-
bates to metal surfaces through the ability to determine local
geometry and bond lengths.
6
A main advantage of XAS is the
ability to selectively excite individual atoms within a molecule
and thereby examine specific chemical bonds (e.g., CdO,
CsC, OsH, etc.). Traditionally, near-edge X-ray absorption
fine structure (NEXAFS) experiments have characterized the
rehybridization of covalent bonds, which can yield information
about which orbitals are involved in the formation of a surface
chemical bond.
7
Although NEXAFS is most sensitive to changes
in intramolecular bond lengths and angles, there are a number
of recent studies
3,4,8-15
examining the changes in electronic
structure of liquid water, ice and H
2
O clusters upon the
rearrangement of intermolecular hydrogen bonding (HB).
Together these studies indicate that the O K edge XAS is
particularly sensitive to broken donor hydrogen bonds located,
e.g., within liquid water,
14,15
on the surface of ice,
15,16
or at the
liquid-gas interface.
3
As expected, water in its various phases
is a natural starting point to investigate the local changes in
electronic structure induced by HB. In this paper, we extend
these studies of intermolecular hydrogen bonds to methanol,
which might be considered the next logical step in a detailed
examination of the changes in electronic structure that occur
upon condensation within the bulk hydrogen-bonded liquid. The
general strategy outlined here is to first obtain high-resolution
XA spectra of molecular (gas phase) methanol whereupon
spectral changes induced by condensation can be evaluated.
Subsequently, density functional theory calculations, utilizing
small methanol clusters, are used to further interpret the
experimental XA spectra, yielding new insights into the HB
network of the bulk liquid.
II. X-ray Absorption of Liquids
XAS entails the removal of a core electron and its promotion
into an unoccupied molecular orbital or continuum state. The
excitation process obeys dipole selection rules yielding spectral
intensity from transitions between the 1s (K shell) orbital to
excited states of mainly p symmetry. The core hole is strongly
localized, allowing individual atoms within molecules to be
independently excited. For methanol, the carbon (∼289 eV) and
oxygen K edge (∼530 eV) spectral intensity will be sensitive
* Corresponding Authors. E-mail: R.J.S., saykally@uclink4.berkeley.edu;
L.G.M.P., lgm@physto.se.
²
Present address: Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory, Chemical
Sciences Division, Berkeley, CA 94720.
‡
University of California.
§
Stockholm University.
|
Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory.
⊥
Stanford Synchrotron Radiation Laboratory.
10194 J. Phys. Chem. B 2005, 109, 10194-10203
10.1021/jp049278u CCC: $30.25 © 2005 American Chemical Society
Published on Web 04/21/2005