. . . . . Mental Health . . . . .
© 2006 National Rural Health Association 182 Vol. 22, No. 2
Family Perspectives on Pathways to Mental
Health Care for Children and Youth in
Rural Communities
Katherine M. Boydell, MHSc, PhD;
1,2
Raymond Pong, PhD;
3
Tiziana Volpe, MSc;
1
Kate Tilleczek, PhD;
4
Elizabeth Wilson, PhD;
5
and Sandy Lemieux, BA
3
ABSTRACT: Context: There is insufficient literature
documenting the mental health experiences and needs of
rural communities, and a lack of focus on children in
particular. This is of concern given that up to 20% of
children and youth suffer from a diagnosable mental
health problem. Purpose: This study examines issues
of access to mental health care for children and youth
in rural communities from the family perspective.
Methods: In-depth interviews were conducted in rural
Ontario, Canada, with 30 parents of children aged 3-17
who had been diagnosed with emotional and behavioral
disorders. Findings: Interview data indicate 3 overall
thematic areas that describe the main barriers and
facilitators to care. These include personal, systemic, and
environmental factors. Family members are constantly
negotiating ongoing tension, struggle, and contradiction
vis-à-vis their attempts to access and provide mental
health care. Most factors identified as barriers are also,
under different circumstances, facilitators. Analysis
clustered around the contrasts, contradictions, and
paradoxes present throughout the interviews.
Conclusions: The route to mental health care for
children in rural communities is complex, dynamic, and
nonlinear, with multiple roadblocks. Although faced with
multiple roadblocks, there are also several factors that help
minimize these barriers.
C
urrently, there are as many as 10 million
Canadians who can be considered rural
residents—one third of all Canadians.
1
Children and their families in rural and
northern communities may face more
obstacles obtaining health services and supports than
their urban counterparts.
2,3
Problems of service access
often result from geographic, economic, and cultural
factors.
4,5
In sparsely populated areas, travel expenses
increase the costs of both providing and obtaining care.
In addition, children from rural areas often must be
placed in residential care outside of their community
because of the lack of resources within the community.
6
Geographic and professional isolation make rural
communities less attractive to mental health workers. It
is difficult to recruit and retain specialists, who tend to
concentrate in larger urban areas.
7
Most rural
communities are too small to sustain highly specialized
personnel. Moreover, within the health research
community, rural issues are often overlooked or dealt
with generically. When rural perspectives are
examined, it is frequently within the context of urban-
rural differences, rather than as the sole focus of
attention.
8
When mental health is the focus, there is
little literature documenting the mental health
experiences and needs of rural communities, and a lack
of focus on children and their families in particular.
9
The purpose of this study is to examine issues of
access to mental health care for children and youth in
rural Canadian communities from the family perspective.
Canadian Health System. The Canadian health
system is a publicly funded insurance program where
1
Community Health Systems Resource Group, The Hospital for Sick
Children, Toronto, Canada.
2
Departments of Psychiatry and Public Health Sciences, University
of Toronto, Toronto, Canada.
3
Centre for Rural and Northern Health Research, Laurentian
University, Sudbury, Ontario, Canada.
4
Department of Sociology, Laurentian University, Sudbury, Ontario,
Canada.
5
Independent research consultant, Owen Sound, Ontario, Canada.
The authors gratefully acknowledge the support of the funders,
the Canadian Health Services Research Foundation and the Ontario
Ministry of Health and Long-Term Care. The authors also thank the
family participants who so willingly shared their stories with us.
For more information contact: Katherine M. Boydell, 555
University Avenue, Toronto, Ontario, Canada M5G 1X8; e-mail
katherine.boydell@sickkids.ca.