Abstract—This paper describes the application of fuzzy logic
to the Short Physical Performance Battery (SPPB) test, a series
of timed physical activities that have been created to evaluate,
discriminate, and predict physical functional performance for
both research and clinical purposes, primarily for physically
impaired older adults. The original scoring system of SPPB test
uses crisp time boundaries to assign the subject to discrete
classes of performance. The crisp (and somewhat arbitrary)
nature of the crisp thresholds can easily produce anomalies.
Fuzzy Logic theory allows the natural description, in linguistic
terms, of input/output relationships rather than relying on
precise numerical threshold values. This advantage, dealing
with the complicated systems in simple way, is the main reason
why fuzzy logic theory is widely applied. In this paper, we offer
a new approach for scoring the SPPB test. We demonstrate that
in the proposed system, the Fuzzy Short Physical Performance
Battery (FSPPB), we can improve the sensitivity and data
distribution of the scoring system for the SPPB test. We present
the procedures of constructing a fuzzy inference system using
fuzzy logic to score the SPPB test and compare the original
scoring system with our fuzzy scoring system. As part of a large
project in technology for Eldercare, our goal is to accurately
measure trends in physical performance of seniors over time.
Keywords—Fuzzy logic, Short physical performance battery
test, Eldercare technology
I. INTRODUCTION
lder adults are living longer and more fulfilled lives, and
they desire to live as independently as possible in the
home of their choice. However, independent lifestyles come
with risks that are complicated by chronic illness and
impairments in mobility, cognition, and the senses. In
response to this trend, the University of Missouri has been
investigating new approaches in caring for the elderly. One
recent example of this research focus has resulted in
TigerPlace, a 32-unit apartment complex for seniors that
opened in Columbia, Missouri in 2004. A joint venture
between MU’s Sinclair School of Nursing and Americare
Systems Inc., TigerPlace is one of four projects granted state
approval to operate under the “aging in place” model of care
giving [1]. Under that model, residents who would otherwise
be required by state law to live in nursing homes may have
health services brought to them in their apartments instead.
Technology that can help seniors “age in place” has been
spotlighted in recent years, spurred by an aging population.
One focus of our research is the creation of “intelligent
software” that uses sensors to uncover patterns of activity
helpful to caregivers [2], especially targeting mobility and
Manuscript received January 20, 2006. This work was supported in part
by the National Science Foundation Grant IIS-0428420 and the
Administration on Aging Grant 90AM3013/01.
S. Wang , J. Keller, M. Skubic and H. Tyrer are with the Electrical and
Computer Engineering Department, University of Missouri- Columbia,
Columbia, MO 65211. J. Keller is the corresponding author
(kellerj@missouri.edu , (573) 882-7339).
K . Burks is with the Sinclair School of Nursing, University of Missouri-
Columbia, Columbia, MO 65211.
cognitive impairment. Details can be found at
http://eldertech.missouri.edu . A critical part of this effort is
being able to sense, detect and assess changes in basic
physical performance in elders. So, we centered on the Short
Physical Performance Battery (SPPB) test [3]. This exam
was created to evaluate, discriminate, and predict physical
functional performance for older adults. It was used to assess
lower extremity function in more than 5,000 persons age 71
years and older. The SPPB test measures balance, gait,
strength, and endurance. Although it is a timed performance
test, each subtask score is an integer value in the range 0-4. A
score of 0 indicates the inability to complete the task in a
nominal time frame while categories 1-4 are assigned to the
corresponding quartiles of time needed to perform the action.
There are five subscales: semi-tandem standing (the heel of
one foot on the side of the big toe of the other foot), side by
side standing, full tandem position (the heel of one foot
directly in front of the other foot), walking speed (eight feet
on a smooth service with no obstructions), and a sit-to-stand
test (rise from a chair five times with arms folded across the
chest). It has been shown that such performance measures
correlate well with the self-assessment of older persons
across a broad spectrum of lower extremity function [3-6].
The original scoring for the SPPB test is as follows [3]:
Scoring performance on tests of standing balance
Score Side by side
stand
Semi-tandem
stand
Full tandem
stand
0 t< 10 seconds Not
attempted
Not
attempted
1 t=10 seconds t< 10 seconds Not
attempted
2 t=10 seconds t=10 seconds t< 3 seconds
3 t=10 seconds t=10 seconds 3seconds<=t
<10seconds
4 t=10 seconds t=10 seconds t=10 seconds
Scoring performance on test for walking 8 feet (using
faster of the two walks)
Score Walking Time
1 t>=5.7 seconds
2 4.1seconds<=t<=5.7seconds
3 3.2seconds<=t<4.1seconds
4 t<3.2seconds
Scorning performance on chair test (sit to stand 5 times)
Score Sit to Stand Time
1 t>=16.7 seconds
2 13.7seconds<=t<16.7seconds
3 11.2seconds<=t<13.7seconds
4 t<11.2seconds
While the crisp scoring of the SPPB has been validated on
good sized populations of elders, the crisp nature of the
Assessing Physical Performance of Elders Using Fuzzy Logic
Shuang Wang, James M. Keller, Kathryn Burks, Marjorie Skubic, Harry Tyrer
O
0-7803-9489-5/06/$20.00/©2006 IEEE
2006 IEEE International Conference on Fuzzy Systems
Sheraton Vancouver Wall Centre Hotel, Vancouver, BC, Canada
July 16-21, 2006
1482