978-1-4244-2120-6/08/$25.00 ©IEEE.
AbstractイRecently, there have been numerous food scares
particularly with the production of milk powders for infants. This
has been caused by the addition of excess melamine to increase the
tested protein count of a powder. In this paper we investigate the
potential of THz-TDS for use in food quality control and compare
this technique to other established techniques.
I. INTRODUCTION AND BACKGROUND
ELAMINE is a nitrogen rich molecule, with six out of the
fifteen atoms being nitrogen (C
3
H
6
N
6
). This high nitrogen
content has led to its use as a protein supplement in food
powders. This has been the case, with pet foods supplied in the
United States
1
, milk powders supplied in mainland China
2
and
poultry feed in France
3
.
Melamine has typically been thought of as a harmless
chemical, as it is used in its plastic form for food packaging. In
some recent incidents however, contamination levels of
melamine exceeded the European Union tolerable daily intake
of 0.5 mg/kg of body weight
4
. This has caused deaths in pets
from tainted pet foods, infant deaths and kidney failures from
contaminated milk powders and caused a poultry scare with
laced chicken feed.
In the interests of public safety and to ensure adequate quality
of foods, quick and effective methods need to be developed to
detect whether foods are within safe standards (no more than 2.5
mg/kg of melamine in food products, set by the European
Union
4
). Mass spectroscopy
5
and liquid chromatography
6
have
typically been used for the detection of melamine in food
products. These methods have proven to be effective in
determining if melamine is present in a sample and also the
quantity to within parts per million. However, fairly complex
sample preparation is required, and thus blanket sample testing
is not possible.
Melamine by itself is not the only cause for kidney failures in
humans and animals. When melamine is combined with
cyanuric acid ((CNOH)
3
) within an aqueous solution, melamine
- cyanurate crystals are formed, causing kidney stone formation
and the possibility of acute renal failure
6
.
THz-TDS provides an alternative to these established
methods. Recently, Harsha et. al.
7
have shown that melamine
has characteristic signatures in the THz region with two distinct
spectral features at 1.98 and 2.25 THz. THz-TDS provides
advantages over these techniques, as it is able to penetrate
plastic packaging, sample preparation is simple and cost
effective and detection is fast (within minutes). However, the
limit of detection of THz-TDS may prove to be a disadvantage
when determining the exact quantity of melamine and cyanuric
acid present in a given sample. We thus attempt to determine an
estimate for the detection limit and compare this with other
detection techniques, putting into perspective the advantages
and disadvantages of THz-TDS with respect to other
techniques. In particular, we compare THz-TDS with an FTIR
approach to detection.
II. RESULTS
Samples of melamine, cyanuric acid, and mixtures are
prepared by mixing with polyethylene, which are then
compressed forming pellets. These sample pellets are optimized
in thickness for maximum bandwidth for both transmission and
reflection mode THz-TDS, by varying the amount of sample
used. Sample pellets are measured at room temperature to match
possible real world usage. Concentrations of melamine were
varied, with a dilution table formed to determine the minimal
detectable limit of melamine within a sample.
The absorption peaks previously reported in literature for
both THz-TDS
7
and FTIR
8
were reproduced in experiments,
and subsequently we proceeded directly into a dilution series of
melamine, cyanuric acid and infant formula.
Figure 1: Melamine FTIR spectra from wave numbers 400 to 4000 cm
-1
.
III. EXPERIMENTAL PARAMETERS
Melamine and cyanuric acid were purchased from Sigma
Aldrich (M2659 and 185809), while Indocus 13/3 polyethylene
was used as a buffering compound and Nestle S-26 infant
formula was used as the basis for the dilution series. The
mixture was weighed and then mixed crushed into a
homogeneous mixture in a mortar and pestle. Pellets of 12 mm
diameter were then produced by compressing the mixture in a
10 ton press. Concentrations of melamine and cyanuric acid
Benjamin S.Y. Ung, Bernd M. Fischer, Brian H.-W. Ng, and Derek Abbott
Centre of Biomedical Engineering, School of Electrical & Electronic Engineering, The University of
Adelaide, North Terrace, Adelaide, South Australia, Australia, 5005
Comparative Investigation of Detection of Melamine in Food Powders
M