European Sociological Review VOLUME 21 NUMBER 2 APRIL 2005 149–163 149
DOI:10.1093/esr/jci010, available online at www.esr.oupjournals.org
© The Author 2005. Published by Oxford University Press. All rights reserved.
For permissions, please e-mail: journals.permissions@oupjournals.org
Cherchez la Femme: Women
as Supporting Actors in the
Russian Labour Market
Sarah Ashwin and Valery Yakubovich
It is well known that women have inferior labour market opportunities in post-communist
Russia, but little is known about their role as labour market intermediaries. This paper
examines how women compare to men in this role. We base our analysis on qualitative
and quantitative data, gathered in the Russian city of Samara in 1999. We find that women
are more effective than men in helping their contacts into jobs, but that these jobs are
lower paid than those provided by men. Our explanation is that while women’s position in
the labour market restricts their access to information about good jobs, their leading role
in the household implies intervention in the lives of others, including as persistent labour
market intermediaries.
Introduction
In her influential study of the relationship between gender
roles within nuclear families and the social networks in
which families are embedded, Elizabeth Bott found that
women were notably more active than men in keeping
up kinship ties and, in this context, were the ones who
persuaded male relatives to help one another get jobs
(Bott, 1971 [1957]: 135–136). Despite the prominence of
both gender and network themes in the sociology of
labour markets, Bott’s insight went unnoticed in that lit-
erature. One exception is the work of Margaret Grieco,
which, on the basis of case study research among blue
collar workers in the UK in the 1980s, finds a similar
pattern: ‘females link the employment chances of their
spouses to the male kin of their family of origin and vice
versa’ (1987: 36), partly by servicing and managing the
ties between the two families. Other available studies
consistently show the lower diversity and narrower out-
reach of women’s networks vis-à-vis men’s: they include
more kin and neighbours and fewer coworkers (Marsden,
1987; Moore, 1990; Marsden and Gorman, 2001). This
suggests, as Bott argues, that women are confined to a
‘behind-the-scenes’ role. In this article, we explore the
role played by women as labour market intermediaries
in contemporary Russia – a context which is significant
both because of the high labour participation of women,
and because of the importance of networks within the
post-communist labour market.
One of the reasons for the relative neglect of gender
issues in the sociology of labour markets and networks
may be purely methodological. Sociologists of labour
markets simply assume that the characteristics of the
contact that leads to a job can serve as a proxy for the
structure of the underlying network. The larger network
from which these ‘productive’ ties emerge remains
unobserved, which does not allow Bott’s ethnographic
observation to surface in quantitative data. The other
reason is substantive. Since the middle of the twentieth
century, women in the developed world have left the
confines of their households to enter the public economy
and have therefore become capable of assisting others in