0196/0202/2014/356-0680/0•Ear&Hearing•Copyright©2014byLippincottWilliams&Wilkins•PrintedintheU.S.A.
680
Objectives: Sensorineural hearing loss from sound overexposure has
a considerable prevalence. Identification of sound hazards is crucial, as
prevention, due to a lack of definitive therapies, is the sole alternative
to hearing aids. One subjectively loud, yet little studied, potential sound
hazard is movie theaters. This study uses smart phones to evaluate their
applicability as a widely available, validated sound pressure level (SPL)
meter. Therefore, this study measures sound levels in movie theaters to
determine whether sound levels exceed safe occupational noise expo-
sure limits and whether sound levels in movie theaters differ as a func-
tion of movie, movie theater, presentation time, and seat location within
the theater.
Design: Six smart phones with an SPL meter software application were
calibrated with a precision SPL meter and validated as an SPL meter.
Additionally, three different smart phone generations were measured
in comparison to an integrating SPL meter. Two different movies, an
action movie and a children’s movie, were measured six times each in
10 different venues (n = 117). To maximize representativeness, movies
were selected focusing on large release productions with probable high
attendance. Movie theaters were selected in the San Francisco, CA, area
based on whether they screened both chosen movies and to represent
the largest variety of theater proprietors. Measurements were analyzed
in regard to differences between theaters, location within the theater,
movie, as well as presentation time and day as indirect indicator of film
attendance.
Results: The smart phone measurements demonstrated high accuracy
and reliability. Overall, sound levels in movie theaters do not exceed
safe exposure limits by occupational standards. Sound levels vary
significantly across theaters and demonstrated statistically significant
higher sound levels and exposures in the action movie compared to the
children’s movie. Sound levels decrease with distance from the screen.
However, no influence on time of day or day of the week as indirect indi-
cator of film attendance could be found.
Conclusions: Calibrated smart phones with an appropriate software
application as used in this study can be utilized as a validated SPL meter.
Because of the wide availability, smart phones in combination with the
software application can provide high quantity recreational sound expo-
sure measurements, which can facilitate the identification of potential
noise hazards. Sound levels in movie theaters decrease with distance
to the screen, but do not exceed safe occupational noise exposure lim-
its. Additionally, there are significant differences in sound levels across
movie theaters and movies, but not in presentation time.
Key words: Cinema, Movie, Noise exposure, Noise-induced hearing loss,
Recreational noise, Smart phone, Sensorineural hearing loss, Sound
level measurement, Sound exposure measurement, Theater.
(Ear&Hearing2014;35;680–686)
INTRODUCTION
Permanent sensorineural hearing loss (SNHL) is a major
societal burden with considerable prevalence. Currently, it
affectseverysixthpersoninthedevelopedworld(Shield2006;
Agrawaletal.2008)andanevenhigherpercentageindevel-
oping countries (WHO 2012). SNHL has multiple causes, of
which a prominent contributor is exposure to high levels of
sound(Rabinowitz2010).Todate,noeffectivecausaltherapy
existstoreverseSNHLfollowingsoundoverexposure(noise)
(Oishi&Schacht2011).Therefore,preventionremainscritical
inavoidingtheconsiderableassociatedmorbidity.
Hazardous occupational noise exposures (ONEs) are well
deinedandstandardizedbytheNationalInstituteforOccupa-
tionalHealthandSafety(NIOSH)(NIOSH1998),theAmerican
NationalStandardInstitute(ANSI)(ANSI-S3.441996),andthe
InternationalOrganizationforStandardization(ISO)(ISO-1999
1990).According to these standards, continuous sound levels
greater than 85 dB of A-weighted SPL [dB (A)] for 8 hours
daily are related to an increased lifetime risk of developing
permanentSNHL(ISO-19991990;ANSI-S3.441996;NIOSH
1998).Exposuretooccupationalnoise,however,maynotbean
exposuretocontinuous,butrathertoluctuatingsound levels.
Thus,thetotalenergyof luctuatingsound levelsisexpressed
in a continuous, energy-equivalent sound level (L
eq
) over the
measuredtime(NIOSH1998;Earshen2003).Inadditiontothe
L
eq
,safeONElimitsrepresentanoisedoseand,assuch,further
dependonacceptableexposureduration.Theacceptableexpo-
suredurationisdeterminedbyadeinedexchangerate,which
describestherequiredincreaseinoverallsoundlevelthatneces-
sitates a decrease in exposure time by one half.An exchange
rateof3dBasrecommendedbyNIOSH(NIOSH1998)results
inthereductionofasafeexposuretimefrom8to4hrfor88dB
(A)andto2hrfor91dB(A),respectively.Basedonthesestan-
dards,ONEisregulatedbytheOccupationalHealthandSafety
Administration(OSHA)intheUnitedStates,bytheEuropean
AgencyforSafetyandHealthatWork(EU-OSHA)inEurope,
andbysimilaragenciesinothercountries.
Hazardousrecreationalsoundexposures(RSE),onthecon-
trary,arenotasrigorouslyregulatedordeined as ONE. One
reasonisthattheaccuratemeasurementofRSErequiresboth
measuresofsoundlevelsanddurationinhighlyvariableenvi-
ronments.A second reason for the less rigorous regulation is
that at-risk environments for RSE are generally sought inten-
tionally.Inmostrecreationalenvironmentssuchasmusicclubs
(Babisch2000b)andconcerthalls(Yassietal.1993;Opperman
etal.2006),thesoundlevelanddurationisnotunderthedirect
controloftheindividual.Evenwithusercontrolsuchasself-
adjustedvolumesettingsinpersonalmusicplayers,hazardous
listeninghabitsbasedonONEstandardshavebeenreportedin
10 to 25% of participants (Ising et al. 1994; Williams 2005,
2009).A third reason for the less rigorous regulation of RSE
Comprehensive Measures of Sound Exposures in
Cinemas Using Smart Phones
MarkusE.Huth,
1,2
GeraldR.Popelka,
1
andNikolasH.Blevins
1
1
Department of Otolaryngology, Head and Neck Surgery, Stanford
UniversitySchoolofMedicine,Stanford,California,USA;and
2
Department
ofOtorhinolaryngology,HeadandNeckSurgery,Inselspital,Universityof
Bern,Freiburgstrasse,Bern,Switzerland.