Molecular Dynamics Simulations of CO
2
/Water/Quartz Interfacial
Properties: Impact of CO
2
Dissolution in Water
Gina Javanbakht, Mohammad Sedghi, William Welch, and Lamia Goual*
Department of Chemical and Petroleum Engineering, University of Wyoming, 1000 E. University Avenue, Laramie, Wyoming 82071,
United States
ABSTRACT: The safe trapping of carbon dioxide (CO
2
) in deep saline aquifers is one of the major
concerns of CO
2
sequestration. The amount of capillary trapping is dominated by the capillary pressure
of water and CO
2
inside the reservoir, which in turn is controlled by the interfacial tension (IFT) and
the contact angle (CA) of CO
2
/water/rock systems. The measurement of IFT and CA could be very
challenging at reservoir conditions, especially in the presence of toxic cocontaminants. Thus, the ability
to accurately predict these interfacial properties at reservoir conditions is very advantageous. Although
the majority of existing molecular dynamics (MD) studies of CO
2
/water/mineral systems were able to
capture the trends in IFT and CA variations with pressure and temperature, their predictions often
deviated from experimental data, possibly due to erroneous models and/or overlooked chemical
reactions. The objective of this study was to improve the MD predictions of IFT and CA of CO
2
/
water/quartz systems at various pressure and temperature conditions by (i) considering the chemical reactions between CO
2
and
water and (ii) using a new molecular model for α-quartz surface. The results showed that the presence of carbonic acid at the
CO
2
/water interface improved the predictions of IFT, especially at low temperature and high pressure where more CO
2
dissolution occurs. On the other hand, the effect on CA was minor. The slight decrease in CA observed across the pressure range
investigated could be attributed to an increase in the total number of H-bonds between fluid molecules and quartz surface.
1. INTRODUCTION
The successful sequestration of carbon dioxide (CO
2
) in deep
geological formations requires a minimum leakage of CO
2
through the cap rock. The amount of leakage could be
estimated from the threshold capillary pressure, which in turn is
affected by the interfacial tension (IFT) between CO
2
and the
present fluids, as well as the contact angle (CA) between fluids
and the solid surface, according to the following equation
1
γ θ =
αβ
αβδ
P r [2 cos( )]/
c
,
, , (1)
where γ
α,β
is the interfacial tension between phases α and β and
θ
α,β,δ
is the contact angle between phases α and β and solid
surface δ. Although this relationship applies to perfect capillary
tubes, it is more complicated in pore spaces as pore geometry
affects the capillary pressure.
2,3
In addition to CO
2
sequestration, the prediction of IFT in
CO
2
enhanced oil recovery (EOR) processes is important since
IFT (or γ) controls the spreading coefficient of one fluid over
the others
4
according to
γ γ γ = − − S
gas,brine oil,gas oil,brine (2)
The measurement of IFT and CA at reservoir conditions is
usually very challenging, especially in the presence of
cocontaminants such as SO
2
and NOx. Therefore, the ability
to accurately predict these properties at reservoir conditions
can be very useful. Several research groups have used molecular
dynamics (MD) modeling to estimate the IFT and CA of CO
2
/
water/quartz systems under various conditions.
5-12
In 2007,
Vega and Miguel calculated the surface tension of water in
order to compare different water models.
13
Their study showed
that among molecular models for water, TIP4P/2005
14
could
produce the closest match to experimental data. Other
researchers have reached the same conclusion by using a
dummy particle to carry the negative charge of oxygen atom in
various water models.
14,15
Older water models (e.g., TIP3P,
16
SPC,
17
TIP4P,
14
and SPC/E
18
) were not as accurate as TIP4P/
2005 in predicting the behavior of water molecules during MD
simulations. Several models were also suggested for CO
2
such
as MSM, EPM2, TraPPE, Errington, etc.
5
In order to find the
best model for CO
2
/water systems at high pressure (P) and
temperature (T), Liu et al. examined several existing models for
water (SPC, TIP4P, TIP4P2005) and CO
2
(EPM2, TraPPE)
and found that TraPPE/TIP4P2005 and EPM2/SPC combi-
nations provided the most accurate predictions of CO
2
solubility and IFT variations with P and T.
6,16
Kvamme et al.
used the SPC/E model for water and a simple EMP model for
CO
2
to study the IFT between CO
2
and water at 278-335 K
temperatures and 0.1-20 MPa pressures. Their results were in
good agreement with experimental data and revealed a decrease
in IFT with increasing pressure.
7
More recently, Li et al. studied
the IFT of CO
2
/brine systems at higher P and T using TIP4P
and SPC/E models for water and EPM2 model for CO
2
.
8
They
showed that the SPC/E water model gives a better match
between experimental and simulation data. However, the
simulation errors were higher at elevated pressures.
In addition to IFT, the CA between two fluid phases and a
solid phase controls the capillary pressure of the system. Using
Received: February 3, 2015
Revised: April 14, 2015
Published: May 12, 2015
Article
pubs.acs.org/Langmuir
© 2015 American Chemical Society 5812 DOI: 10.1021/acs.langmuir.5b00445
Langmuir 2015, 31, 5812-5819