Debating the Future of Management Research
Julian Birkinshaw, Mark P. Healey, Roy Suddaby and
Klaus Weber
London Business School; Manchester Business School; University of Alberta; Kellogg School of Management,
Northwestern University
ABSTRACT The Editors of JMS invited four leading scholars in research on management and
organizations to have an open discussion on the current state and future prospects of
management research. Our four contributors discuss, among other things, the growing
influence of economics, psychology, and sociology on current management research, and the
danger of an increasingly fetishistic and formulaic approach to management research that they
believe may lead to stale and narrow contributions. Such an approach carries a risk in the
long run of seriously dampening the intellectual vigour and impact of management research.
Our contributors conclude their discussion with a number of recommendations for
management researchers. These recommendations include asking bigger, better, and more
challenging questions compared to the orthodoxy in our management research and engaging
in modes of research that are not only intellectually challenging but that also have the
potential of making a real impact on management practice.
Keywords: management practice, management research, methods, theory
EDITORS’ INTRODUCTION
To celebrate the 50th anniversary of the Journal of Management Studies and its contribution
to the discipline of management studies, we felt it appropriate to take stock of the
discipline and to explore future directions and challenges. As such, in this Special Issue
devoted to the 50 years of publishing in the Journal of Management Studies, we introduce a
unique format for inquiry. In this article, we have four leading scholars debate and
provide deep insight into an issue we consider core to the future trajectories of research
on management and organizations.
Our motive for initiating this debate is rooted in a simple but important observation.
Whilst management research
[1]
has grown in size and significance over the past couple of
decades, in tandem with the growing size and significance of business education around
Address for reprints: Mark P. Healey, Manchester Business School, The University of Manchester, Booth Street
West, Manchester M15 6PB, UK (mark.healey@mbs.ac.uk).
© 2013 John Wiley & Sons Ltd and Society for the Advancement of Management Studies
Journal of Management Studies 51:1 January 2014
doi: 10.1111/joms.12061