Improvement of Hospital
Performance Through Innovation
Toward the Value of Hospital Care
Casimiro Dias, MPH; Ana Escoval, PhD
The perspective of innovation as the strategic lever of organizational performance has been
widespread in the hospital sector. While public value of innovation can be significant, it is not
evident that innovation always ends up in higher levels of performance. Within this context, the
purpose of the article was to critically analyze the relationship between innovation and perfor-
mance, taking into account the specificities of the hospital sector. This article pulls together pri-
mary data on organizational flexibility, innovation, and performance from 95 hospitals in Portugal,
collected through a survey, data from interviews to hospital administration boards, and a panel of
15 experts. The diversity of data sources allowed for triangulation. The article uses mixed
methods to explore the relationship between innovation and performance in the hospital sector
in Portugal. The relationship between innovation and performance is analyzed through cluster
analysis, supplemented with content analysis of interviews and the technical nominal group. The
main findings reveal that the cluster of efficient innovators has twice the level of performance than
other clusters. Organizational flexibility and external cooperation are the 2 major factors explaining
these differences. The article identifies various organizational strategies to use innovation in order
to enhance hospital performance. Overall, it proposes the alignment of perspectives of different
stakeholders on the value proposition of hospital services, the embeddedness of information
loops, and continuous adjustments toward high-value services. Key words: hospitals, health care
organizations, integrated delivery systems, technology adoption
T
HE HOSPITAL SECTOR in Portugal and
Europe is currently facing evolving needs
and expectations from service users against a
backdrop of fiscal austerity.
1
A renewed fo-
cus on innovation reflects an emerging view
of hospitals as an important source of new
ideas, both for the creation of innovation
within the health sector and in the interface
with other sectors. It is noted that innovation
in the hospital sector can act as a stimulus for
innovation across the economy, through the
provision of technological infrastructure, reg-
ulations, and other framework conditions.
2
‘‘Innovation’’ is the leading theme of the
European Union economic strategy to 2020.
3
It proposes a ‘‘knowledge based economy’’
through research and innovation for sustain-
able development. However, while looking at
the scale and scope of innovation in the health
sector, it is important to avoid the ‘‘proinno-
vation bias.’’ This is based on the assumption
that any innovation is generally good for orga-
nizations and society. Within this context,
there is an increasing focus on the so-called
European Paradox, referring to the assumed
fact that Europe is strong in science but re-
mains weak in innovation.
4,5
However, these apparent paradoxes might
emanate from a narrow understanding of inno-
vation. In fact, previous evidence shows that
investments in science and technology, with-
out organizational changes, have a limited
The Health Care Manager
Volume 32, Number 3, pp. 268–279
Copyright
#
2013 Wolters Kluwer Health |
Lippincott Williams & Wilkins
Author Affiliations: Health Systems and Public Health,
World Health Organization, Copenhagen, Denmark
(Mr Dias); and National School of Public Health,
University Nova Lisboa, Lisbon, Portugal (Dr Escoval).
The authors have no conflicts of interest.
Correspondence: Casimiro Dias, MPH, World Health
Organization, Regional Office for Europe, Division of
Health Systems and Public Health, 8 Scherfigsvej,
DK-2100 Copenhagen Ø, Denmark (diasc@who.int).
DOI: 10.1097/HCM.0b013e31828ef60a
268
Copyright © 2013 Wolters Kluwer Health | Lippincott Williams & Wilkins. Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited.