Chemical Physics Letters 610–611 (2014) 351–356
Contents lists available at ScienceDirect
Chemical Physics Letters
jou rn al hom epage: www.elsevier.com/locate/cplett
Movement of Ng
2
molecules confined in a C
60
cage: An ab initio
molecular dynamics study
Munmun Khatua, Sudip Pan, Pratim K. Chattaraj
∗
Department of Chemistry and Centre for Theoretical Studies, Indian Institute of Technology, Kharagpur 721302, India
a r t i c l e i n f o
Article history:
Received 12 May 2014
Received in revised form 25 June 2014
In final form 26 June 2014
Available online 8 July 2014
a b s t r a c t
An ab initio molecular dynamics study on Ng
2
@C
60
(Ng = He Kr) systems is performed to analyze the
movement of Ng
2
molecules inside a C
60
cage. Within 500 fs time window, the He
2
undergoes preces-
sion encompassing translation, vibration and rotation readily whereas other Ng
2
molecules show usual
vibration but the degrees of translation and rotation decrease with an increase in size of the Ng atoms.
Increase in interaction between the Ng centers and cage carbons and an increased distortion of cage in
moving from He to Kr seem to be responsible for this. During the movement, the Ng
2
units behave as
single entity.
© 2014 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.
1. Introduction
The long-established chemical principle that noble gases (Ng)
are inert and do not take part in chemical bonding was abandoned
after the synthesis of Xe
+
[PtF
6
]
-
by Bartlett [1,2]. Prompted by this
synthesis within a short duration, a good number of Kr Rn com-
pounds [3,4] were synthesized, which further raised the interest
of the researchers in this developing arena named Ng chemistry.
The contributions of Räsänen and co-workers [3–5] in synthesizing
successfully a series of compounds of type H(Ng)Y (Ng = Ar, Kr, Xe;
Y = electron-withdrawing group) and that of Feldman et al. [6] in
preparing Ng hydrides and other related Ng compounds are consid-
ered as significant in enriching this field. The Ng-compounds were
also investigated theoretically by different researchers [7–14].
The study of chemical systems under unusual conditions like
the endohedrally confined one has been a matter of great inter-
est to the scientists. Ever since the discovery of fullerenes in 1985
[15], several methods were developed for producing endohedrally
doped fullerenes since the space inside could hold atoms and even
small molecules. Methods such as ion bombardment and high
pressure/high-temperature techniques [16–22] were used but the
yield was low (<1%) and so the ‘molecular surgery’ method was
used where a hole is chemically opened on the surface of the
fullerene cage, and a gas molecule is inserted reversibly through
the orifice [23–30]. Komatsu et al. added groups to C
60
to create a
∗
Corresponding author.
E-mail addresses: pkc@chem.iitkgp.ernet.in, pratim.chattaraj@gmail.com
(P.K. Chattaraj).
13-membered ring in the carbon cage [27] large enough to permit
H
2
and He to enter [28,29]. They then devised a sequence of reac-
tions that closed the hole, trapping H
2
inside to produce H
2
@C
60
in high yield [30]. Several theoretical and experimental [16,31–34]
studies were also carried out on the endohedrally trapped Ng com-
pounds like Ng
n
@C
60
and Ng
n
@C
70
. These unusual endohedrally
trapped compounds are stable with a van der Waals type of inter-
action in most cases in that there is no chemical bond between the
trapped atom and the carbon cage. Yet, they are very stable, since
several C C bonds must break to allow the atom to escape. In addi-
tion to the fullerene cages, inclusion of Ng atoms in much smaller
cages like C
10
H
16
, C
20
H
20
and Mo
6
Cl
8
F
6
was also studied [35–38].
From a theoretical perspective, noble gas dimers (Ng
2
) confined
in a C
60
and other cages have revealed how the valence electrons
of atoms, which have a fully occupied valence shell, change when
they are confined to strong interatomic interactions at equilibrium
geometry. The theoretical data suggest of a possible new type of
inter-atomic interaction, which would provide material for further
stimulating discussions about the nature of a chemical bond. Cer-
tain quantum-chemical studies about the endohedrally confined
Ng dimers i.e. Ng
2
(Ng = He Xe) in C
60
fullerene cage [39–41]
revealed that the Ng Ng distances in Ng
2
@C
60
are considerably
shorter than those in free Ng dimers. All these Ng
2
@C
60
systems are
thermodynamically unstable toward the loss of Ng atoms. Krapp
and Frenking [40] investigated whether the bonds in between
two Ng atoms or in between Ng and C atoms in Ng
2
@C
60
systems
could be called a chemical bond. With the help of detailed bonding
analysis and IUPAC definition of a chemical bond, they termed the
Ng Ng and Ng C bonds for Ng = Ar Xe as genuine chemical bonds
whereas those in He
2
@C
60
and Ne
2
@C
60
are just weakly bonded
http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.cplett.2014.06.052
0009-2614/© 2014 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.