Inverse Modeling of Water-Rock-CO
2
Batch Experiments: Potential
Impacts on Groundwater Resources at Carbon Sequestration Sites
Changbing Yang,*
,†
Zhenxue Dai,
‡
Katherine D. Romanak,
†
Susan D. Hovorka,
†
and Ramó n H. Treviñ o
†
†
Bureau of Economic Geology, The University of Texas at Austin, 10100 Burnet Road, Austin, Texas 78758, United States
‡
Earth and Environmental Sciences Division, Los Alamos National Laboratory, Los Alamos, New Mexico 87545, United States
* S Supporting Information
ABSTRACT: This study developed a multicomponent geo-
chemical model to interpret responses of water chemistry to
introduction of CO
2
into six water-rock batches with
sedimentary samples collected from representative potable
aquifers in the Gulf Coast area. The model simulated CO
2
dissolution in groundwater, aqueous complexation, mineral
reactions (dissolution/precipitation), and surface complexation
on clay mineral surfaces. An inverse method was used to
estimate mineral surface area, the key parameter for describing
kinetic mineral reactions. Modeling results suggested that
reductions in groundwater pH were more significant in the
carbonate-poor aquifers than in the carbonate-rich aquifers,
resulting in potential groundwater acidification. Modeled
concentrations of major ions showed overall increasing trends, depending on mineralogy of the sediments, especially carbonate
content. The geochemical model confirmed that mobilization of trace metals was caused likely by mineral dissolution and surface
complexation on clay mineral surfaces. Although dissolved inorganic carbon and pH may be used as indicative parameters in
potable aquifers, selection of geochemical parameters for CO
2
leakage detection is site-specific and a stepwise procedure may be
followed. A combined study of the geochemical models with the laboratory batch experiments improves our understanding of the
mechanisms that dominate responses of water chemistry to CO
2
leakage and also provides a frame of reference for designing
monitoring strategy in potable aquifers.
■
INTRODUCTION
One of the critical issues related to geological CO
2
sequestration (GCS) is the potential impact of CO
2
leakage
from the storage formations on underground sources of
drinking water (USDW) in overlying aquifers. Although CO
2
itself is not hazardous to the water quality of USDW, increased
CO
2
concentrations in USDW caused by CO
2
leakage could
lead to a decrease in groundwater pH, potentially enhancing
mineral dissolution, adsorption/desorption, and cation ex-
change reactions, subsequently resulting in mobilization of
major ions and trace metals from aquifer sediments into
groundwater,
1-8
and thus potentially degrade groundwater
quality.
A variety of approaches, including laboratory experi-
ments,
4,6,9,10
field tests,
2,8,11,12
numerical modeling,
5,13-17
and
natural and industrial analogs,
18-20
have been used to (1)
assess risks of CO
2
leakage from deep reservoirs into USDWs
and (2) determine plausible geochemical parameters that might
be used to detect CO
2
leakage in potable aquifers.
13
Few
laboratory experiments of water-rock-CO
2
interaction and field
tests were reported in the literature to investigate how CO
2
was
introduced, in contact with shallow-aquifer sediments and
groundwater. The results show that groundwater pH was
decreased, and some major and trace metals may be mobilized
after introducing CO
2
into the reactors.
1,2,4,6,8,11,21
Limitations
of laboratory batch experiments were also obvious, such as, high
water-rock ratios (usually 4:1), a small amount of sedimentary
samples, and low CO
2
pressure (∼1 atmospheric) which was
applied to the water-rock system.
2,8
To date, much of our
understanding of impacts of the leaked CO
2
on drinking
groundwater quality is based on modeling investigations
because numerical modeling studies can help identify the
physical and geochemical processes that control the effects of
CO
2
introduced into an aquifer and provide information for
risk assessments related to GCS. Wang and Jaffe
14
simulated
dissolution of galena in shallow aquifers as a result of CO
2
leakage and concluded that a decrease in pH would result in
large concentrations of Pb in shallow groundwater. Zheng et
al.
13
simulated reactive transport of CO
2
into a shallow aquifer
for 100 yr and concluded that CO
2
leakage could mobilize As
and Pb in shallow aquifers through mineral dissolution and
surface complex desorption. However, most modeling studies
are subject to considerable uncertainty inherent in model
Received: September 18, 2013
Revised: January 30, 2014
Accepted: February 4, 2014
Article
pubs.acs.org/est
© XXXX American Chemical Society A dx.doi.org/10.1021/es4041368 | Environ. Sci. Technol. XXXX, XXX, XXX-XXX