A 370-year dendroecological history of an
old-growth Abies– Acer – Quercus forest in
Hokkaido, northern Japan
Marc D. Abrams, Carolyn A. Copenheaver, Kazuhiko Terazawa, Kiyoshi Umeki,
Mika Takiya, and Nobuhiro Akashi
Abstract: Dendroecological techniques were used to study the dynamics and species recruitment patterns, spanning
nearly four centuries, for a mesic, montane, old-growth forest in Hokkaido, northern Japan. The forest is dominated by
Abies sachalinensis (Masters), Acer palmatum (Thunb.), Quercus mongolica var. grosseserrata (Rehd.), and
Cercidiphyllum japonicum (Sieb.). From 1620 to 1750 and 1820 to 1840, Q. mongolica exhibited continuous
recruitment into the overstory. A lack of recruitment for all tree species from 1750 to 1820 followed a 1739 volcanic
eruption 200 km from the study area. Release events for individual trees occurred almost every decade of the stand
history, indicating that frequent small-scale disturbances coupled with infrequent large-scale disturbances, impact tree
growth and species recruitment. From 1870 to 1950, canopy recruitment of Abies and Acer dominated the forest, while
recruitment of Quercus ceased. These later successional species appeared to be replacing Quercus, suggesting that the
syndrome of declining oak dominance is an increasingly global phenomenon. However, successional patterns in the
forest are difficult to predict because intensive deer browsing has recently prevented canopy recruitment of all tree
species and the possibility of future large-scale disturbances, such as fire and volcanic eruption.
Résumé : Des techniques dendroécologiques ont été utilisées pour étudier la dynamique et les patrons de recrutement
des espèces, sur près de quatre siècles, d’une vieille forêt montagnarde mésique de l’île de Hokkaido, dans le nord du
Japon. La forêt est dominée par l’Abies sachalinensis (Masters), l’Acer palmatum (Thunb.), le Quercus mongolica var.
grosseserrata (Rehd.) et le Cercidiphyllum japonicum (Sieb.). De 1620 à 1750 et de 1820 à 1840, le Q. mongolica a
montré un recrutement continu dans l’étage dominant. Le manque de recrutement de toutes les espèces entre 1750 et
1820 a suivi une éruption volcanique qui s’est produite en 1739, à 200 km de l’aire étudiée. Le dégagement des arbres
individuels s’est produit presque à chaque décennie de l’histoire du peuplement, indiquant que de fréquentes
perturbations à petite échelle, combinées à des perturbations peu fréquentes à grande échelle, avaient un impact sur la
croissance des arbres et le recrutement des espèces. De 1870 à 1950, le recrutement dans la canopée d’Abies et d’Acer
a dominé la forêt, tandis que celui du Quercus a cessé. Ces dernières espèces successionnelles semblaient être en train
de remplacer le Quercus, suggérant que le syndrome du déclin de la dominance du chêne est un phénomène de plus en
plus global. Toutefois, les patrons de succession forestière sont difficiles à prédire à cause du broutage du cerf, qui a
récemment empêché le recrutement dans la canopée de toutes les espèces arborescentes, et à cause de la possibilité que
surviennent dans le futur des perturbations à grande échelle, telles que les feux et les éruptions volcaniques.
[Traduit par la Rédaction] Abrams et al. 1899
Introduction
Over the past decade, dendroecological techniques have
become an important tool in the study of stand dynamics and
ecological history (Fritts 1976; Fritts and Swetnam 1989).
From tree-ring chronologies, researchers have been able to
reconstruct the historical development of forests in terms of
species recruitment patterns, periodicity and intensity of dis-
turbances, the impacts of yearly climatic variation and ex-
treme weather phenomena, and populations and successional
dynamics (Canham 1985; Foster 1988; Frelich and Graum-
lich 1994; Abrams and Orwig 1995; Abrams et al. 1995).
Coupling tree-ring chronologies, age structure, and land-use
history has proven to be a particularly robust approach for
understanding long-term variation in forest dynamics and
history (Foster 1988; Abrams and Orwig 1995; Abrams et
al. 1997).
Stand dynamics is an important subject of ecological re-
search in Japan, and these studies have provided a substan-
tial data base of information on the regeneration ecology and
population structure of forests, particularly in relation to
canopy gaps (Nakashizuka 1984; Yamamoto 1989; Kubota
1995; Namikawa 1996). However, there have been very few
dendroecological studies conducted in Japan, despite the fact
that most trees produce distinct annual rings. A few recent
papers have reported on the age structure of trees in old-
growth forests and the effects of climatic factors on radial
Can. J. For. Res. 29: 1891–1899 (1999) © 1999 NRC Canada
1891
Received July 6, 1999. Accepted August 5, 1999.
M.D. Abrams
1
and C.A. Copenheaver. School of Forest
Resources, Ferguson Building, Pennsylvania State University,
University Park, PA 16802 U.S.A.
Kiyoshi Umeki, Mika Takiya, Kazuhiko Terazawa, and
Nobuhiro Akashi. Hokkaido Forestry Research Institute,
Bibai, Hokkaido 079-0198, Japan.
1
Corresponding author. e-mail: agl@psu.edu