Q
R
DOI: 10.1177/1468794110385885
Qualitative Research
Copyright © 2011
The Author(s)
http://qrj.sagepub.com
vol. 11(1) 47–68
SHARLENE SWARTZ
Human Sciences Research Council, Cape Town, South Africa
ARTICLE 47
‘Going deep’ and ‘giving back’: strategies for
exceeding ethical expectations when researching
amongst vulnerable youth
ABSTRACT This article interrogates how research amongst vulnerable
populations, especially youth, may be designed and implemented to
exceed the usual standards of research ethics. It describes the dual aims
of ethical research within an emancipatory framework as ‘going deep’
through utilizing ‘an ethics of parallax perspectives’; and ‘giving back’ by
employing an ‘intentional ethics of reciprocation’. It offers a package of
six additional ethical strategies, which may be combined in various
permutations in order to achieve these ends. These strategies include
choosing appropriate research activities; deliberately building
relationships with research participants; conveying researcher
subjectivity; developing mutuality and flattening the power gradient;
considering how language is used and representations are made; and
planning ‘research-as-intervention’. Drawing on a multi-layered
ethnographic study of the moral understandings of a group of
impoverished South African township youth, the article offers insight
into how these ethical strategies address vulnerability and emancipation
in practice, including the multiple ethical dilemmas they raise.
KEYWORDS : emancipatory research, ethnography, morality, poverty, qualitative research,
research ethics, vulnerable youth
Introduction
As a novice researcher, I understood ethics in research to be a consideration of
the moral, legal and professional conduct of researchers in the field and
beyond (Kelly and Ali, 2004). It was easy to glean the three conventional
standards or ‘canons’ (Cloke et al., 2000) of research ethics. Paying attention
to informed consent for research participants, ensuring reasonable confidential-
ity, and undertaking research that aimed to protect (especially children) or do