JOURNALOF ENOODONTICS Printed in U.S.A,
Copyright © 1999 by The American Association of Endodontists VOL. 25, No. 4, APRIL1999
The Dental Hygienist as a Co-therapist in the
Endodontic Practice
Marylou E. Gutmann, RDH, MA, and James L. Gutmann, DDS
This paper explores the potential contributions to
patients, the practice, the endodontist, and the
dental hygienist that may be realized by the em-
ployment of one or more dental hygienists to serve
as endodontic co-therapists in the delivery of end-
odontic treatment. An endodontic co-therapist is
an individual who participates with the endodontist
in the assessment, planning, implementation, and
evaluation of treatment much like the periodontal
co-therapist relationship that exists between peri-
odontists and dental hygienists. Dental hygienists
are ideal individuals for this role because of their
education in basic, clinical, and behavioral sci-
ences. Suggestions are provided for which ser-
vices could be delegated by the endodontist to the
dental hygienist during each phase of care. Advan-
tages of this contemporary approach to the deliv-
ery of endodontic treatment are also addressed.
Imagine seeing this classified advertisement in the employment
section of the Sunday newspaper:
DENTAL HYGIENIST WANTED: Exciting opportunity
for a motivated, caring, registered dental hygienist interested
in a career move that would enable full use of prior education
and experience. Responsibilities will be varied and include
exposure control policies, patient assessment procedures at
multiple levels, specific data preparation, analyses and doc-
umentation, patient treatment, patient education, and practice
management. Salary commensurate with education and ex-
perience.
For the dental hygienist, this type of employment opportunity
sounds too good to be true, but it has the potential to exist in almost
every large endodontic practice.
General dental practices usually employ the greatest numbers of
dental hygienists. However, dental specialists (such as periodon-
tists, pediatric dentists, prosthodontists, and orthodontists) may
also employ dental hygienists (1-5). The only dental specialist that
rarely, if ever, employs a dental hygienist is the endodontist.
272
Various reasons exist for the tack of hygienists in endodontic
specialty practices. One of the primary reasons is economics. An
endodontist can usually employ a dental assistant at a lower salary
than a dental hygienist. Secondly, the scope of practice of dental
hygienists is generally associated with preventive or periodontal
services, although some dental hygienists are involved with restor-
ative services in states where the practice act permits these services
(3). If asked about the possibility of dental hygienists working
within an endodontic practice, most endodontists and dental hy-
gienists would wonder what a dental hygienist would do in this
setting. The purpose of this paper is to explore the potential
contributions to patients, the practice, the endodontist, and the
dental hygienist that may be realized in this contemporary ap-
proach to the delivery of endodontic treatment.
Practice management experts have begun to look at the tradi-
tional roles of allied health personnel in medical, as well as dental,
practices. In addition, the emergence of Health Maintenance Or-
ganizations (HMO's) and Preferred Provider Organizations
(PPO's) has generated an increased emphasis on individualization
of care (including self-care education), office efficiency that hope-
fully results in cost containment, streamlined administrative and
business practices, and effective infection control procedures. As a
result of these various influences, all dental practices have been
encouraged to rethink their structures, business plans, modes of
delivering care, quality assurance procedures, and established
ways of practicing. One approach to meeting these challenges is to
use the depth of education and experience that allied personnel can
provide. This is particularly true in the case of the dental hygienist.
In most dental practices, dental hygienists spend the majority of
their time on one procedure--the scaling and polishing of teeth (3,
6). One practice management expert believes that three major
advantages occur when dentists delegate legally permitted tasks to
dental hygienists (6). Patients are better served at lower costs,
dental hygienists have more diverse responsibilities which in turn
results in increased job satisfaction (7, 8), and finally "dentists are
relieved of some professional tasks" that give them time "to
concentrate on the clinical services that demand their additional
education" (6). Variety in scope of practice also accounts for
long-term retention of dental hygienists in the same practice setting
(7, 9).
A computer-generated search of the literature revealed no in-
formation on the employment of dental hygienists in endodontic
practices. As previously mentioned, other specialties do employ
dental hygienists to provide a variety of patient care and admin-
istrative services (1-5). For example, orthodontists in the United