Review
10.1586/17474108.3.4.539 © 2008 Expert Reviews Ltd ISSN 1747-4108 539 www.expert-reviews.com
Impact of oxidative stress
on IVF
Expert Rev. Obstet. Gynecol. 3(4), 539–554 (2008)
Stefan S du Plessis,
Kartikeya Makker,
Nisarg R Desai and
Ashok Agarwal
†
†
Author for correspondence
Center for Reproductive
Medicine, Glickman
Urological and Kidney
Institute and Ob–Gyn and
Women’s Health Institute,
Cleveland Clinic, 9500 Euclid
Avenue, Desk A19.1,
Cleveland, OH 44195, USA
Tel.: +1 216 444 9485
Fax: +1 216 445 6049
agarwaa@ccf.org
Gametes and embryos are natural sources of free radicals. When manipulated in vitro during
assisted reproductive techniques, these cells run the risk of generating and being exposed to
supraphysiological levels of reactive oxygen species. It is therefore clear that free radicals and
oxidative stress can have a significant impact on IVF outcome. This review summarizes the role
of oxidative stress in the etiology and pathophysiology of human IVF, as well as considering
different strategies and approaches to be followed to prevent the harmful effects of oxidative
stress on IVF.
KEYWORDS: antioxidant • assisted reproductive technology • embryo • free radical • IVF • oocyte • oxidative stress
• reactive oxygen species • spermatozoa
The term oxidative stress (OS) is generally
applied when oxidants outnumber anti-
oxidants [1], when peroxidation products
develop [2] and when these phenomena cause
pathological effects [3,4]. The imbalance
between the production of reactive oxygen
species (ROS) and a biological system’s ability
to readily detoxify the reactive intermediates
or easily repair the resulting damage is known
as OS [5]. All forms of life maintain a reducing
environment within their cells. This reducing
environment is preserved by enzymes that
maintain the reduced state through a constant
input of metabolic energy. Disturbances in
this normal redox state can cause toxic effects
through the production of peroxides and free
radicals that damage all components of the
cell, including proteins, lipids and DNA [6].
The effects of OS depend upon the size of
these changes, with a cell being able to over-
come small perturbations and regain its origi-
nal state. However, more severe OS can cause
cell death, and even moderate oxidation can
trigger apoptosis, while more intense stresses
may cause necrosis [7]. A particularly destruc-
tive aspect of OS is the production of ROS,
which include free radicals and peroxides [8].
Various ROS play an important role in
many physiologic functions, such as phago-
cytosis. Free radicals are also known as a nec-
essary evil for intracellular signaling involved
in the normal processes of cell proliferation,
differentiation and migration [9–11]. In the
reproductive tract, free radicals also play a dual
role and can modulate various reproductive
functions. Physiological levels of ROS influence
and mediate the gametes [12–14] and crucial
reproductive processes, such as sperm–oocyte
interaction [15], implantation and early
embryo development [16]. An imbalance in
the redox state can thus cause OS to develop,
ultimately affecting successful pregnancy
outcome [17–19].
Since the birth of the first IVF baby [20],
assisted reproductive techniques (ART) have
become the treatment of choice in many cases
of male and female infertility [17]. These
methods inevitably require manipulation of
gametes and embryos in vitro, exposing these
cells to additional OS [21]. Various factors, for
example, the absence of cytokines/growth fac-
tors, pH shock, osmotic shock, temperature
fluctuations, UV light damage and nutrient
imbalance can influence the outcome of ART;
however, OS has recently emerged as one of
the most important factors negatively affect-
ing ART outcome [5,22–24]. It has been hypoth-
esized that this is predominantly due to a lack
of in vitro gamete and embryo protection by
oxygen radical scavengers [21,23,25].
The goal of this review is to discuss the pos-
sible sources of ROS that can lead to OS dur-
ing ART, as well as the effects of OS on IVF
outcome. Suggestions and possible solutions to
curtail this necessary ROS evil to prevent OS
in the IVF setting will also be presented.