The chemical stability of coffinite, USiO
4
·nH
2
O; 0 b n b 2, associated with organic
matter: A case study from Grants uranium region, New Mexico, USA
Artur P. Deditius ⁎, Satoshi Utsunomiya
1
, Rodney C. Ewing
Department of Geological Sciences, University of Michigan,1100 N. University Avenue, Ann Arbor, MI 48109-1005, United States
ABSTRACT ARTICLE INFO
Article history:
Received 23 March 2007
Received in revised form 6 February 2008
Accepted 11 February 2008
Edited by: D. Rickard
Keywords:
Coffinite
Organic matter
Alteration
Reducing conditions
Oxidizing conditions
Coarse-grained coffinite [USiO
4
·nH
2
O; n =0–2] from the Upper Jurassic Morrison Formation in the Grants
uranium region, New Mexico, USA, has been investigated in order to understand the processes of coffinite
formation and alteration under reducing and oxidizing conditions. Elongated (up to 35 μm) prismatic crystals
of coffinite precipitated contemporaneously with layers of organic matter (OM) and a vanadium-rich mica in
this sandstone. Three different populations of coffinite were determined based on paragenesis and chemical
composition; i) primary coffinite, (U
0.924
Ca
0.218
Y,REE
0.021
)
1.163
(Si
0.835
P
0.033
As
0.010
)
0.878
O
4
·nH
2
O, that was
partially dissolved by migrating organic acids under reducing conditions; ii) recrystallized coffinite,
(U
0.805
Ca
0.156
Y,REE
0.022
Zr
0.001
)
0.984
(Si
0.954
P
0.036
As
0.005
)
0.995
O
4
·nH
2
O, for which there was a 13% loss of U [apfu]
and 28% loss of Ca [apfu], while Y + La + Ce + Nd [apfu] is enriched 5%. Uranium and REEs were incorporated
into nano-scale crystals of secondary coffinite within the layers of organic matter; iii) coffinite formed during
extensive alteration under oxidizing conditions. This coffinite, (U
0.619
Ca
0.117
Y,REE
0.018
)
0.754
(Si
1.127
P
0.040-
As
0.004
)
1.171
O
4
·nH
2
O, is depleted ~23% of U [apfu], 25% of Ca [apfu] and 18% of Y +REE [apfu], as compared
with coffinite-(ii). (Na,K)-boltwoodite, [(Na,K)(UO
2
SiO
3
OH)(H
2
O)], and a mixture of various uranyl sulfates,
precipitated at the expense of coarse-grained coffinite-(i) as the final products of the alteration under
oxidizing conditions.
Based on charge balance calculations of coffinite groups (i) and (ii), the amount of U
6+
was estimated to be in the
range of 0.1–0.19 [apfu]. An upper limit of 0.2 [apfu] U
6+
is postulated for the coffinite structure. Thus, the ideal
chemical formula of coffinite is: (U
4+
1 - x
U
6+
x
)Si
1 - x
O
4
·nH
2
O, where 0 b x b 0.2; 0 b n b 2. Compositional variations of
coffinite are governed by the substitutions: U
4+
+Si
4+
f U
6+
+ [2(OH)
-
, 0.5 □]; REE
3+
+ As
5+
f U
4+
+Si
4+
; Ca
2+
+ (As,
P)
5+
f REE
3+
+Si
4+
. The variable, but high, totals of the chemical analyses (92.8–99.7 wt.%) suggest that coffinite
contains molecular H
2
O, which is not an essential component of coffinite structure. The amount of H
2
O varies
between 0 and 2 molecules per formula unit, and a minor amount of (OH)
-
may be accommodated into the
structure.
The U–Pb chemical ages limit the age of coffinite precipitation to between 36.6 and 0.7 Ma, which
indicates continuous precipitation of coffinite since the mid-Tertiary. These results suggest that organic
matter, which has preserved reducing conditions even in the presence of oxidizing fluids, over this long
period of approximately 30 million years, plays an important role in the sustained presence of coffinite in
these deposits.
© 2008 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.
1. Introduction
Coffinite, nominally USiO
4
·nH
2
O, I4
1
/amd and Z =4, is one of the
major U
4+
-minerals in economically exploitable U-ores, and coffinite is
the second most abundant source of U in the world (Plant et al., 1999).
Coffinite is an orthosilicate with the general formula of ABO
4
. There
are a large number of possible substitution schemes: A-site: U
6+
, Zr
4+
,
Chemical Geology 251 (2008) 33–49
⁎ Corresponding author. Tel.: +1 734 763 5344; fax: +1 734 647 5706.
E-mail address: deditius@umich.edu (A.P. Deditius).
1
Current address. Kyushu University, Department of Chemistry, Ropponmatsu, 4-2-1,
Chuou-ku, Fukuoka-shi, 810-8560, Japan.
Th
4+
, Hf
4+
, Ca
2+
,Y
3+
, REE
3+
; while for B-site: P
5+
, As
5+
,V
5+
,S
6+
,F
-
and
OH
-
groups, as well as the possibility of vacancies at the tetrahedral
site (e.g., Stieff et al., 1956; Janeczek and Ewing, 1992a; Burns, 1999;
Finch and Hanchar, 2003; Förster, 2006). The presence of multivalent
elements in coffinite implies the possibility of limited or complete
solid solutions between: coffinite–zircon (ZrSiO
4
)–thorite (ThSiO
4
)–
xenotime (YPO
4
)–ningyoite UCa(PO
4
)
2
·1–2H
2
O (e.g., Smits, 1989;
Janeczek and Ewing, 1992a; Finch and Hanchar, 2003; Förster,
2006). However, compositional data for coffinite are limited because:
1) it usually occurs as very fine-grained crystals, b10 μm; 2) it occurs in
intimate intergrowths with large amounts of associated minerals,
such as illite, uraninite and REE-phosphates, which is often the
0009-2541/$ – see front matter © 2008 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.
doi:10.1016/j.chemgeo.2008.02.009
Contents lists available at ScienceDirect
Chemical Geology
journal homepage: www.elsevier.com/locate/chemgeo