1
power systems. An arrester with some kind of failure is not able
to actuate properly during an electrical surge. As a consequence
it will present an excessive heating which can lead to a thermal
runaway [1, 2, 3]. Thermographic inspection is a widely used
method to monitor surge arresters preventing their failure.
When an arrester is substituted due to some abnormality
detected by means of thermal inspection, no further analysis is
done, so that the causes of the problem cannot be evaluated. In
addition, there is no study indicating which are the main causes
of failures in ZnO arresters or if there is another alternative to
the substitution of the. This work presents a study done with 96
kV ZnO arresters presenting the most common failures detected
in substations and their effects on the thermal image.
Index Terms—Arrester, Diagnosis, Failures, Monitoring,
Thermal Image, ZnO.
I. INTRODUCTION
Zinc oxide (ZnO) surge arresters are part of the protection
system of power substations and transmission and distribution
networks. They actuate dumping overvoltages generated by
atmospheric or switching surges, avoiding them to reach
equipments like power transformers.
To work properly, an arrester absorbs part of the surge
energy converting it to thermal energy. A defective arrester
may not be able to work in a satisfactory way when an
electrical surge occurs, presenting an excessive heating. As a
consequence, a thermal runaway can begin, when the leakage
current and the temperature of the arrester increases till its
explosion or break up, risking the power system and people
nearby.
To avoid this kind of problem, power companies have been
more concerned with the operation of their arresters, searching
and improving techniques for their monitoring and
maintenance. The leakage current monitoring and thermal
inspections have been pointed as the most effective techniques
for monitoring and predictive maintenance of ZnO arresters
[4].
This work had the financial support of the Companhia Hidro Elétrica do
São Francisco – Chesf, by means of a Research & Development project with
the Universidade Federal de Campina Grande, and of the Federal government
by means of CAPES.
E. T. Wanderley Neto and E. G. da Costa are with the Universidade
Federal de Campina Grande, Campina Grande, Brasil. (e-mail:
estacio@ee.ufcg.edu.br, edson@ee.ufcg.edu.br).
M. J. A. Maia is with the Companhia Hidro Elétrica do São Francisco,
Recife, Brasil. (mjamaia@chesf.gov.br).
Thermal image analysis is a non-invasive monitoring
technique that has been used for a long time in transmission
lines and power equipments [5]. However, in the case of surge
arresters there is no specific methodology for the application
of thermal monitoring. Each company follows its own
methodology and determines its own parameters to be
analyzed, based on the experience and observation of their
technicians and engineers. Besides that, when an arrester is
pointed as defective by means of thermal inspection, no
further study is conducted to point the causes of failure or an
alternative solution to the replacement of the equipment. So,
the simple acquisition of a thermal image does not lead to a
precise diagnostic. A complete analysis could be done with
more detailed study of the thermal image and the conditions to
which the arrester was submitted.
A complete case study and the creation of a failures
database can become a very important tool to aid the analysis
of suspicious arresters thermal images. Beyond that, it could
help in a precise diagnosis of the problem of the equipment.
This paper presents an study of failures in ZnO arresters was
conducted in the High Voltage Laboratory of the
Universidade Federal de Campina Grande.
II. OBJECTIVES
This study has the main purpose of indicating the most
common failures in arresters and their influences over their
thermal images. This is the starting point for the creation of an
analysis system based in thermal images and artificial
intelligence techniques. In order to achieve this goal, a series
of tests simulating failures in actual 96 kV ZnO arresters was
conducted. These simulated failures correspond to the most
common problems found in arresters in operation. Their
analysis will allow the creation of a more safe criteria to the
replacement of defective arresters. Besides that, arresters
manufactures will be more concerned about the main
problems occurring with their products.
III. FAILURES IN ZNOARRESTERS
The usage of ZnO arresters in power systems has begun at
about 30 years ago. They were created as an evolution of semi
conductive ceramics for electronics and became an alternative
more efficient in relation to the silicon carbide ceramics used
in power surge arresters. Besides the problem related to
failures in ZnO arresters, there is also too little information
about the natural ageing of ZnO varistors. That’s because the
1-4244-0288-3/06/$20.00 ©2006 IEEE
2006 IEEE PES Transmission and Distribution Conference and Exposition Latin America, Venezuela
Failure Analysis in ZnO Arresters Using
Thermal Images
E. T. Wanderley Neto, E. G. da Costa, T. V. Ferreira, and M. J. A. Maia