ORIGINAL ARTICLE
Acute Changes in Vascular Function Among Welders
Exposed to Metal-Rich Particulate Matter
Shona C. Fang,* Ellen A. Eisen,* Jennifer M. Cavallari,* Murray A. Mittleman,†‡ and
David C. Christiani*§
Background: Although welding fume exposure is associated with
adverse cardiovascular outcomes, the mechanisms remain unclear.
To investigate the role of vascular function, we assessed levels of the
augmentation index (a correlate of arterial stiffness) after short-term
exposure to welding-derived fine particulate matter (PM
2.5
).
Methods: In a panel study, we monitored 26 male welders over 24
hours on a welding day (n = 25), a nonwelding day (n = 15), or
both (n = 14). Augmentation index (expressed as a percent) was
obtained in the morning before exposure (baseline) and after expo-
sure in the afternoon and the following morning. Personal PM
2.5
exposure was measured over 6 hours of welding or an equivalent
nonwelding period. We used linear mixed models adjusting for
baseline augmentation index, smoking, age, and time to evaluate the
effects of welding (binary) and PM
2.5
(continuous) on augmentation
index levels. We also assessed modification by welding exposure the
day before monitoring (binary).
Results: Welding was associated with a 2.8% increase in afternoon
augmentation index (95% confidence interval =-1.4 to 7.0) and a
2.4% decrease (-6.9 to 2.2) in next-morning augmentation index.
Additional exposure the day prior to monitoring was associated with
a greater afternoon increase (5.1%; 0.8 to 9.5). Using PM
2.5
con-
centration, a positive association was observed in the afternoon and
an inverse association the next morning; results differed by previous
day’s welding status after excluding outliers.
Conclusions: Subsequent to welding fume exposure, there is an
increase in afternoon augmentation index and a decrease in next-
morning augmentation index, with greater changes after consecutive
days of exposure. These results suggest that exposure to the PM
2.5
component of welding fume elicits acute adverse vascular responses.
(Epidemiology 2008;19: 217–225)
W
elding fume is a complex mixture containing metal-
rich airborne particulate matter (PM), generated when
heated metal vaporizes and condenses in air. Exposure in-
cludes high concentrations of respirable particles with an
aerodynamic diameter 2.5 m (PM
2.5
). Although the pul-
monary health effects of welding fume exposures are well-
known,
1
there is growing concern for the cardiovascular
health effects. Several mortality studies report increased risk
of death from ischemic heart disease among welders.
2–4
In
addition, the prevalence of myocardial infarction and other
cardiovascular events and symptoms are increased in weld-
ers.
5
The underlying mechanisms responsible for these car-
diovascular effects are largely unclear; however, a role for
vascular function may be involved.
6,7
Several studies have
demonstrated vasoconstriction and increases in blood pres-
sure after short-term exposure to ambient PM.
8 –12
Vascular
changes may be mediated by direct action of PM on lung
receptors
13
or via inflammatory pathways.
14
In observational studies, vasoconstriction has been
measured by vasoreactivity and brachial artery diameter.
8,9
These measurements are not feasible in workplace studies
where practical restrictions warrant the use of simpler tech-
niques. One component of vascular function that is easily
measured with a portable device is the aortic augmentation
index, a measure of wave reflections that relates to central
aortic pulse pressure, and is a correlate of arterial stiffness.
15
It is derived from reflective properties of the arterial bed and
is measured reproducibly
16,17
by the noninvasive technique
of pulse wave analysis. Increased augmentation index is
associated with advancing age, hypertension, diabetes, and
hypercholesterolemia.
18 –20
The measurement is also a strong
and independent marker of established coronary artery dis-
ease
21
and correlates with risk of coronary artery disease
development.
22
Acute increases in the augmentation index
are observed in individuals after exposure to first- and sec-
ond-hand cigarette smoking.
23,24
However, the relation be-
tween the augmentation index and metal-rich occupational
particulate exposures has not been studied.
We conducted a panel study to investigate the relation-
ship between short-term exposure to metal-rich PM
2.5
and the
augmentation index over a 24-hour period in a group of
welders on either or both a welding and a nonwelding day.
The augmentation index was evaluated with respect to weld-
Submitted 22 March 2007; accepted 23 August 2007; posted 29 January 2008.
From the Departments of *Environmental Health, †Epidemiology, Harvard
School of Public Health, ‡Cardiovascular Epidemiology Research Unit,
Beth Israel Deaconess Medical Center, and §Department of Medicine,
Massachusetts General Hospital, Boston, Massachusetts.
Supported by NIEHS grants ES009860 and ES00002 and a pilot project grant
awarded under the Harvard-NIOSH Education and Research Center grant
T42 OH008416. Supported by NIOSH training grant T42 OH008416 (to
S.F. and J.C.) and NIEHS training grant T32 ES007069 (to J.C.).
Correspondence: David C. Christiani, Environmental and Occupational
Medicine and Epidemiology Program, Department of Environmental
Health, Harvard School of Public Health, 665 Huntington Avenue,
Building I-Room 1402, Boston, MA 02115. E-mail: dchris@hsph.
harvard.edu.
Copyright © 2008 by Lippincott Williams & Wilkins
ISSN: 1044-3983/08/1902-0217
DOI: 10.1097/EDE.0b013e31816334dc
Epidemiology • Volume 19, Number 2, March 2008 217