Weed seed decay in conventional and diversified
cropping systems
RG Ó MEZ*, M LIEBMAN † & G MUNKVOLD‡
*Escuela de Agronom ıa, Universidad de Costa Rica, San Jos e, Costa Rica, †Department of Agronomy, Iowa State University, Ames, IA,
USA, and ‡Department of Plant Pathology and Microbiology, Iowa State University, Ames, IA, USA
Received 21 January 2013
Revised version accepted 16 July 2013
Subject Editor: Jonathan Storkey, Rothamsted Research, UK
Summary
Diversified cropping systems can have high soil micro-
bial biomass and thus strong potential to reduce the
weed seedbank through seed decay. This study, con-
ducted in Iowa, USA, evaluated the hypothesis that
weed seed decay is higher in a diversified 4-year
maize–soyabean–oat/lucerne–lucerne cropping system
than in a conventional 2-year maize–soyabean rota-
tion. Mesh bags filled with either Setaria faberi or
Abutilon theophrasti seeds and soil were buried at two
depths in the maize phase of the two cropping systems
and sampled over a 3-year period. Setaria faberi seed
decay was consistently greater at 2 cm than at 20 cm
burial depth and was higher in the more diverse rota-
tion than in the conventional rotation in 1 year. Abuti-
lon theophrasti seeds decayed very little in comparison
with seeds of S. faberi. Separate laboratory and field
experiments confirmed differences in germination and
seed decay among the seed lots evaluated each year.
Fusarium, Pythium, Alternaria, Cladosporium and
Trichoderma were the most abundant genera colonising
seeds of both species. A glasshouse experiment deter-
mined a relationship between Pythium ultimum and
S. faberi seed decay. Possible differences in seed
susceptibility to decay indicate the need to evaluate
weed seedbank dynamics in different cropping systems
when evaluating overall population dynamics and for-
mulating weed management strategies.
Keywords: weed management, seedbank, Setaria faberi,
giant foxtail, Abutilon theophrasti, diversified crop
rotations, soil microorganisms, seed pathogens, organic
matter.
GÓMEZ R, LIEBMAN M&MUNKVOLD G (2014). Weed seed decay in conventional and diversified cropping systems.
Weed Research 54, 13–25.
Introduction
Crop rotations comprised of crops with different life
cycles can have detrimental effects on weed population
growth (Liebman & Gallandt, 1997), with different
planting and harvest dates among crops preventing or
reducing either plant establishment or seed production
by weeds (Bastiaans et al., 2008). In diversified crop-
ping systems, the use of forage legumes as green
manure and livestock manure to provide organic
sources of nutrients and organic matter can reduce
weed emergence, by affecting small seeded weeds
through the release of allelochemicals or by providing
substrates for other organisms that inhibit seedling
growth (Liebman & Davis, 2000; Mohler et al., 2012).
Previous work by Liebman et al. (2008) at a long-
term field experiment established in Iowa, USA,
assessed the effect of simple and more diverse cropping
systems on weed seed densities in soil. Over a 4-year
period, decline of an experimentally supplemented
seedbank of Setaria faberi Herrm. (giant foxtail) was
greater in a 2-year maize (Zea mays L.) – soyabean
Correspondence:RG omez, Escuela de Agronom ıa, Universidad de Costa Rica, San Jos e, Costa Rica. Tel: (+506) 2511 7782;
Fax: (+506) 2433 9086; E-mail: gomez.robin@gmail.com
© 2013 European Weed Research Society 54, 13–25
DOI: 10.1111/wre.12052