Seizures Decrease Postnatal Neurogenesis and Granule Cell
Development in the Human Fascia Dentata
*Gary W. Mathern, *James L. Leiphart, *Adelaine De Vera, †P. David Adelson, ‡Tatsunori Seki,
§Luciano Neder, and §Joao P. Leite
*Division of Neurosurgery, The Mental Retardation Research Center, and The Brain Research Institute, University of California,
Los Angeles, Los Angeles, California, and †Department of Neurosurgery, University of Pittsburgh, Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania,
U.S.A.; ‡Department of Anatomy, Juntendo University School of Medicine, Tokyo, Japan; and §Departments of Neurology and
Pathology, Ribeira ˜o Preto School of Medicine, University of Sa ˜o Paulo, Ribeira ˜ o Preto, Brazil
Summary: Purpose: There is considerable controversy
whether childhood seizures damage existing neurons and/or
adversely affect neurogenesis and synaptogenesis. This study
addressed this question by examining fascia dentata neurogen-
esis, cell death, and aberrant axon connections in hippocampi
from children with extratemporal seizure foci.
Methods: Surgically resected (n 53) and age-comparable
autopsy (n 22) hippocampi were studied for neuronal den-
sities, polysialic acid (PSA) neural cell adhesion molecule
(NCAM) immunoreactivity (IR), TUNEL, and neo-Timm’s
histochemistry.
Results: Compared with autopsy cases, hippocampi from
children with frequent seizures showed (a) decreased fascia
dentata granule cell densities; (b) decreased PSA NCAM IR
cell densities in the stratum granulosum, infragranular, and hi-
lar regions; (c) no positive TUNEL-stained cells; and (d) ab-
errant supragranular mossy fiber axon connections.
Conclusions: These results indicate that severe seizures dur-
ing early childhood are associated with anatomic signs of de-
creased postnatal granule cell neurogenesis (PSA NCAM IR)
and aberrant mossy fiber axon connections (neo-Timm’s) with-
out evidence of seizure-induced cell death (TUNEL). In hu-
mans, these results support the concept that seizures do not
damage existing neurons, but adversely affect processes in-
volved with normal postnatal neuronal development such as
neurogenesis and axon formation. Such alterations probably
negatively affect normal brain development, and/or promote
epileptogenesis. Key Words: Hippocampus—Mossy fibers—
Synaptogenesis—Epilepsy.
The effects of seizures in the developing brain differ
compared with those in the mature brain. In adult ani-
mals, frequent seizures and/or status epilepticus result in
neuronal loss, aberrant axon sprouting, and long-term
deficits in learning, memory, and behavior (1,2). Similar
experiments in immature rats demonstrate minimal or no
pathology unless the brain insults are severe, and even
then, the amount of damage is generally less than with
the same insult in adult rats (3–5). Some authors have
concluded, therefore, that the immature brain is resistant
to seizure-induced neuronal damage. However, these ex-
periments do not address whether seizures adversely af-
fect other developmental processes, such as postnatal
neurogenesis, axogenesis, and synaptogenesis, which are
equally important components of early brain develop-
ment.
Previous animal studies demonstrated that neonatal
seizures may adversely affect some aspects of brain de-
velopment, and in adult rats, reported increased postsei-
zure neurogenesis of fascia dentata granule cells (6–10).
Another study, however, showed that granule cell neu-
rogenesis was reduced in postnatal (PN) day 1–4 rats
with repeated flurothyl-induced seizures (11). Hence, it
is unclear if seizures during early hippocampal develop-
ment might alter postnatal granule cell neurogenesis, and
whether this is associated with aberrant mossy fiber
sprouting. Previous human studies from our laboratory
found decreased granule cell densities in young patients
with extratemporal seizures (12,13). Whether decreased
granule cell densities began early in life or were the
consequence of repeated seizures over time was unclear
because of the small sample size. Likewise, it was un-
known if decreased granule cell numbers were from re-
duced neurogenesis or seizure-induced cell death of
already formed granule cells. The current human study
addresses these questions by performing immunocyto-
chemistry (ICC) for polysialic acid (PSA) neural cell
Address correspondence and reprint requests to Dr. G.W. Mathern at
Division of Neurosurgery, Reed Neurological Research Center, 710
Westwood Plaza, Room 2123, Los Angeles, CA 90095-1769, U.S.A.
E-mail: gmathern@ucla.edu
Epilepsia, 43(Suppl. 5):68–73, 2002
Blackwell Publishing, Inc.
© International League Against Epilepsy
68