DGT-Induced Copper Flux Predicts Bioaccumulation and Toxicity to
Bivalves in Sediments with Varying Properties
Stuart L. Simpson,*
,†
He ́ loïse Yverneau,
†,‡
Anne Cremazy,
†,§
Chad V. Jarolimek,
†
Helen L. Price,
∥
and Dianne F. Jolley
∥
†
Centre for Environmental Contaminants Research, CSIRO Land and Water, Locked Bag 2007, Kirrawee, NSW 2234, Australia
‡
Ecole Nationale Supe ́ rieure de Chimie de Montpellier-National Graduate School of Chemistry of Montpellier, Montpellier 34296,
France
§
Universite ́ de Bordeaux 1, 33600 Pessac, France
∥
School of Chemistry, University of Wollongong, NSW 2522, Australia
* S Supporting Information
ABSTRACT: Many regulatory frameworks for sediment quality assessment include
consideration of contaminant bioavailability. However, the “snap-shots” of metal
bioavailability provided by analyses of porewaters or acid-volatile sul fide-
simultaneously extractable metal (AVS-SEM) relationships do not always contribute
sufficient information. The use of inappropriate or inadequate information for
assessing metal bioavailability in sediments may result in incorrect assessment
decisions. The technique of diffusive gradients in thin films (DGT) enables the in
situ measurement of metal concentrations in waters and fluxes from sediment
porewaters. We utilized the DGT technique to interpret the bioavailability of copper
to the benthic bivalve Tellina deltoidalis in sediments of varying properties
contaminated with copper-based antifouling paint particles. For a concentration
series of copper-paint contaminated sandy, silty-sand, and silty sediment types, DGT-
probes were used to measure copper fluxes to the overlying water, at the sediment-
water interface, and in deeper sediments. The overlying water copper concentrations and DGT-Cu fluxes were shown to provide
excellent exposure concentration−response relationships in relation to lethal effects occurring to the copper-sensitive benthic
bivalve, T. deltoidalis. The study demonstrates the strength of the DGT technique, which we expect will become frequently used
for assessing metal bioavailability in sediments.
■
INTRODUCTION
The technique of diffusive gradients in thin films (DGT) was
developed to enable the in situ measurement of metal
concentrations in waters
1
and fluxes from sediment pore-
waters.
1,2
In a DGT device, dissolved metal species diffuse
through a polyacrylamide gel layer and become trapped in a gel
impregnated with a metal-exchange resin, which acts as a metal
sink.
3
The removal of metals from sediment porewaters causes
the concentration to decline immediately adjacent to the
device. This localized decline could disturb the dynamic
equilibrium between the sediment and metal in solution and
induced release of metals to solution,
4
the extent of which will
depend on the rate of metal resupply from the sediment solid
phase to the porewater. If there is rapid resupply, metal
concentrations in porewaters may be calculated from the DGT-
accumulated metal concentration. However, when resupply
from the sediments is limited, the DGT-flux provides
information on the relative rate of remobilization of metals
from sediments to the porewater.
5
Hence the DGT directly
measures the flux of metal from the sediment during the
deployment time, which reflects the concentration in the
porewater, its diffusional transport, and the supply from the
solid phase to solution.
6
It can be interpreted simply as the
average porewater concentration at the interface of the device
over the deployment period. The ability of DGT measurements
to provide information on the localized remobilization of
metals has been utilized to create high-resolution depth profiles
of metals within sediments.
2,7
Such studies have demonstrated
the heterogeneity of sediment environments, including the
existence of microniches and to characterize zones of metal
remobilization.
8−10
Existing methods for estimating the bioavailability of metals
in sediments to benthic organisms have numerous limita-
tions.
11,12
For example, the usefulness of chemical extractions
that provide information on metal lability varies between metals
and the degree of contamination and for the organism being
studied.
13,14
Further to this, the equilibrium partitioning
relationships between metals and acid-volatile sulfide (AVS)
become less appropriate for organisms that create oxic/suboxic
Received: April 4, 2012
Revised: July 14, 2012
Accepted: July 24, 2012
Published: July 24, 2012
Article
pubs.acs.org/est
© 2012 American Chemical Society 9038 dx.doi.org/10.1021/es301225d | Environ. Sci. Technol. 2012, 46, 9038−9046