Directly Photoinscribed Thick Bragg Gratings in Ohara
WMS-15 Glass-Ceramic
Peter A. Krug, Rodica Matei Rogojan and Jacques Albert
Department of Electronics, Carleton University, 1125 Colonel By Drive, Ottawa, ON K1S 5B6, Canada
pkrug@doe.carleton.ca
Abstract: Volume gratings were UV inscribed in WMS-15 glass-ceramic at 193 and 248nm
without additional processing. Weak, easily bleached gratings resulted from fluences below
0.3kJ/cm
2
. Stable gratings with Δn ~ 6×10
-5
were formed at higher fluences.
©2009 Optical Society of America
OCIS codes: (050.7330) Volume gratings; (160.5335) Photosensitive materials
1. Introduction
Glass-ceramics, which combine many useful properties including a wide range of values (negative, zero or positive)
of both thermal expansion and thermo-optic coefficients, are obtained by the controlled nucleation and
crystallization of glass [1]. Glass-ceramics that are sufficiently transparent to be used in transmissive optical
components have recently been reported and have become available commercially [2,3]. Diffraction gratings have
previously been photoinduced in glass-ceramics by UV exposure, followed by chemical etching [4], thermal
treatment [5] or both [6]. Here we report, for the first time to our knowledge, the direct photoinscription of
diffraction gratings in a glass-ceramic without the need for any subsequent processing.
2. UV Inscription of gratings
The composition of Ohara WMS-15 transparent glass-ceramic [7] is a trade secret, but the material is known to
contain oxides of Si, Al, Zr, P, and possibly Zn and Sb. Polished 3mm thick samples were exposed through zero
order nulled phase mask to spatially uniform beam with energy densities of 226mJ/cm
2
/pulse (25 pulses per second
at 248nm) or 36mJ/cm
2
/pulse (100 pulses per second at 193nm). The grating depths were calculated from the
angular dependence of diffraction efficiency [8] to be between 127 ± 20 and 254 ± 20μm for the 248nm written
gratings but only 8.5 ± 2μm for the 193nm written gratings. From the depths and the Bragg diffraction efficiencies
measured using a collimated laser beam at 632.8nm, we determined the index modulation depth of gratings written
with UV doses between 0.01 and 30kJ/cm
2
, as shown in Fig. 1.
0.01 0.1 1 10
10
-7
10
-6
10
-5
10
-4
High UV Exposure Dose
Wavelength
193nm
248nm
Index Modulation Depth
UV Exposure Dose (kJ/cm
2
)
Low UV Exposure Dose
No anneal
100°(5h)
100° (91h)
200°
300°
400°
500°
10
-7
10
-6
10
-5
10
-4
10
-3
10
-2
Dose (kJ/cm
2
)
30
10
3
1
0.3
0.1
0.03
0.01
Diffraction Efficiency
Maximum Annealing Temperature (°C)
Fig. 1. Refractive index modulation depth as a function of dose. Fig. 2. Grating diffraction efficiency as a function of annealing.
We see that there are two very distinctly different regions of grating formation. For UV doses less than
0.3kJ/cm
2
we observe the rapid formation of weak gratings, having diffraction efficiency less than 2×10
-5
. For
248nm inscription, these gratings reach maximum strength at the relatively low dose of 0.03kJ/cm
2
, after which their
strength decreases with increasing dose up to 0.3kJ/cm
2
. For UV doses of 1kJ/cm
2
and above, much stronger grating
growth is observed, with the gratings continuing to grow with increasing UV dose up to the maximum applied dose
of 30kJ/cm
2
. The strongest grating in the high UV dose regime, written at 30kJ/cm
2
, has an index modulation depth
of around 6×10
-5
, which is around 25 times the modulation depth of the strongest grating in the low UV dose