Journal of Molecular Catalysis A: Chemical 215 (2004) 201–208
Acylation of toluene using rare earth cation exchanged
zeolite as solid acid catalyst
V.N. Sheemol, Beena Tyagi, Raksh V. Jasra
∗
Silicates and Catalysis Discipline, Central Salt and Marine Chemicals Research Institute (CSMCRI), G.B. Marg, 364002 Bhavnagar, India
Received 25 September 2003; received in revised form 16 January 2004; accepted 3 February 2004
Abstract
The catalytic activity of rare earth cations exchanged zeolite was studied for the acylation of toluene with acetic anhydride as an acylating
agent and nitrobenzene, o-dichlorobenzene and dichloroethane as the solvent in liquid phase in the temperature range of 368–408 K. The rare
earth cation exchanged zeolites were observed to have the catalytic activity in the following order: La- > H- = Ce- > Dy- > Eu- >
Sm- > Gd- > Nd- > Pr- with more than 95% selectivity towards the p-isomer. Among the solvents studied, nitrobenzene is the most
favored for toluene acylation reaction. The correlation of catalytic activities of the different catalysts with the cyclohexanol dehydration as
well as DRIFT spectroscopy showed that the toluene acylation is a Brönsted acid catalyzed reaction.
© 2004 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.
Keywords: Acylation; Toluene; Rare earth cation; Zeolite ; Brönsted acidity
1. Introduction
The acylated aromatic compounds are prominent interme-
diates in many of the organic syntheses especially in pharma-
ceutical and fine chemical industry. Presently, Friedel–Crafts
acylation of aromatic compounds is commercially done [1]
using Lewis acids such as AlCl
3
, BF
3
, ZnCl
2
, TiCl
4
, FeCl
3
as well as Brönsted acids like polyphosphoric acid and hy-
drofluoric acid. However, these traditional catalysts have
limitations such as environmental pollution hazards arising
from the disposal of potential toxic wastes, reactor corrosion
and difficulty in handling. Furthermore, the catalyst amount
to be employed is more than the stoichiometric quantity re-
quired as the catalyst has a tendency for complex formation
either with the reactants or products [2]. Therefore, con-
siderable research efforts are directed to develop alternative
suitable catalysts to overcome these drawbacks. Zeolites,
clays, and ionic resins are potential solid acid materials for
developing catalysts to overcome above-mentioned limita-
tions. Zeolites, particularly, exhibit good thermal stability,
shape selectivity, and ease to modify their surface acidity by
simpler processes like cation exchange. The present study
∗
Corresponding author. Tel.: +91-278-2471793;
fax: +91-278-2567-562.
E-mail address: rvjasra@csir.res.in (R.V. Jasra).
reports the liquid phase acylation of toluene with rare earth
exchanged zeolite using acetic anhydride as an acylating
agent. Methyl-p-tolylketone, p-isomer of acylated toluene is
a colorless liquid with a penetrating floral fruity odor and
finds applications in perfumery, flavors and fragrance in-
dustry. There are some reports on the acylation of toluene
with different acylating agents using solid acids. For exam-
ple, Chiche et al. [3] has reported the acylation of toluene
with C
2
to C
22
alkanoic acids with CeNa-Y (70% cation ex-
change) and reported the maximum yield for C
12
and C
14
acids. Acetic acid was not observed to be effective for acy-
lation. Gauthier et al. [4] from their study of acylation of
toluene with octanoic acid and cation exchanged zeolite-Y
concluded that acylation can also be catalyzed by Brönsted
acid sites. Phosphotungstic acid (H
3
PW
12
O
40
) supported on
silica was shown [5] to be more active than zeolite-Y and
for acylation of toluene with crotonic acid. The acylation of
lower aromatics with ion-exchanged montmorillonite clay
has been discussed by Chiche et al. [6] and showed that
Al
3+
exchanged clay was most active for acylation. It is re-
ported that, the activity of La-exchanged zeolite-Y increases
with an increase of La
3+
content in the zeolite for the acy-
lation of toluene with acetyl chloride as an acylating agent
[7]. It was observed from earlier studies on the acylation
of aromatic compounds like anisole, veratrole and isobutyl-
benzene [8,9] that rare earth cations exchanged zeolites and
1381-1169/$ – see front matter © 2004 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.
doi:10.1016/j.molcata.2004.02.002