Lanthanide-Containing Molecular and Supramolecular Polymetallic Functional
Assemblies
Jean-Claude G. Bu ¨nzli*
,†
and Claude Piguet*
,‡
Institute of Molecular and Biological Chemistry, Swiss Federal Institute of Technology, BCH 1402, CH-1015 Lausanne, and the Department of
Inorganic, Analytical and Applied Chemistry, University of Geneva, 30 quai Ernest Ansermet, CH-1211 Geneva 4, Switzerland
Received January 21, 2002
Contents
I. Introduction 1
II. Lanthanide Ions as Functional Centers in
Elaborate Molecular Edifices
3
A. Redox Centers and Lewis Acids 3
B. Optical, Spectroscopic, and Magnetic Probes 5
III. Synthesis of Elaborated Lanthanide-Containing
Edifices
8
A. Lock-and-Key Principle in Monometallic
Lanthanide Complexes
9
B. Induced Fit Principle in Monometallic
Lanthanide Complexes
10
C. Planning Discrete Lanthanide-Containing
Polymetallic Assemblies
11
D. Innovative Synthetic Routes to
Lanthanide-Containing Polymetallic
Assemblies
17
IV. Functional Polymetallic Assemblies Triggered by
Intermetallic Communications
18
A. Edifices Containing 4f- and s-Block Ions 18
B. Edifices Containing 4f- and d-Block Ions 19
1. Communication Based On Orbital Overlap 19
2. Electrostatic Communication 19
3. Mechanical Coupling 21
C. Edifices Containing Two (or More) 4f-Block
Ions
22
1. Communication Based On Orbital Overlap 22
2. Electrostatic Communication 22
3. Mechanical Coupling 23
V. Toward Programmed Functional Extended
Networks
24
A. Clusters 24
B. Self-Assembled Supramolecular Polymetallic
Edifices
25
C. One-Dimensional Arrays 25
D. Two-Dimensional Arrays 27
E. Three-Dimensional Arrays 27
VI. Outlook 28
VII. Acknowledgments 29
VIII. References 29
I. Introduction
As a result of the different degrees of stabilization
experienced by the 4f, 5d, and 6s orbitals occurring
upon ionization of the neutral metal, the lanthanides
(La-Lu, Z ) 57-71) exist almost exclusively in their
trivalent state Ln(III) ([Xe]4f
n
, n ) 0-14) in coordi-
nation complexes or supramolecular assemblies.
1
Except for some arene compounds involving bulky
substituted benzenes or cyclo-octatetraenes,
2
cova-
lence plays a minor role in Ln-ligand dative bonds
and the nature of the coordination sphere is con-
trolled by a subtle interplay between electrostatic
interactions and interligand steric constraints.
3
Vari-
able coordination numbers (6 e CN e 12) and
geometries are thus observed in lanthanide com-
plexes, leading to limited success in the design of
molecular architectures with predetermined struc-
tures.
3,4
Although rigid or semirigid receptors may
help to control the coordination sphere according to
the lock-and-key and induced fit concepts,
5
detailed
studies of lanthanide solvates with water or aceto-
nitrile suggest that trivalent lanthanides display a
tendency to adopt nine-coordinate tricapped trigonal
prismatic (TTP) arrangements around the metal ion
in the solid state. In solution, the picture is a little
more subtle:
6
in water, for instance, large Ln(III) ions
at the beginning of the series (Ln ) La-Nd) adopt
TTP geometries, which are gradually transformed
into eight-coordinate square antiprismatic (SAP)
arrangements for small Ln(III) ions (Ln ) Tb-Lu),
equilibria between CN ) 8 and CN ) 9 being
observed for Ln ) Nd-Tb.
7
The systematic contrac-
tion of the ionic radii observed when going from
Ln ) La to Lu (often referred to as the lanthanide
contraction)
8
explains this trend and increases elec-
trostatic bonding for heavier lanthanides, but this
variation is so smooth and limited (15% contraction
between La and Lu and ≈1% between two successive
lanthanides) that selective recognition and incorpora-
tion into organized supramolecular architectures
remains challenging.
5
A rational access to extended
polymetallic lanthanide-containing assemblies with
predictable and controlled geometries is consequently
very limited, and pioneer work in this field has
focused on poorly characterized intricate mixtures of
complexes in solution which are ‘transformed’ into
well-defined solid-state clusters or networks through
crystallization processes involving a rich palette of
†
Institute of Molecular and Biological Chemistry, Lausanne.
E-mail: Jean-Claude.Bunzli@epfl.ch.
‡
Department of Inorganic, Analytical and Applied Chemistry,
Geneva. E-mail: Claude.Piguet@chiam.unige.ch.
10.1021/cr010299j CCC: $39.75 © xxxx American Chemical Society
PAGE EST: 31.8 Published on Web 00/00/0000