Design of a Fault-Tolerant 6-phase Switched
Reluctance Motor for Electric Power-Assisted
Steering Systems
C. Martis*, C. Oprea*, I.A. Viorel* and J. Gyselinck**
*Technical University of Cluj Napoca
15, Daicoviciu, Cluj-Napoca, RO-400020, Romania
**Université Libre de Bruxelles
50, Avenue Franklin Roosevelt, Brussels, B-1050, Belgium
Abstract – In this paper a six-phase switched reluctance motor
for electric power-assisted steering systems is proposed. Based on
the specification data the main motor dimensions are obtained via
a dedicated sizing-design procedure. The motor parameters and
characteristics are computed by using three methods, namely
using a finite element model, a magnetic equivalent circuit model
and using analytical formulas. The flux linkage and
electromagnetic torque as a function of rotor position and phase
current are calculated, showing that the steady state motor
characteristics are adequate for the purposed drive.
I. INTRODUCTION
Electric actuation is one of the actual trends in the
automotive industry, due to its high reliability, energy
efficiency and controllability [1]. The use of electrical and
electronic systems, such as electronic automatic climate
control, entertainment systems, antilock brakes (ABS), traction
control systems, enhances customer comfort, convenience and
safety. New electric systems eliminate the traditional pumps,
hoses, hydraulic fluid, drive belt and pulley on the engine,
significantly increasing fuel economy.
Electric power-assisted steering (EPAS) systems have
already begun replacing the hydraulic power steering ones,
simplifying vehicle assembly and offering more room in the
engine compartment. An EPAS system incorporates a steering
gear, assist mechanism, an electric motor and its electronic
controller to provide responsive steering assist. Normally,
sensors measure two primary inputs: applied torque on the
steering wheel and the position of the latter. EPAS solutions
can be separated into categories according to the location of the
electric motor that provides steering assistance, as: column-
type, pinion-type, rack-type, and double pinion-type [1, 2].
Some aspects have to be considered during the design of the
EPAS drive systems: reliability, performance, thermal and
acoustic behavior, energy efficiency and cost. These
applications require high performance motors with high
torque/volume ratio, low inertia, high dynamics, low torque
pulsations and low radial forces. Different types of electrical
motors have been proposed and used for EPAS applications so
far. The first "all electric" power-steering system used a brush
DC motor placed concentrically around the rack [1]. But the
DC motor has some unattractive attributes, such as brush
arcing and commutator/brush friction, resulting in wear, lower
overall power density and EMI problems.
As a result, the robust induction motor was chosen to replace
brush DC motor in EPAS applications. The difficulties
associated with extracting heat from the rotor, efficiency
problems over a wide speed range if high slip is required, long
end-turns, and a more expensive manufacturing process due to
the distribution of windings are some of the unattractive
features of the induction machine that made researchers look
for other solutions. The permanent magnet synchronous
machine (PMSM) represents a competitive solution for the
considered application. High torque density, low cogging
torque, small torque ripple and high energy efficiency are the
key assets of PMSMs for this kind of application [2].
However, high power density permanent magnets are
extremely sensitive to the temperature increase, the stability
temperature limit being well below 120°C. This is to be taken
into consideration since in automotive applications the ambient
temperature limits are from -40°C up to 125°C and more. The
PMSMs also raise concerns about failure modes and, without
an adequate design and control, can produce quite important
cogging torques.
Switched reluctance machines (SRMs) are easy to construct
and contain no permanent magnets, resulting in excellent high-
temperature performance and high reliability. Due to the phase
independence, SRMs are able to operate under partial phase
failure conditions and therefore are a competitive candidate for
fault tolerant EPAS applications, where safety is the most
important consideration.
The analysis of the specifications for automotive EPAS
reveals also some other interesting motor challenges: given
overall dimension, low supply voltage, wide range of ambient
temperature, and low motor torque ripple.
The fault tolerance of an EPAS system can be focused either
on the power electronic converter, or on the electrical machine.
Concerning the latter, the effort can be oriented towards the
windings and the number of phases, without increasing the
complexity of the drive. The minimization of the torque ripple
993 978-1-4244-4252-2/09/$25.00 ©2009 IEEE