www.afm-journal.de
FULL PAPER
©
2011 WILEY-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co. KGaA, Weinheim 2744
www.MaterialsViews.com
wileyonlinelibrary.com Adv. Funct. Mater. 2011, 21, 2744–2753
Dan Credgington,* Rick Hamilton, Pedro Atienzar, Jenny Nelson, and James R. Durrant*
1. Introduction
With power conversion efficiencies (PCEs) approaching 8% in
laboratory-scale devices,
[1]
bulk-heterojunction (BHJ) organic
photovoltaics (OPVs) comprising phase-separated blends of
electron-donating and electron-accepting
organic species have begun to demon-
strate their potential as a route to flexible,
low cost microgeneration. The underlying
physical processes determining the opera-
tion and efficiency of BHJ solar cells have
been shown to be substantively different
from those of their inorganic counter-
parts, and many questions on the origin
of device behaviour are still not fully
resolved. One aspect of organic solar cell
performance which has been studied
extensively in recent years is the origin
of the open-circuit voltage ( V
OC
), the
voltage developed across an illuminated
cell’s electrodes when no external current
flows between them.
[2–11]
While it is clear
that the choice of active layer materials
has a significant effect on open-circuit
voltage for a given cell,
[8,10,12,13]
of similar
importance are the detailed processing
conditions
[14]
and choice of cell structure,
including the selection of suitable device
electrodes.
[6,11,15]
These can lead to consid-
erable variations in V
OC
, particularly when
the optimal processing conditions for a
new material are still under investigation.
Here, we demonstrate that variations in
open-circuit voltage arising from differ-
ences in fabrication conditions for a large
set of BHJ solar cells fabricated from a single polymer:fullerene
pair are predominantly determined by variations in non-
geminate recombination losses in the device. Significant vari-
ations in the recombination coefficient and charge densities in
the photoactive layer lead to concomitant variations in open-
circuit voltage between cells fabricated from nominally identical
active layer materials.
Several approaches have previously been explored to explain
the origin of V
OC
in BHJ solar cells, with the simplest being the
MIM (metal–insulator–metal) model. In this interpretation, at
open-circuit, electron and hole polarons generated in the device
drift to opposite electrodes under the influence of a built-in
field, until sufficient charge accumulates to negate that field (or
rather, reduce it sufficiently such that residual drift is balanced
by back-diffusion). Under these conditions, V
OC
scales with the
difference between the work functions of the two electrodes.
MIM behaviour has been observed in BHJ solar cells for the
Non-Geminate Recombination as the Primary Determinant
of Open-Circuit Voltage in Polythiophene:Fullerene
Blend Solar Cells: an Analysis of the Influence of Device
Processing Conditions
The physical origin of the open-circuit voltage in bulk heterojunction solar
cells is still not well understood. While significant evidence exists to indicate
that the open-circuit voltage is limited by the molecular orbital energies of
the heterojunction components, it is clear that this picture is not sufficient to
explain the significant variations which often occur between cells fabricated
from the same heterojunction components. We present here an analysis of
the variation in open-circuit voltage between 0.4–0.65 V observed for a range
of P3HT/PCBM solar cells where device deposition conditions, electrode
structure, active-layer thickness and device polarity are varied. The analysis
quantifies non-geminate recombination losses of dissociated carriers in these
cells, measured under device operating conditions. It is found that at open-
circuit, losses due to non-geminate recombination are sufficiently large that
other loss pathways may effectively be neglected. Variations in open-circuit
voltage between different devices are shown to arise from differences in the
rate coefficient for non-geminate recombination, and from differences in the
charge densities in the photoactive layer of the device. The origin of these
differences is discussed, particularly with regard to variations in film micro-
structure. By separately quantifying these differences in rate coefficient and
charge density, and by application of a simple physical model based upon the
assumption that open-circuit is reached when the flux of charge photogenera-
tion is matched by the flux of non-geminate recombination, we are able to
calculate correctly the open-circuit voltage for all the cells studied to within an
accuracy of ±5 mV.
DOI: 10.1002/adfm.201100225
Dr. D. Credgington, Dr. R. Hamilton, Prof. J. R. Durrant
Centre for Plastic Electronics
Department of Chemistry
Imperial College London
London, SW7 2AZ, UK
E-mail: d.credgington@imperial.ac.uk; j.durrant@imperial.ac.uk
Dr. P. Atienzar, Prof. J. Nelson
Centre for Plastic Electronics
Department of Physics
Imperial College London
London, SW7 2AZ, UK