Prognostic Role of Heart Rate Variability
in Patients With a Recent Acute
Myocardial Infarction
Gaetano Antonio Lanza, MD, Vincenzo Guido, MD, M. Marco Galeazzi, MD,
Marina Mustilli, MD, Rosaria Natali, MD, Carolina Ierardi, MD, Caterina Milici, MD,
Francesco Burzotta, MD, Vincenzo Pasceri, MD, Francesco Tomassini, MD,
Alessandro Lupi, MD, and Attilio Maseri, MD
A low heart rate variability (HRV) has been shown to be
a powerful predictor of cardiac events in patients sur-
viving an acute myocardial infarction (MI), but it is not
clear yet which among the HRV parameters has the best
predictive value. Time domain and frequency domain
HRV was assessed on 24-hour predischarge Holter re-
cording of 239 patients with a recent MI. Patients were
followed up for 6 to 54 months (median 28), during
which 26 deaths (11%) occurred, 19 of which were
cardiac in origin and 12 were sudden. Most HRVs did
not show any difference between patients with or with-
out mortality end points, but the average low-frequency
and low-frequency/high-frequency ratio was lower in
patients with events. However, when dichotomized ac-
cording to cut points that maximized the risk of sudden
death, several HRVs were significantly predictive of clin-
ical end points. Overall, the mean of the standard devi-
ations of all RR intervals for all 5-minute segments and
the standard deviation of the mean RR intervals for all
5-minute segments were the time domain variables most
significantly associated with mortality end points,
whereas very low frequency was the most predictive
frequency domain variable. Compared with the best
time domain variables, very low frequency showed a
better sensitivity (0.27 to 0.42 vs 0.19 to 0.33) for end
points with only a small loss in specificity (0.92 vs 0.96).
On multivariate Cox proportional analysis, a left ven-
tricular ejection fraction <40% and a number of ventric-
ular premature beats >10/hour were the most powerful
independent predictors for all end points, whereas no
HRV was independently associated with the events. A
low frequency/high frequency ratio <1.05 only had a
borderline association with sudden death (RR 2.86,
p 0.076). Our data show a strong association be-
tween HRV and mortality in patients surviving a recent
MI, with a slight better sensitivity of frequency domain
analysis. In our study, however, HRV did not add inde-
pendent prognostic information to more classic prognos-
tic variables (e.g., left ventricular function and ventricu-
lar arrhythmias). 1998 by Excerpta Medica, Inc.
(Am J Cardiol 1998;82:1323–1328)
A
reduced variability of RR intervals (heart rate
variability [HRV]) has been shown to be a pow-
erful predictor of subsequent mortality in patients
surviving an acute myocardial infarction (MI).
Whereas several studies have demonstrated a strong
association of low HRV in the time domain with
mortality,
1–5
there are few data regarding the prognos-
tic value of frequency domain HRV analysis in this
clinical setting.
6–8
Furthermore, it is not yet clear
which among the most frequently used HRVs has the
strongest usefulness in the risk assessment of patients
with acute MI. Thus, in this study we investigated the
value of the most widely used time- and frequency
domain HRV variables in predicting total and cardiac
mortality (both global and sudden) in a population of
patients surviving an acute MI.
METHODS
Patients: Consecutive patients admitted to our cor-
onary care unit because of acute MI and who under-
went Holter monitoring before hospital discharge
were eligible for the study. Acute MI was diagnosed
according to typical prolonged chest pain (30 min-
utes) with significant ST segment and/or T-wave
changes, followed by typical elevation of total creat-
ine kinase and its MB isoform, with (Q-wave MI) or
without (non–Q-wave MI) the subsequent appearance
of diagnostic Q waves on the standard electrocardio-
gram.
Of the 364 patients eligible for the study, 125
(34%) were excluded because of 1 of the following
exclusion criteria: atrial fibrillation, frequent su-
praventricular ectopic beats, pacemaker rhythm, asso-
ciated significant valvular heart disease, Holter re-
cordings lasting 20 hours or with technical defi-
ciences resulting in unreliable analysis, inability of
patients to be followed up.
The final study population consisted of 239 pa-
tients. The following variables were recorded for each
patient: age, gender, MI location, history of previous
MI, diabetes, hypertension, thrombolytic therapy, pre-
discharge left ventricular ejection fraction as assessed
by 2-dimensional echocardiography, and drug therapy
at the time of Holter monitoring.
Holter monitoring: All patients underwent 24-hour
Holter recording 5 to 20 days after MI (median 7),
From the Istituto di Cardiologia Universita’ Cattolica del S. Cuore,
Rome, Italy. Manuscript received March 31, 1998; revised manu-
script received and accepted July 13, 1998.
Address for reprints: Gaetano A. Lanza, MD, Istituto di Cardiolo-
gia, Universita’ Cattolica del S. Cuore, L.go A. Gemelli, 8, 00168
Roma, Italy.
1323 ©1998 by Excerpta Medica, Inc. 0002-9149/98/$19.00
All rights reserved. PII S0002-9149(98)00635-3