Support, sensitivity,
satisfaction: Filipino, Turkish
and Vietnamese women's
experiences of postnatal
hospital stay
Jane Yelland, Rhonda Small, Judith Lumley,
Pranee Liamputtong Rice, Valerie Cotronei
and Rosemary Warren
Jane Yelland
RN, BAppSc,Research
Fellow,
Rhonda Small
BA, Grad Dip Epid.,
Research Fellow,
|udith Lumley
PhD, FAFPHM, Director,
Valerie Cotronei
BA, Vacation Student,
Rosemary Warren
RN, RM, BA, Vacation
Student,
Centre for the Study of
Mothers' and Children's
Health, La Trobe
University, Locked Bag 6,
Post Office, Carlton South,
Victoria 3053, Australia
Pranee Liamputtong Rice
PhD, Lecturer, School of
Public Health, La Trobe
University, Bundoora
Victoria 3083, Australia
(Correspondence to JY)
Manuscript accepted
21 February 1998
Objective: to assess Filipino, Turkish and Vietnamese women's views about their care
during the postnatal hospital stay.
Design: interviews were conducted with recent mothers in the language of the women's
choice, 6-9 months after birth, by three bilingual interviewers.
Participants: three hundred and eighteen women born in the Phillipines (107), Turkey (107)
and Vietnam (I 04) who had migrated to Australia
Setting: women were recruited from the postnatal wards of three maternity teaching
hospitals in Helbourne, Australia, and interviewed at home.
Findings: overall satisfaction with care was low, and one in three women left hospital
feeling that they required more support and assistance with both baby care and their
own personal needs. The method of baby feeding varied between the groups, with
women giving some insight into the reason for their choice. A significant minority
wanted more help with feeding, irrespective of the method. The need for rest was a
recurrent theme, with women stating that staff's attitudes to individual preferences,
coupled with lack of assistance, made this difficult. The majority of comments women
made regarding their postnatal stay focused on the attitude and behaviour of staff and
about routine aspects of care. Issues related to culture and cultural practices were not of
primary concern to women.
Conclusion: maternity services need to consider ways in which care can focus on the
individual needs and preferences of women.
INTRODUCTION
Most societies recognise that women need both
emotional support and practical help in the days
following childbirth. In Australia, the postnatal
hospital stay is promoted as an opportunity for
women to rest and recuperate following birth and to
receive guidance, support and information on baby
care (Lumley et al 1990). This period of time can be
both exciting and harrowing (Oakley 1981, Moss et
al 1987) as women adjust physically and emotion-
ally to the early days of motherhood.
In 1995 in Victoria, Australia 24.6 % of confine-
ments were to women who were born overseas (The
Consultative Council on Obstetric and Paediatric
Mortality and Morbidity 1995). Of these, 73.5%
were women who were born in non-English speak-
ing countries.
Despite this, only a small number of Australian
studies have commented on the experiences of
Midwifery(1998) 14, 144-154 © 1998 HarcourtBrace & Co. Ltd