Detection and Quantitation of Genetically Modified Maize
(Bt-176 Transgenic Maize) by Applying Ligation Detection
Reaction and Universal Array Technology
ROBERTA BORDONI,ALESSANDRA MEZZELANI,CLARISSA CONSOLANDI,
ANDREA FROSINI,ERMANNO RIZZI,BIANCA CASTIGLIONI,CLAUDIA SALATI,
NELSON MARMIROLI,ROSANGELA MARCHELLI,LUIGI ROSSI BERNARDI,
CRISTINA BATTAGLIA, AND GIANLUCA DE BELLIS*
Consiglio Nazionale delle Ricerche, Istituto di Tecnologie Biomediche and Dipartimento di Scienze e
Tecnologie Biomediche, Universita ` degli Studi di Milano, LITA, Via F.lli Cervi,
93 20090 Segrate (MI), Italy
We have applied the ligation detection reaction (LDR) combined with a universal array approach to
the detection and quantitation of the polymerase chain reaction (PCR) amplified cry1A(b) gene from
Bt-176 transgenic maize. We demonstrated excellent specificity and high sensitivity. Down to 0.5
fmol (nearly 60 pg) of PCR amplified transgenic material was inequivocally detected with excellent
linearity within the 0.1-2.0% range with respect to wild-type maize. We suggest the feasibility of
extending the LDR/universal array format to detect in parallel several transgenic sequences that are
being developed for food applications.
KEYWORDS: Genetically modified organisms; GMOs; polymerase chain reaction; PCR; ligation detection
reaction; LDR; universal array; Bt-176 transgenic maize
INTRODUCTION
Identification of genetically modified organisms (GMOs) in
food is becoming an issue of great interest. The introduction in
the market of GMO products raises social and ethical concerns,
and the European Union has dictated several directives and
regulations regarding their liberation and commercialization.
This includes the Novel Food Regulation (258/97/CE) for
labeling of GMO-containing food-stuff and the Directive 49/
2000, which establishes that under 1% of approved GMOs,
labeling is no longer necessary as long as their presence in the
product is accidental or technically unavoidable (1). GMOs
could be detected by either polymerase chain reaction (PCR),
for direct detection of the transgenic DNA, or immunological
methods, for detection of proteins coded by the transgenic
sequences. Because of their higher reliability and sensitivity and
the higher stability of DNA over proteins, PCR methods are
usually preferred (2).
PCR has been applied to the detection of FLAVR SAVR
tomato (3), Roundup Ready soybean (4, 5), Bt-maize (6), and
gbss-antisense transgene potatoes (7). Sequence confirmation
of PCR amplicons by proper methods is mandatory to avoid
false positives.
With the increasing number of GMOs that are being
developed for food application, the ability to detect several
transgenes in a single reaction becomes an important feature of
any detection method (8). Therefore, highly automated and
parallel detection systems for the identification of GMO in foods
are required. Recently microarray technology has been proposed
for several applications in DNA analysis, allowing for the
detection of different nucleic acid targets at once.
Rudi et al. (9) recently proposed a microarray approach to
GMO detection in food by multiplex PCR amplification, GMO
specific primer extension, and hybridization of the resulting
labeled templates to an oligonucleotide microarray. A different
approach based on a universal array could be considered.
Universal arrays consist of a set of synthetic oligonucleotides
named ZipCodes (10) or Tags (11) of similar thermodynamic
characteristics (melting temperature) but very different in
sequence. Their sequences are totally unrelated to those under
scrutiny. The ligation detection reaction has been proposed by
Gerry et al. (10) in combination with a demultiplexing universal
array as a powerful tool for sequence discrimination. This
procedure requires the design of two adjacent probes specific
for each target sequence. The discriminating oligo is 5′
fluorescently labeled, while the 5′ phosphorylated common
probe brings a 3′ unique and artificial sequence named cZip-
Code, which is complementary to a ZipCode sequence included
within the universal array. These oligos hybridize consecutively
along the template, and a thermostable DNA ligase joins their
ends linking the fluorescent label with a specific cZipCode. This
reaction can be cycled to gain in sensitivity. The resulting
products are hybridized onto the universal array where the
* To whom correspondence should be addressed. Telephone: +39022-
6422764. Telefax: +390226422770. E-mail: gianluca.debellis@itb.cnr.it.
J. Agric. Food Chem. 2004, 52, 1049-1054 1049
10.1021/jf034871e CCC: $27.50 © 2004 American Chemical Society
Published on Web 02/04/2004