Highly Reversible Mg Insertion in Nanostructured Bi for Mg Ion
Batteries
Yuyan Shao,* Meng Gu, Xiaolin Li, Zimin Nie, Pengjian Zuo, Guosheng Li, Tianbiao Liu, Jie Xiao,
Yingwen Cheng, Chongmin Wang, Ji-Guang Zhang, and Jun Liu*
Pacific Northwest National Laboratory, Richland, Washington 99352, United States
* S Supporting Information
ABSTRACT: Rechargeable magnesium batteries have at-
tracted wide attention for energy storage. Currently, most
studies focus on Mg metal as the anode, but this approach is
still limited by the properties of the electrolyte and poor
control of the Mg plating/stripping processes. This paper
reports the synthesis and application of Bi nanotubes as a high-
performance anode material for rechargeable Mg ion batteries.
The nanostructured Bi anode delivers a high reversible specific
capacity (350 mAh/g
Bi
or 3430 mAh/cm
3
Bi
), excellent stability,
and high Coulombic efficiency (95% initial and very close to
100% afterward). The good performance is attributed to the
unique properties of in situ formed, interconnected nano-
porous bismuth. Such nanostructures can effectively accom-
modate the large volume change without losing electric contact and significantly reduce diffusion length for Mg
2+
. Significantly,
the nanostructured Bi anode can be used with conventional electrolytes which will open new opportunities to study Mg ion
battery chemistry and further improve its properties.
KEYWORDS: Energy storage, magnesium battery, anode, bismuth nanotube, insertion
M
agnesium-based batteries have attracted increasing
interest in the past few years.
1-5
This technology uses
earth-abundant Mg element with a bivalent charge carrier Mg
2+
which could potentially lead to low cost and high energy
density. To date, most efforts in this field have been focused on
Mg metal anode based rechargeable Mg battery
1,4
by
developing high-performance electrolytes
5-9
and catho-
des.
2,10-14
The use of Mg metal is still limited by the properties
of the electrolyte and the poor control of the electrochemical
reaction at the metal-electrolyte interfaces.
1,4
Conventional
electrolytes made by mixing simple Mg salts (e.g., Mg(ClO
4
)
2
)
and nonaqueous solvents (e.g., propylene carbonate), as widely
used in lithium batteries,
15
do not produce reversible plating/
stripping of Mg.
16,17
This is likely due to a nonconductive layer
formed on Mg surface in these conventional electrolytes.
18
Specially designed and synthesized electrolytes are needed for
Mg metal anode.
4,19
So far, there are only a limited number of
electrolytes that show reversible Mg plating/stripping.
5-7,20
The synthesis of these electrolytes usually requires strictly
controlled chemical processes.
5,6,9
Low electrochemical stable
window,
1,4,21
the corrosive nature of the electrolytes
21-24
and
high volatility, usually involving solvents such as tetrahydrofur-
an (THF),
4,5,7,9
are also significant limiting factors. A new
approach that does not rely on the special electrolytes
associated with Mg plating/stripping could lead to significant
breakthroughs in this field.
The revolution and large scale commercialization of Li-ion
batteries were facilitated by the successful development of the
intercalation and insertion materials for both cathode and
anode.
25-31
Significant progresses have been made in the
synthesis, understanding and utilization of such intercalation
and insertion materials.
27,32-35
Extensive knowledge has been
gained on the chemistry, properties and optimization of
electrolytes for intercalation and insertion electrode materi-
als.
15,36
If such mechanisms can be successfully used in Mg
chemistry, the battery may not be limited by the Mg plating/
stripping reaction and the special electrolytes associated with
such reactions. Instead, conventional electrolytes commonly
used in Li-ion batteries could be used. The new approach will
significantly widen the choices of the electrode and electrolyte
materials, provide great opportunity to gain better under-
standing of the reaction mechanisms involved Mg chemistry,
and may lead to new cost-effective materials and technologies.
Recently, a few groups studied bismuth and tin as the anode
materials for rechargeable Mg-ion batteries.
37-39
These
materials still have poor rate performance and fast capacity
fading upon cycling. Taking tin as an example, only ∼20% of its
theoretical capacity was obtained at the rate C/20 (discharge in
20 h), and the capacity fading is fast.
38
The Coulombic
Received: October 16, 2013
Revised: November 20, 2013
Published: November 26, 2013
Letter
pubs.acs.org/NanoLett
© 2013 American Chemical Society 255 dx.doi.org/10.1021/nl403874y | Nano Lett. 2014, 14, 255-260