Pergamon
Neuropsychologia, Vol. 33, No. 10, pp. 1225-1242,1995
Copyright © 1995Elsevier Science Ltd
Printedin GreatBritain.All rightsreserved
0028-3932/95 $9.50 + 0.00
0028-3932(95)00039-9
THE EMERGENCE OF THE CAPACITY TO NAME LEFT VISUAL
FIELD STIMULI IN A CALLOSOTOMY PATIENT:
IMPLICATIONS FOR FUNCTIONAL PLASTICITY
KATHLEEN BAYNES,* C. MARK WESSINGER, ROBERT FENDRICH and
MICHAEL S. GAZZANIGA
Center for Neuroscience, University of California, Davis, CA 95616, U.S.A.
(Received 16 December 1993; accepted 17 February 1995)
Abstraet--Callosotomized patient J.W. has a well-documented history of right hemisphere
language abilities, including an auditory and visual lexical-semantic system with limited phonology
and syntax. However, J.W. has not previously exhibited the ability to name stimuli presented to the
left visual field (LVF). We report the emergence of this ability. Experiments were conducted in
which pictures and text were presented to the subject's LVF using retinal stabilization techniques to
ensure lateralization. J.W. was able to correctly name approximately one-quarter of these stimuli
under a variety of presentation conditions. The newly developed ability to respond verbally to
complex LVF stimuli can be the result of (1) enhanced inter-hemispberic transfer of information via
sub-cortical pathways, (2) sophisticated cross cueing strategies, or (3) control of motor speech in
the right hemisphere. Although it appears that the first two mechanisms make a contribution to
J.W.'s LVF naming performance, accuracy for unpredictable stimulus sets and the error patterns
require acknowledgement that control of motor speech is now available to the right hemisphere.
Key Words: right hemisphere language; hemispheric differences; laterality.
INTRODUCTION
The study of callosotomy and commissurotomyt patients has yielded striking
documentation of the existence of independent, self-determined cognitive systems
operating within a single being [13]. Of special interest is investigation of the differing
language abilities in the disconnected left and right hemispheres. In general, the left
hemisphere is language dominant and evidence of right hemisphere language capacity is
absent in most patients. The studies that explore right hemisphere language in this
population have concentrated on seven patients that have demonstrated this ability [4, 14,
31].
The insight that the disconnected right hemisphere was characteristically mute and
required a non-verbal means of expression to respond was what first permitted
observation of right hemisphere cognition in these patients [23]. However, subsequent
*To whom all correspondence should be addressed.
tCommissurotomy and callosotomy procedures are surgical interventions which have been employed to limit
interhemispheric spread of seizure activity in patients who suffer from intractable epilepsy. A eommissurotomy
includes resection of the anterior commissure as well as the corpus callosum; a callosotomy entails severing the
corpus callosum only.
1225