Plant and Soil 211: 111–119, 1999.
© 1999 Kluwer Academic Publishers. Printed in the Netherlands.
111
Dynamics of phosphorus in the rhizosphere of maize and rape grown on
synthetic, phosphated calcite and goethite
I. Bertrand, P. Hinsinger
∗
, B. Jaillard and J.C. Arvieu
UFR de Science du Sol, Institut National de la Recherche Agronomique, place Pierre Viala, F-34060Montpellier
cedex 2, France
Received 29 April 1998. Accepted in revised form 16 Sepember 1998
Key words: calcite, goethite, maize, phosphate, H
+
release, Brassica napus L., Zea Mays L.
Abstract
In calcareous soils the dynamics of phosphorus is controlled by calcite and iron oxides such as goethite which
strongly retain P and consequently maintain low P concentrations in soil solution. Plants can drastically change
chemical conditions in the rhizosphere, in particular by releasing H
+
or OH
−
or by excreting organic anions.
By modifying the dissolution/precipitation and desorption/adsorption equilibria, roots can influence the mobility
of soil P. The aim of this work was to test whether H
+
or OH
−
release can induce the mobilization of P in the
rhizosphere of maize and rape supplied with NO
3
-N or NH
4
-N and grown on synthetic phosphated calcite or
goethite as sole source of P. With P-calcite, the mobilization of P was generally related to the acidification of the
rhizosphere. With P-goethite, rhizosphere acidification induced some increase of DTPA-extractable Fe and hence
dissolution of goethite. Rhizosphere P was concomitantly depleted but the mechanisms involved are less clear. The
difference in behavior of the two species is discussed.
Introduction
The dynamics of phosphorus in calcareous environ-
ments is largely controlled by two major mineral
components that are iron oxides and calcium carbon-
ates (Matar et al., 1992). Calcium carbonates, which
are largely dominated by calcite, can immobilize sub-
stantial amounts of phosphate ions by both adsorption
processes and precipitation of various types of calcium
phosphates (Arvieu and Bouvier, 1980; Freeman and
Rowell, 1981). Iron oxides including crystalline iron
oxyhydroxides such as goethite can also contribute a
large proportion of the sorption of P by calcareous
soils (Matar et al., 1992; Ryan et al., 1985). Because
of these strong interactions with the soil solid phase,
phosphate concentrations in the soil solution of cal-
careous soils are often very low. To cope with such
adverse conditions, plants have evolved various mech-
anisms that influence the chemical conditions at the
∗
Fax No: +33 0467632614. E-mail: hinsinger@enjam.inra.fr
root-soil interface and enhance the solubilization of
soil P in the rhizosphere (e.g. Hinsinger, 1998). For
the acquisition of inorganic P, previous works have
shown that the mechanisms that are likely to operate
are related to release of protons and to the excre-
tion of organic anions by roots (Hinsinger and Gilkes,
1996; Hinsinger, 1998). Some authors have moreover
shown that some species like oilseed rape respond to
P-deficiency by an enhanced release of either protons
(Moorby et al., 1988) or organic anions (Hoffland et
al., 1989). These phenomena may induce some dis-
solution of both iron oxides and calcium carbonate or
phosphate. In addition, ligand exchange reactions may
occur and organic anions may be directly involved in
the release of sorbed P into soil solution (Gerke et al.,
1994). Gahoonia et al. (1992) have also suggested that
hydroxyl or bicarbonate ions excreted by species such
as ryegrass when fed with nitrate may be responsible
for some desorption of P from iron oxide surfaces.
The aim of this work was to test whether proton or
hydroxyl release can induce the mobilization of P in
7793IS.tex; 17/09/1999; 12:36; p.1
DISK: CP: PIPS No.: 191388 (plsokap:bio2fam) v.1.15