Plant and Soil 260: 19–32, 2004.
© 2004 Kluwer Academic Publishers. Printed in the Netherlands.
19
Zinc mobilisation from a contaminated soil by three genotypes of tobacco
as affected by soil and rhizosphere pH
Nancy Loosemore, Anne Straczek, Philippe Hinsinger & Benoît Jaillard
1
Institut National de la Recherche Agronomique, UMR INRA – ENSAM Rhizosph` ere & Symbiose, 2 Place Pierre
Viala, 34060 Montpellier Cedex 2, France
1
Corresponding author
∗
Received 23 January 2003. Accepted in revised form 11 July 2003
Key words: exchangeable cations, pH, rhizosphere, tobacco, zinc
Abstract
The aim of this research was to evaluate the effect of soil and rhizosphere pH on the mobilisation of Zn by various
tobacco genotypes. One-month-old tobacco plants were grown for 8 days on top of a thin layer of an arable soil that
had been sampled near a Zn smelter. A range of rhizosphere pH values was obtained either by growing nitrate-fed
tobacco on top of the soil amended with various amounts of acid or lime, or by growing tobacco on top of the
unamended soil with nitrate or ammonium supply. In the latter case, we used three genotypes that were assumed
to differ in their ability to accumulate Zn or acidify the rhizosphere and, hence, mobilise soil Zn. In spite of the
moderate level of contamination of the soil, tobacco took up substantial amounts of soil Zn. No difference was
found between the three genotypes. Exchangeable Zn steeply increased with decreasing soil pH, which could be
adequately modelled with a simple model. Whatever the source of nitrogen supplied, a significant acidification
occurred in the rhizosphere. This explains why the observed Zn mobilisation was larger than expected on the basis
of bulk soil pH values. Taking account of the change of pH induced by tobacco roots is thus of prime importance
for better predicting the actual amount of exchangeable Zn in the rhizosphere and, thereafter the bioavailability of
soil Zn.
Abbreviations: A1 – control genotype of tobacco (wild-type genotype neutrally transformed with a CAMV 35S
promoter-GUS construct); C5 – genotype of tobacco genetically transformed to over-accumulate the Fe storage
protein ferritin in the cytoplasm; CEC – cation exchange capacity; CAMV – cauliflower mosaic virus; DW –
dry weight; Fe-EDTA – ethylene-diamine-tetra-acetic acid iron
III
sodium salt; GUS – β -D-glucuronidase (EC
3.2.1.31); H – genotype of tobacco genetically transformed to over-accumulate the H
+
-ATPase protein in roots;
H
+
-ATPase – proton-translocating P-type ATPase (EC 3.6.3.6); pH
cobalthexamine
– soil pH in cobalthexamine extract
Introduction
Availability of Zn for plants depends in the first place
on forms under which the element occurs in soil. As
most metals, soil Zn can be (i) dissolved in soil solu-
tion as various species of soluble Zn, (ii) bound as
exchangeable Zn to negatively charged compounds,
(iii) adsorbed onto metal oxides, (iv) complexed by
organic matter, or (v) included as insoluble Zn in
∗
FAX No: +33-467-632-614.
E-mail: benoit.jaillard@ensam.inra.fr
the crystalline lattice of clay minerals or metal ox-
ides (Kiekens, 1995). The distribution of Zn among
these various soil compartments determines its solu-
bility, and thereby its availability. The solubility of Zn
varies considerably according to soil composition and
properties. For instance, Lorenz et al. (1997) reported
that, in 10 European, contaminated topsoils, the solid-
solution partitioning K
d
ranged from 69 to 36 222 L
kg
−1
. In a critical review, Sauvé et al. (2000) compiled
K
d
values from 300 soils from 70 studies: K
d
ranged
from 1.4 to 320 000 L kg
−1
, with a mean of 11 615