ORIGINAL RESEARCH
Caught in the middle: Tensions around the
emergency department care of people with
advanced cancer
George A Jelinek,
1,2
Claudia H Marck,
1
Tracey J Weiland,
1,2
Jennifer Philip,
3,4
Mark Boughey,
3,4
Jennifer Weil
3
and Heather Lane
3
1
Emergency Practice Innovation Centre, St Vincent’s Hospital, Melbourne, Victoria, Australia,
2
Department of Medicine, The University of Melbourne, Melbourne, Victoria, Australia,
3
Palliative
Medicine, St Vincent’s Hospital, Melbourne, Victoria, Australia, and
4
Centre for Palliative Care,
The University of Melbourne, Melbourne, Victoria, Australia
Abstract
Background: People with advanced cancer frequently present to hospital EDs. International studies
report conflicting attitudes towards providing such care and difficulties with communica-
tion. The experience of Australian clinicians, however, is not described.
Objective: The present study aims to identify issues important to emergency, palliative care (PC) and
oncology clinical staff in managing people with advanced cancer presenting to EDs.
Methods: We qualitatively explored views of Australian clinicians working in emergency medicine,
PC and oncology, via focus groups at two major hospitals and two community PC services
in Melbourne, Victoria, and emergency clinicians from all other Australian states and
territories via semi-structured telephone interviews. Purposive sampling for both groups
ensured representation of experience, discipline and region of work. The focus groups and
interviews were audio-recorded, transcribed and a thematic analysis identified issues
important to participants.
Results: The overarching theme was EDs being ‘caught in the middle’ when providing care to
patients with advanced cancer in the physical environment (privacy, noise, lack of infor-
mation and delay and lack of defined pathways), the available resources (access block and
overcrowding, time pressures, competition with other emergencies, lack of alternatives)
and the roles and expectations of the staff providing care (seniority and comfort with dying,
views of dying in the ED, expertise and comfort in caring for those with advanced illness).
Conclusion: Despite limitations in the ED environment and resources, clinicians in oncology, PC and
emergency medicine support the important role the ED plays in providing the necessary
access and expertise for people with advanced cancer.
Key words: cancer, ED, oncology, palliative care.
Correspondence: Professor George A Jelinek, Emergency Practice Innovation Centre, St Vincent’s Hospital, Melbourne, Vic. 3045,
Australia. Email: george.jelinek@gmail.com, george.jelinek@svhm.org.au
George A Jelinek, MBBS, MD, DipDHM, FACEM, Director and Professorial Fellow; Claudia H Marck, BSc, MSc (Psych), MSc (Neuroscience),
Research Officer, PhD Candidate; Tracey J Weiland, BBSc (Hons), PhD, MAPS, Senior Research Fellow, Honorary Research Fellow; Jennifer Philip,
MBBS, PhD, MMed, FAChPM, GradDipPallMed, Co-Deputy Director of Centre for Palliative Care, Deputy Director of Palliative Medicine; Mark
Boughey, MBBS, BMedSc, DipPallMed, MPH, FAChPM, Co-Deputy Director of Centre for Palliative Care, Director of Palliative Medicine; Jennifer
Weil, MBBS (Hons), FRACP, FAChPM, Palliative Care Physician; Heather Lane, MBChB, FRACP, Research Fellow.
doi: 10.1111/1742-6723.12047 Emergency Medicine Australasia (2013) ••, ••–••
© 2013 The Authors
EMA © 2013 Australasian College for Emergency Medicine and Australasian Society for Emergency Medicine