EXAFS and XANES Investigation of the ETS-10 Microporous Titanosilicate
C. Prestipino,*
,²
P. L. Solari,
‡
and C. Lamberti
²
Department of Inorganic, Physical and Materials Chemistry and NIS Centre of Excellence, Via P. Giuria 7,
I-10125 Torino, Italy, and ESRF, rue J. Horowitz 6, BP 220 F-38043 Grenoble France
ReceiVed: January 11, 2005; In Final Form: March 16, 2005
In this work, we report state-of-the-art analysis of both Ti K-edge high-resolution XANES and EXAFS data
collected on the ETS-10 molecular sieve at the GILDA BM8 beamline of the ESRF facility. The interatomic
distances and the angles obtained in our EXAFS study are in fair agreement with the single-crystal XRD data
of Wang and Jacobson (Chem. Commun. 1999, 973) and with the recent ab initio periodic study of Damin et
al. (J. Phys. Chem. B 2004, 108, 1328) Differently from previous EXAFS work (J. Phys. Chem. 1996, 100,
449), our study supports a model of ETS-10 where the Ti atoms are bonded with two equivalent axial oxygen
atoms. This model is also able to reproduce the edge and the post-edge region of the XANES spectrum.
Conversely, the weak but well-defined pre-edge peak at 4971.3 eV can be explained only by assuming that
a fraction of Ti atoms are in a local geometry similar to that of the pentacoordinated Ti sites in the ETS-4
structure. These Ti atoms in ETS-10 should be the terminal of the -Ti-O-Ti-O-Ti- chains, of which the
actual number is strongly increased by the high crystal defectivity (Ti vacancies).
1. Introduction
Microporous titanosilicates have been of interest since the
discovery of important catalytic properties in titanium silicalite-1
(TS-1)
1
in oxidation and epoxidation reactions.
2-5
Among the
huge number of porous titanosilicates, ETS-10, first reported
by Kuznicki et al.,
6
occupies an important role owing to its
interesting chemical and physical properties. Because of the high
number of counterions present in the material, this molecular
sieve has been appreciated for its ionic exchange properties
6,7
and as a bare catalyst.
8
The much higher density of framework Ti(IV) centers with
respect to other titanosilicates, such as TS-1
2-5
or Ti-,
9
makes
ETS-10 a promising photocatalyst. Its advantage, with respect
to the classical high-surface-area TiO
2
oxide, consists of a three-
dimensional microporous structure that provides to ETS-10 a
shape selectivity toward the photodegradation of large organic
molecules.
10,11
Very recently, Llabre ´s i Xamena et al.
12
have
enhanced the activity in the shape-selectivity photocatalytic
degradation of large aromatic molecules of ETS-10 by controlled
defects production with fluoridic acid.
1.1. Brief Overview of the Structure of ETS-10. ETS-10
is a microporous titanosilicate with as-synthesized stoichiometry
of (Na, K)
2
TiSi
5
O
13
. For the first time, a convincing model of
the structure of the ETS-10 framework was proposed by
Anderson et al.
13
on the basis of a detailed high-resolution
electron microscopy (HREM), NMR, powder x-ray diffraction
(XRD), and structural modeling study. The same authors
successively reported a deeper discussion on the model else-
where.
14,15
However, up to 1999, the small-crystal size of
samples of ETS-10 has prevented accurate structure refinement
from single-crystal data, despite efforts to improve the syntheses.
After that time, Wang and Jacobson
16
have been able to grow
crystals with the necessary size to perform an accurate single-
crystal analysis. A much more accurate knowledge of the
structure of this material has consequently been achieved.
Its structure is formed by chains of corner-sharing TiO
6
octahedra linked to each other by tetrahedral SiO
4
units,
generating a large-pore (twelve-membered ring) and forming a
three-dimensional channel structure. Although the material is
crystalline, it is characterized by a high level of disorder, owing
to the possibility to build the crystal with different stacking
arrangements. In fact, although two “ideal” polymorphs of ETS-
10 have been identified, each formed by a particular stacking
arrangement of the (001) layer, in reality, the stacking sequence
is virtually random, resulting in an inherently disordered
structure. The two polymorphs are shown in Figure 1. Poly-
morph A (tetragonal, P4
1
or P4
3
) is formed by a zigzag stacking
of layers, while polymorph B (monoclinic, C2/c) results from
a diagonal stacking arrangement. The occurrence of stacking
defects has even been revealed by the electron microscopy
studies by Anderson et al.
13-15,17
This structural complexity has
prevented the use of standard approaches for the refinement of
the diffraction data, complicating the structure solving process.
One of the most interesting aspects of the ETS-10 structure
is its possibility to be thought of as a network of one-dimensional
TiO
2
semiconductor “quantum wires” embedded in a siliceous
insulating matrix. This idea was first introduced by Torino’s
group,
18,19
who by following this concept have been able to
explain the main features of the UV-vis spectrum of this
material. A serious understanding of the electronic properties
of ETS-10 came only later in the ab initio works of Bordiga et
al.
20
and of Damin et al.
21
1.2. Previous XAFS Study of ETS-10. Extended x-ray
absorption fine structure (EXAFS) spectroscopy is an important
tool for the characterization of new materials, particularly when
a degree of disorder is present in the structure. The first
application of this techniques on ETS-10 is the work of Davis
et al.,
22
which appeared in 1995, just one year after the structure
proposed by Anderson et al.
13
Successively, a more accurate
* Corresponding author: C. Prestipino, phone +39011-6707841; fax
+39011-6707855; e-mail carmelo.prestipino@unito.it.
²
Department of Inorganic, Physical and Materials Chemistry and NIS
Centre of Excellence.
‡
ESRF.
13132 J. Phys. Chem. B 2005, 109, 13132-13137
10.1021/jp050183h CCC: $30.25 © 2005 American Chemical Society
Published on Web 06/17/2005